Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast - "one of the best British & UK True Crime podcasts"
  • PODCAST
    • About the Host
    • About the Music
    • About the Sound
    • About the Research
    • Legal Disclaimer
  • Shop
  • Blog
  • Contact

Murder Mile UK True-Crime Podcast - #370: The Biggest Gamble (Mabel Tattershaw & Herbert Mills, Nottingham)

15/10/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
Eight time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
Picture
EPISODE THREE HUNDRED AND SEVENTY: On Friday the 3rd of August 1951, 49-year-old housewife, Mabel Tattershaw went out on a date with 19-year-old Herbert Mills. She was smitten with him, but as a chronic gambler who was obsessed with making an easy fortune, smashing the authorities and beating the odds, she had no idea that she would be the part of his plan to place the biggest gamble of his life. 
  • Location: 'The Jungle' nearby Woodthorpe Park, Nottingham. 
  • Date: Friday the 3rd of August 1951 post 9pm (murder)
  • Victims:Mabel Tattershaw
  • Culprit: Herbert Leonard Mills

SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cr4935yvy6vo
Southern Daily Echo Thu, Nov 22, 1951
Coventry Evening Telegraph Sat, Aug 25, 1951
Daily Mirror Thu, Sep 20, 1951
Hull Daily Mail Thu, Sep 20, 1951
Lincolnshire Echo Wed, Sep 19, 1951
The Daily Telegraph Thu, Sep 20, 1951
Worcester News Sat, Dec 08, 1951
Dorset Echo Tue, Dec 11, 1951
Daily Echo Wed, Sep 19, 1951
Evening News and Star (Late Final ed.) Tue, Dec 11, 1951
Sunderland Echo Thu, Sep 20, 1951
Leicester Mercury Thu, Nov 22, 1951
The Bolton News Tue, Dec 11, 1951
Evening Chronicle Wed, Nov 21, 1951
Bristol Evening World Thu, Sep 20, 1951
The Guardian Thu, Sep 20, 1951
The Birmingham Post Fri, Nov 23, 1951
Leicester Evening Mail Tue, Nov 20, 1951
The Argus Thu, Nov 22, 1951
The Guardian Journal Wed, Oct 13, 1965
The Guardian Journal Wed, Apr 04, 1973
Nottingham Evening News Sat, Sep 01, 1962
The Guardian Journal Wed, Apr 11, 1973
Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Friday, 10 August 1951
Belfast News-Letter Thursday, 23 August 1951
Daily Herald Wednesday, 21 November 1951
Daily Express Thursday, 23 August 1951
Bradford Observer Friday, 10 August 1951
Bexhill-on-Sea Observer Saturday, 1 September 1951
Bradford Observer Thursday, 23 August 1951
Daily Express - Tuesday, 14 August 1951
Daily Herald - Saturday, 11 August 1951
Leicester Evening Mail - Saturday, 1 September 1951
Bradford Observer - Saturday, 11 August 1951
Western Daily Press - Monday, 3 December 1951
Daily Herald - Monday, 20 August 1951
Aberdeen Evening Express - Saturday, 11 August 1951
Coventry Evening Telegraph - Saturday, 25 August 1951
Yorkshire Post and Leeds Intelligencer - Monday, 13 August 1951
Coventry Evening Telegraph - Wednesday, 19 September 1951
Leicester Evening Mail - Tuesday, 14 August 1951
Aberdeen Evening Express - Tuesday, 20 November 1951
Gloucester Citizen - Friday, 10 August 1951
Leicester Daily Mercury - Friday, 10 August 1951
Bristol Evening Post - Friday, 10 August 1951
Torbay Express and South Devon Echo - Friday, 10 August 1951
Grimsby Daily Telegraph - Friday, 10 August 1951
Staffordshire Sentinel - Friday, 10 August 1951
Scunthorpe Evening Telegraph - Friday, 10 August 1951
Huddersfield Daily Examiner - Friday, 10 August 1951

MUSIC:
  • Man in a Bag by Cult With No Name

UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT:

Welcome to Murder Mile: Unleashed.

