Murder Mile UK True-Crime Podcast - #374: The Rotter (Isobel Chesney & Mary Menzies, Ealing)12/11/2026
CEight time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
On the 11th of February 1954, staff at a care home in Ealing, West London, found the body of its owner, 42-year-old Isobel Chesney having drowned in her bath. Her killer, her husband, John Donald Merrett assumed that Police would believe this was an accident, but having also battered to death her mother, Lady Mary Menzies, when she got in the way, the investigation quickly led to a killer who thought he had the perfect alibi - being hundreds of miles away in Amsterdam at the time of the killing – but his murder plot was fueled by more confidence than common sense.
SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives:
MUSIC:
UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT: Welcome to Murder Mile: Unleashed. And I’m away. Goodbye London. Hello Britain. And as I cruise the UK’s canal network in my little boat, I shall bring you true crime cases from the cities, towns and villages I visit. This week, I’m back in Ealing to explore an utter bastard who committed a brutal double murder to sate his cashflow and his crotch. My name is Michael, I am your tour guide, and this is Murder Mile. Episode 374: The Rotter. Thursday 11th of February 1954 at 7:45am, on a small bed in the corner of the scullery at Sunset House, a 14-roomed three-storey old people’s home at 22 Montpelier Road in Ealing, 18-year-old housemaid Eileen Thorpe woke with a start. It was a habit that her employer - 68-year-old Lady Mary Menzies or her daughter 42-year-old Isobel Chesney as co-owners of the house - would wake her, but they hadn’t. With its 19 residents aged 70 to 95 all asleep, Eileen greeted the dogs Tinker & Chow, and quietly crept to Mary’s bedroom on the front ground floor; the room was tidy, the fire was on, the curtains were drawn, her clothes were folded beside her handbag, and her bed was made, but Mary was missing. Eileen was concerned, but being junior staff, when she heard the residents slowly stirring, she started making their breakfasts as was her duty. At 8:15am, she went to Isobel’s room on the first floor, but again, with the curtains closed, the lights off, the bed unkempt, her clothes folded, but Isobel nowhere to be seen, she tried the door to her en-suite bathroom, accessed only from here, but it was locked. Both women were absent, but she didn’t know why. Serving the residents’ breakfasts, she confirmed that Lady Mary & Isobel weren’t attending to them, she searched every room they regularly used, she checked the front door but it was locked and bolted from within, and although the lock on the French windows leading to the back garden was always broken, a large stone still held it in place, as usual. At about 11am, an ambulance escorting a new patient arrived, who Mary & Isobel should have been there to greet, but weren’t, so Eileen called Phyliss McNeish, Isobel’s cousin who ran a care home on Mount Park Road and Isobel’s adopted daughter, Elizabeth Trull, who helped out with the residents, and each searched the house, but couldn’t explain where Mary & Isobel were, or what had happened? Then just before 2:20pm, Phyllis noticed something odd, something that only a loved one would know. Mary’s bed was made, only she never made her ‘bed’, as with it being too small, she preferred to sleep on the sofa. And in Isobel’s bedroom, her light was off having been switched off at the wall by the door, but owing to a quirk in the old electrics, she only used her bedside lamp for illumination, as when the main light was turned off, it switched off the bedside lamp, the electric fire, and her alarm clock. Grabbing the master key from a tea-tray in Mary’s room, Phyllis unlocked Isobel’s en-suite bathroom… …her scream rang out, a body was found drowned in the bath. Minutes later, searching every room as well as the unused ones, in the ground floor spare room, Mary was found brutally battered to death. The previous night, as Eileen and the old residents slept; no-one had heard a sound nor saw anything suspicious, the dogs hadn’t even barked. There were no signs of a break in, nothing was stolen, they hadn’t been threatened, and as they always did, they locked all the doors to keep themselves safe. So, why did Mary end up murdered, and Isobel drowned, possibly by accident? It was a case which perplexed the Police for barely a week… …as there was only ever one suspect – The Rotter. The Rotter went by several aliases; John Donald Chesney, Ronald John Chesney and Leslie Chown. It was said that he was born John Donald Merritt in Levin, New Zealand on 17th of August 1908 as the son of John Merrett & Bertha Milner, but this also could have been a lie, as his life was full of whoppers and outright fibs. Merrett was described as a rogue, a cad and a bounder, but everything you need to know about this very odd man can be gleaned from what happened when he was just 18 years old. In April 1925, while Merrett was an art student in Edinburgh University who lived with his 58 year-old widowed mother in a fashionable flat in Buckingham Terrace, one day, he alleged that while writing a standard letter to a casual friend – hit by a pique of unexpected depression owing to her non-existent debts - she pulled out his pistol (which he purchased for target practice) and fired a shot into her head. Claiming, he heard the shot from the other room and had seen his mother slump, he swiftly gave her first aid and raced her to the infirmary, but having died of severe haemorrhage and with the evidence pointing to this being a suicide, he expected to be bequeathed her very sizable life insurance policy. The problem was, being newly orphaned, Merrett would be forced to wait until he was 21 to live the high life off his dead