(Engine) And I’m away. Goodbye London. Hello Britain. And as I cruise the UK’s canal network in my little boat, I shall bring you true crime cases from the cities, towns and villages I visit. This week, I’m in Nottingham, where a killer made a bet by confessing to a killing in the hope of winning big, but lost.

My name is Michael, I am your tour guide, and this is Murder Mile.

Episode 370: The Biggest Gamble.

The year was 1951, the war was over, but rationing was still in-force.

Mabel Tattershaw wasn’t a gambler, she didn’t have the luxury of a disposable income, as being  a 49-year-old housewife who was single-handedly raising her two daughters (Nora aged 14 and Lilian aged 16) while her husband was serving time in prison, the toughness of her life was etched across her tired face and body, being a woman of hard work and hardship whose life was a daily grind and struggle.

In the only photograph published of Mabel, she looks like the epitome of weary, as if the ravages of her life have drained and rung her dry; her short dark hair (often) tied in a headscarf like all she ever did was clean, her nails worn down from a lifetime of scrubbing, her limbs skinny from bad war-time nutrition, and with more wrinkles than she had teeth, Mabel looked a lot older than her years belied.

Described as quiet, kind and sociable, by day (as she no longer worked as a cleaner at Nottingham City Hospital) she earned a modest wage renting out rooms to lodgers - which may seem odd as it was said her daughters had been taken into care having been seduced by a former tenant – but she had to earn to live to eat, and with very little love, her only enjoyment was a pint at the pub or a trip to the cinema.

F Donal Barry for the Prosecution said “there could be little or no reason for destroying so inoffensive a person”, but someone did, and they would do it for the most cruel and arrogant of motives… a bet.

Thursday the 2nd of August 1951 was Mabel’s night to go to the cinema; she ate a frugal dinner, at 6pm she left her home on Longmead Drive in Woodthorpe two miles north of the city centre, and headed two streets north-east to The Roxy at 2 Ribblesdale Road, at the junction of Mansfield Road.

Accompanied by her friend and lodger, Lily Wilson, it’s uncertain what they watched, but out that week across the UK were Walt Disney’s ‘Alice in Wonderland’, ‘No Highway (in the Sky)’ an aviation thriller starring James Stewart, and the Ealing Comedy, ‘The Lavender Hill Mob’ starring Alec Guinness.

Sat together, her friend Lily Wilson later told Police, “I saw that Mabel was talking to the person next to her. He was a man, I can’t described him, I didn’t take much notice of him”, and that was how they met - by chance. When interviewed, the man confirmed this, “I went to the Roxy, someone sat down next to me. She commenced to speak to me. I do not remember what she was saying. I think it was an attempt to converse with me. She wished me to meet her… I did not wish to, but eventually agreed”.

Whether he initiated it or not will forever remain unknown, but downtrodden housewife, Mabel Tattershaw was getting attention from a young and handsome man, and she liked it.

But that night, he brutally murdered her…

…as the killer make the biggest gamble of his life.

Her date was Herbert Leonard Mills, a slim, well-groomed and nattily-dressed former dispatch clerk who, at just 19-year-old, was 30 years her junior, but many mistook him as older owing to his style and old-fashioned demeanour. Describing himself as “sensitive and poetic”, Herbert Mills was a loner, a dreamer who loved reading and writing prose and was never without a book of poems by Shelley.

Like Mabel, his life had its own hardships; his mother died when was a child, he lived unhappily with his father and stepmother, born with rickets – a deformity of the legs caused by severe malnutritian which meant he spent his childhood wearing leg irons and being bullied – he still walked with a limp, and struggling to hold down a dead-end job, he was now unemployed and living with his grandparents.

His only joy was gambling, he bet on horses and bragged that he made more than he lost - at one time claiming he had won £1500 (roughly £60,000 today) – and with nothing else in his life; no career, no girlfriend and no prospects, just a desire to win and (like most gamblers) a lot of misplaced confidence, far from looking like a coldblooded killer, those who met Herbert Mills saw him as nothing but a lonely exhibitionist obsessed with making an easy fortune, defying the authorities, and beating the odds.

That year, Mills would place the ultimate bet… and it began on a date with Mabel.

The next night, as agreed, Mills & Mabel met. Keen to make a good impression on this man she clearly liked, her lodgers said Mabel was a bag of nerves as she did her make-up and hair to make herself look younger, and dressed in a blue flowered dress, an old overcoat, grey stockings, crepe soled shoes and a coloured necklace of plastic beads, she left home at 5pm, never to be seen alive by her loved ones.

At the inquest, Mills wouldn’t deny meeting Mabel that night, but being the epitome of arrogance, he claimed “I expected her to be younger and (prettier)” having only seen each other in a dark cinema, but when two school friends saw him stepping out with a shabbily dressed woman, old enough to be his mother or even his grandmother, he admitted “I felt ashamed”. So did this make her disposable?

Mabel was reported missing by the morning, but across the next six days, with no-one believing that she was dead just absent, as she wasn’t depressed or suicidal, and with no witnesses to any foul play, the police regarded her as a missing person and the press reports spoke only of her disappearance.

As misinformation spread, possible sightings of Mabel gave her family a false hope; as police checked lodging houses in the Mansfield Road area to see if she had stayed over, and it was reported on Sunday 5th of August at 5pm – 45 hours after her death - Mabel was somehow seen two miles south at Forrest Recreation Ground with a man with a limp, but this one was “50 years old, medium build, moustached, a scar under his right eye, fresh complexion, in a black suit, black Trilby hat, blue tie and brown shoes”.

The man wasn’t Herbert Mills, just as the woman accompanying the limping moustachioed man was not Mabel Tattershaw, but with the Police not even considering this as a crime - where-as other killers would jump for joy that they had got away with the perfect murder - it proved problematic for Mills… 

…as having hidden Mabel’s body a little too well - to win his bet - he needed it to be found.

Given the timings, it’s unproven but likely that Mabel & Mills went to The Roxy that night as planned.

Afterwards, needing to lure this lonely lady who was charmed by the affections of this younger man, with dusk at 9:23pm, it was around this point that she willingly went with him to ‘the jungle’, a series of abandoned clay pits, disused brickyards and derelict orchards just to the side of nearby Woodthorpe Park. It may not seem like the most romantic of spots to take her, but this was a lover’s lane where it was known that couples went to kiss, cuddle and have sex, but MIlls had something else on his mind.

Under the quiet seclusion of twinkling stars and an almost new moon, with no-one about, Mills recalled “we walked up a path and branched off to the right”. Finding a comfortable spot on the grass “she took off her coat and lay down”. Seeing her coloured beaded necklace, “I asked her if I could have it. I was interested In plastic, or rather I thought it might interfere with my little crime and intentions. She broke the beads from her neck to give to me and I tied them. She was a very simple woman”.

The night was cold, she shivered, Mills recalled ”I covered her with her own coat, then my own coat”, which seemed like a kindly gesture, but it had a much darker motive. “She had her eyes closed” as if she was awaiting his tender kiss… but instead, he violently punched her in the face, again and again, smashing her nose, her teeth and her eye sockets, so her face was a swollen and unrecognisable mess of reds, blacks and purples, as blood burst through her pale skin, so no hint of white could be seen.

But Mills wasn’t finished with his murderous ‘masterpiece’. “I put on a pair of gloves”, and as she was still conscious, “I knelt my knees on her shoulders. She was trying to claw at me, but… the coats were placed so that she would not clutch or gather any threads within her fingernails. I was very pleased. I think I did it rather well”. And placing his gloved hands around her neck, arrogantly he would crow to the press and the police “the strangling itself was quite easily accomplished. I examined the contents of her pockets which I replaced. I slid her down the bank, then covered the coat over her, and left”.

Hidden down an eight-foot gully thick with dense nettles and thorns, he had too effectively disposed of her body, and although – in order for his plan to work - he needed to deny, then confess to killing her – he made it clear  “I had not interfered with her in any way”, as if the very thought disgusted him.

He walked back to his grandparents house and began to plan how he could profit from her death…

…but with Mabel only missing and the body not yet found, with the Police looking elsewhere and the press (as he said) writing ‘silly stories’ about a moustachioed man with a limp, he took his next big risk.

In court, Mabel was described by the Prosecution as “a woman of small significance… you may take the view that his mind was such that this reason appeared to him a significant motive”; a woman who he had no connection to and no-one would suspect, but later stating with a sense of self-importance, “I made a study of murders… I found the perfect victim for the perfect murder. No motive. No clues”. And for a lonely fantasist like Mills who loved attention, the press would give him what he wanted.

Thursday 9th of August at 11:30am, six days after her murder, from a phone-box, Mills called Norman Rae, chief reporter at the News of the World. He gave his name ‘Herbert Mills’, his job ‘poet’, said “I’ve found a body of a missing woman” asking “what price will you pay for information about her murder?”

Telling the interested reporter who regularly got calls from cranks as well as confessions from culprits, Mills said “it looked like the perfect murder, there were no clues”. Mills offered to sell the exclusive for £200 to £300, and as Rae recalled  “his scheme was that he would keep quiet about this until I had arrived in Nottingham with a photographer… so we could get some pictures of him at the crime scene”.

Smelling something rotten but also eager for the scoop, Rae recalled “I told him that the police should know at once. He refused to give information to the police and said he would try another newspaper. Mills indicated that whatever I said he had said, he would deny”, but having come to an agreement that if the News of the World were satisfied, they “would see him alright”, Rae called Nottingham CID, the phone-box was traced, and a few minutes later, Mills was met by Detective Sergeant Burrows.

He didn’t run and wasn’t arrested, as being merely a man who may have ‘found’ a body, showing them the plastic necklace Mabel had worn, Mills directed the detective (and later the press) to ‘the jungle’.

Part One of his plan was complete; ‘find’ the body. Part Two would be to make everyone suspect him of her murder. And with it all mapped out to the finest details, by Part Three, at his trial, Herbert Mills would be acquitted of the killing of Mabel Tattershaw, and then made famously wealthy by the press.

It was the biggest gamble of his life…

…and he felt it was a dead-cert that it would succeed.

That afternoon, Mills led detectives to the old orchard in ‘the jungle’, where he said on Wednesday the 8th of August about midday “I went to read poetry and pick raspberries”, and down an 8-foot gully, just as he had described it, there it was, the bloody body of Mabel Tattershaw, covered in her coat.

First he said he found the plastic necklace, then her pale white face, and stated “I was quite shocked. I recognised the woman”, but decided not to go to the Police, coldly stating “after thinking it over again, I thought it possible to sell the story to the News of the World… I felt he should profit from it”.

Found with her face pressed into the earth and her body concealed, officers had to hack through the thick bushes to see her face - a swollen mottled mix of reds and blacks - and with “severe head bruises Police think may have been caused by a blunt instrument”, this was a comment Mills would ridicule.

With it suspected she was killed not far from where she was found owing to the limited drag marks, sniffer dogs and officers with metal detectors scoured the area, and although a rusty shovel blade and a 3 foot of chain was found, Professor Tryhorn of the East Midlands Forensic Lab discounted them all.

The crime scene was processed, but it wouldn’t reveal its secrets for a few weeks.

That night in a cafe, Mills met Norman Rae the celebrated crime reporter, and Mills’ opening words were “did you bring the money?”. He had. £75 (£3000 today), which was worth it as Rae knew he was onto a winner. The next day, as the autopsy took place, on the front page of the News of the World was an exclusive featuring a photo of Mills beside the bushes pointing down the gully to where he said he had ‘found’ Mabel Tattershaw’s body - a murder he was now connected to, but not yet as her killer.

Keen to keep him for themselves as Mills promised them “another piece of sensational information which was worth a lot of money”, with the odds in their favour, the newspaper took him back to their offices in London, gave him £5 pocket money, took him to see the Festival of Britain, the sights of Soho and King’s Rhapsody on Shaftesbury Avenue  under the watchful protection of a reporter, and assuring them he wouldn’t speak to any other paper, he dropped two bombshells: he didn’t find the body on Wednesday 8th but a few days earlier, and confirming “without doubt, Mrs Tattershaw was strangled” - an odd statement to make as he claimed he hadn’t been within 8 feet of this well-hidden body. 

By Saturday the 11th of August, with the investigation headed-up by Detective Superintendent Percy Ellington of Nottingham CID, being bereft of the exclusive, the local papers incorrectly reported that Mabel was last seen alive two days after her murder being accompanied by a moustachioed man with a limp. And with Police struggling to hunt this man down, as well as two men she met at a darts match, so lopsided was the hunt for Mabel’s killer that they wondered if it was connected to the recent killing of 22 year old Florence Jean Weatherall at Hucknall, who was also found murdered on a lover’s lane, and who (with nothing better to do) the local press blamed on a fictional killer known as The Traveller.

The culprit was clearly Mills, but with the Police and the Press looking the wrong way, as Mills was just a 19-year-old, slightly shy, wannabe poet who had no criminal record or known motive to kill her, he wasn’t even considered as a viable suspect, so this chronic gambler decided to take his next big risk…

…to draw the suspicion for her murder onto himself.

On the morning of Sunday the 12th of August 1951, outside of Leenside Police Station on Nottingham’s Canal Street, wearing his best suit and with his hair neatly coiffured, Herbert Mills arrived by taxi to give evidence at the inquest. Before him, a wall of reporters from the national papers jostled for his attention, calling his name as if his celebrity status was already a given, as the paps took his picture.

Playing it coy, but blabbing too much like an eager killer desperate to spill the beans, Mills told them about how he had ‘found’ the body; “I went to the orchard to read poetry and pick raspberries, I wiped my mouth with a hanky as if the Police found it, they would think the stains were blood. It began to rain, I went to find shelter, I saw a necklace on the ground, and bending down to pick it up, I saw something white in a gully. It was a woman’s face. She was dead”. Asked why he had held onto to it, Mills replied “it had my fingerprints on it”, as if that was justification for his arrest. When asked “why didn’t you go to the police straight away?”, he grinned and said “there’s money to be made in murder”.

Playing with them like they were his toy, he told the press the Police were wrong that she had only been battered to death, he called the detectives ‘fools’, and lapping up the attention, he stated “I’ have put himself in an awkward situation with the Police, as I could be charged with murder”, but being so reluctant to talk to them in any detail, if they wanted to know more, it would cost them.
To John Perry of the Press Association he said “I know things no-one else does” but wouldn’t say what. To Alfred Connelly of the Daily Graphic, Mills said “I don’t mind being charged with murder, as when I’m acquitted, there will be a high price to pay”. And to Harry Longmuir of the Daily Mail, Mills he said “the Police won’t catch the killer this week, next, or the next…  they have no clue apart from a cheap little necklace”. The reporters regarded him as cocksure but rational, shy but clearly an exhibitionist.

And although hardly subtle, suspicion was now falling on Mills as the culprit…

…but his guilt needed to be proven before he could play the penultimate part of his trifecta.  

On Monday the 13th of August, Professor J M Webster, the Home Office Pathologist gave evidence at the inquest. Before the coroner, A G Rothers, he confirmed that she had been beaten about the head by fists (as reported), but she had died by manual strangulation, which Mills had stated five days prior. 

The Pathologist was asked “do you consider your examination would have been easier if you had been able to conduct a post-mortem on Wednesday?”, the day Mills claimed he found the body but didn’t report it, the Professor replied “very definitely”, with the Coroner warning Mills that because of his actions for the sake of financial gain, “there is a probability that other proceedings might arise”.

Three times the Coroner asked “are you sure it was on Wednesday 8th August, when you found her?” Three times Mills answered “yes”, having already alluded that it was the Friday before. Again, warned about his testimony of how he found the body, the coroner asked “were you there long after you had seen the body”, Mills replied “about five minutes. I did not touch the body, nor put anything on it… I could not touch it without going down”, when of course he’d admit he had, to place her coat over her.

But if the body was hidden, how did he know she had been strangled?

At the inquest, the limping moustachioed man was removed from the line of inquiry, and suspicion clearly crept towards Mills as a possible culprit… but also as a deluded, attention-seeking fantasist.

Mills should have been arrested, but he was right, the Detectives had no hard evidence against him; he admitted he had been with her earlier that night (as confirmed by the lodger, Lily Wilson) and said he’d found the necklace at the crime scene on the night he found the body. But nobody saw him there with Mabel, and as for her being strangled, he could have simply guessed it, as it’s not exactly unique.

Mills had to play a very careful game now. If he pushed the press too hard for money, they would see him as nothing but a liar and his prospective cash-cows would dry up, which was not good, as the £75 the News of the World had given him, he’d blown most of it on a single bet. If he gave away too many facts, he may be convicted of murder making his dramatic and financially rewarding acquittal a bust. But if he went too far in his retelling of his lies, if he was found insane and may end up at Broadmoor.

So, on Friday the 24th of August, having told Norman Rae that he had something ‘sensational’ to reveal - knowing that if Rae kept Mills talking long enough that he would eventually incriminate himself - even this seasoned crime reporter was shocked to find that Mills was already two steps ahead of him.

Sat in the lobby of The Black Boy Hotel on Nottingham’s Long Row, at first the conversation was casual; a talk about money, racing, murderers, prison conditions, Broadmoor and acquittal. Initially, Rae felt as if Mills was merely wasting his time and had nothing sensational to say, until he hit him with this…

“I want to tell the truth”.

And over the next hour, he wrote his confession on the hotel’s headed notepaper. In his handwriting, it read “on the evening of August 8th, I killed Mrs Tattershaw and now wish to clean my conscience and confess to the murder”. He told of how they met, their date and described the killing, arrogantly bragging “I had always considered the possibility of the perfect crime – murder. I am very much interested in crime and here was my opportunity. No motive, no clues. I am quite proud of my achievement. Seeing an opportunity of putting my theory into practice, I decided to meet her. I was satisfied I had found the perfect victim. I put on a pair of gloves. I knelt on her. I was very pleased. I think I did rather well. The strangling was easily accomplished. I slid her down the bank, and left”.

Rae had Mills sign each page and agreeing “we’ll take it to Superintendent Ellington in the morning, if that is what you desire?”, Mills agreed, and went to bed, as Rae had to file his explosive news story.

In gambling parlance, Mills had gone all in, he’d placed all his chips on one number, the roulette wheel was spinning, and if he won, he would walk away wealthy having beaten the house. But if he lost…

…it would mean his death.

On Saturday the 25th of August at 10am, at Leenside Police Station, accompanied by Normal Rae, Mills handed his confession to a shocked Detective Superintendent Ellington, who having read the first page cautioned him. Sup: “is this document in your handwriting?”, Mills: “yes”, Sup: “you understand that what is in this document is of a very serious nature and can have serious consequences for you?”, Mills “yes”, Sup: “do you wish to make a statement?”, Mills: “yes”. An official statement was made, Mills read it and signed it, he was cautioned again, and was charged with the murder of Mabel Tattershaw.

That week, Dr Fish of the Home Office laboratory came back with the exhibits found at the crime scene which had been sent off for scientific testing. With Mills, having repeatedly stated that he hadn’t been within 8 feet of the body, three hairs similar to his were found on Mabel’s dress which had been hidden under her grey overcoat, and although he’d placed over that his jacket to trap her arms and stop her clawing at him, fibres from his jacket were found under her fingernails, proving he was there. (End).

The trial began at Nottingham Assizes on the 19th of November 1951 before Justice Bryne. He pleaded not guilty to murder and did not present an insanity plea. His own defence called Mills “a desperately lonely, hateful boy, whose character was a mixture of cruelty and boastfulness", whose confession was ‘completely bogus’ and had been a ruse to make his story more valuable. They would also state that there was no motive for the murder, as Mills didn’t know Mabel and hadn’t met her before then.

On the other hand, even though the Prosecution had hairs from his head on her, fibres from his jacket under her nails, a confession in his own handwriting and he knew details only the killer knew, although a chronic gambler who admitted he did this for fame and money, the question was would the jury see the deliberate mistakes in his confession and acquit him, as he wanted, making him famous and rich…

…or find him guilty of murder beyond a reasonable doubt?

Having been instructed by the Judge that there were only two possible outcomes - wilful murder or not guilty, not manslaughter on any grounds – after 25 minutes of deliberation, they returned a verdict – guilty. As per his directions, having agreed that Mills’ confession was true, the charge of murder was established, and with his guilt proven, on the 22nd of November, Herbert Mills was sentenced to death.

Described as having the composure of a gambler, the Judge said “if you have never seen a man who would gamble with his life, you are looking at one now”. Even during the trial, the prosecution asked “if you had thought it would have brought you more money would have pleaded guilty?”, Mills said “I considered it”. He didn’t appeal the decision, and although a reprieve was submitted, it was rejected.

He hated prison life, he refused to see his father, he ridiculed his grandmother’s prayers for salvation, he crushed a prison officer’s arm in a door, and on Tuesday the 11th of December 1951 at 9am, Herbert Leonard Mills was executed by hanging at Lincoln Prison by Albert Pierrepoint. As a convicted prisoner, he was not allowed to profit from his crimes, and having made the biggest gamble of his life… he lost.

The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Author

    Michael J Buchanan-Dunne is a crime writer, podcaster of Murder Mile UK True Crime and creator of true-crime TV series.

    Become a Patron!
    Picture

    Archives

    November 2026
    October 2026
    September 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016



    Picture
    Subscribe to the Murder Mile true-crime podcast

    Categories

    All
    Adverts
    Assassinations
    Canalkillers
    Cannibal
    Celebrities
    Curious-stuff
    Deadly-families
    Execution Sites
    Forgotten Disasters
    Head Injuries
    Killer Interviews
    Killer Profiles
    Killer's Books
    Killers By Age
    Killers By Birthday
    Killers By Birth Name
    Killers By County
    Killers By Diet
    Killers By Drink
    Killers By Height
    Killers By IQ
    Killers By Job
    Killers By Lunar Cycle
    Killers By Marriage
    Killers By Motive
    Killers By Music
    Killers By Nickname
    Killers By Star Sign
    Killers By Weight
    Killers = Dead Or Alive?
    Killer's Kids
    Killers Last Meals
    Killers Last Words
    Killers Mothers
    Killers Not Caught
    Killers On TV
    Killers & Pets
    Killer's Religion
    Local History
    Mass Graves
    Mistakes
    Murder
    Murder Mile
    Nicknames
    Obsession With True Crime
    Pod
    Podcast
    Poisoners
    Q & A
    Serial Killers
    Soho
    Soho Murders
    The Dangers Of Booze
    The Innocent
    The Law

    Note: This blog contains only licence-free images or photos shot by myself in compliance with UK & EU copyright laws. If any image breaches these laws, blame Google Images. 

SOCIAL MEDIA

BUSINESS ADDRESS

ABOUT MURDER MILE UK TRUE CRIME

(c) Murder Mile Walks, P O Box 83
15 Ingestre Place, Soho, W1F 0JH
Murder Mile UK True Crime is a true-crime podcast and blog featuring little known cases within London's West End but mostly the square mile of Soho, with new projects in the works
  • PODCAST
    • About the Host
    • About the Music
    • About the Sound
    • About the Research
    • Legal Disclaimer
  • Shop
  • Blog
  • Contact