mum’s money, so instead he forged £457 of her cheques (£36,000 today) so he could get drunk and shag girls, but being convicted of fraud, the Police also charged him with murder. On 8th of February 1927, after an 8-day trial at Edinburgh Crown Court, Merrett (under his legal name of John Donald Milner) was found guilty of fraud, but acquitted of murder being ‘unproven’. Sentenced to 12 months in prison, he served six as a first offence, then changed his name to Ronald John Chesney and having had to wait till his 21st birthday, Merrett received a £60,000 payout (£2.1 million today, with £10,000 set aside for him and any wife-to-be). But by the decade’s end, he’d squandered the lot. This may also explain why he got married so hastily, as on the 29th of March 1928 in Glasgow, Isobel Veronica Menzies, the affluent daughter of Lady Mary & Sir Thomas Menzies became Isobel Chesney. Like her soon-to-be widowed mother, as a devout Catholic, Isobel was big hearted and compassionate, she dreamed of running a care home for the elderly, and adopted her daughter, Elizabeth, at 2 weeks. Whereas Merrett was not. This 6 foot 2 inch, bulbous nosed thief with a pompous moustache and the slicked hair of a spiv was a narcissist. And later describing their marriage as “not good”, within weeks, Merrett was having affairs and was arrested in Newcastle for larceny and false pretences. What a shit! When the Second World War plunged the world in chaos, Merrett enlisted in the Royal Navy Volunteer Reserve, and – as the son-in-law of a Lord – he rose up the rank to Lieutenant Commander. Only he wasn’t there to fight, he was there to steal, and used his rank and privilege not only to joyride a naval car for which he would be court-marshalled in 1946, but also for his other nefarious occupations he undertook during this service, like black marketeering, smuggling, forgery, theft and gun-running. One year before, Lieutenant Commander Ronald Chesney also used his rank to acquire a house which had been requisitioned for the war effort, 22 Montpelier Road in Ealing, and although I’m sure he’d have loved to turn it into a brothel or gambling den, Isobel, her mother Mary and daughter Elizabeth wanted to turn it into an old people’s home called ‘Sunset House’, and so that is what it became. The three women officially became its co-owners on the 21st of January 1946 under licence from Ealing Borough Council, by which time, Isobel & Merrett had mutually separated. As Isobel built a respectable care home for the elderly, Merrett fled to France, shagged his way through Paris, and served time annually; 1947 for smuggling, 1948 for forgery, 1949 for fraud, and 1951 for concealing bank notes. He hated prison, but he loved money, and the only way he knew how to make it was by stealing it… …or by getting divorced. By 1951, being perpetually broke, he asked Isobel for a divorce, knowing that – not only could this mean he could marry his mistress, 29-year-old German, Sonja Winnikes - but the split would financially favour him as the care home would be sold, so rightly, Isobel always said ‘no’. Unwilling to work, that left just one alternative for Merrett, as a settlement made at the time of their marriage meant he could inherit £10,000 (£355,000), but only if Isobel died naturally or by accident. Merrett treated Isobel like dirt. Her care-home he saw as a doss house, where he let his ex-con mates crash over at, along with his girlfriend Sonja, and other mistresses, behind Sonja’s back. He used Isobel to bankroll his hare-brained schemes, and when she wouldn’t fund him, he stole her rugs and her car. He never assaulted her, and yet toll of Merrett’s theft and cheating secretly drove Isobel to drink, so almost every night in those final years, she would lay in bed unconscious, having drunk herself to sleep. Five month before her mysterious ‘drowning’, Isobel told her daughter that Merrett, her father, who she had considered “a nice man but a useless husband” had been acquitted of murdering his mother, and just days before her death, she even described him to their new housemaid, Eileen, as ‘a rotter’… …but how far would a ‘rotter’ really go for money? Merrett wanted Isobel dead. But he couldn’t just kill her, not if he wanted to get his grubby little mitts on the £10,000 inheritance. Having learned his lesson from the so-called suicide of his dead mother, this would be his deadly plan; one – Isobel would need to die by accident, two – he (as the most likely suspect) would need to be far away when she died, and three – her killer would need to be paid off and then vanish into nowhere. Being selfish and unsubtle, while serving time in HMP Wandsworth, Merrett had begun interviewing potential killers. In total, he spoke to six people, all in a manner as casual as buying a loaf of bread. Richard Pickersgill, a petty thief with no convictions for violence who had the displeasure of sharing a cell with Merrett, who offered him £2000 to kill his wife, as well as a train ticket to Paris and a safe house to lay low until the heat had blown over. Pickersgill was only serving a few months inside, so rather than risking his neck dangling from a rope for the sake of around £70,000 today, he said ‘no’. Another was Herbert John Boyd, who Merrett offered half what he had offered Pickersgill, if he would run his wife down with her car (the same car he would later steal), or using the ex-military guns he had stashed in the care home, he could shoot her. Boyd thought it was a joke. It wasn’t. But what was a joke, was that Merrett was broke, so the money would have to be on a ‘kill now, get paid later’ basis. For both, Merrett gave them her name, address, her timings, a plan of the care home and the fact that she drank heavily at night, which came in very useful when they later gave evidence at the inquest. When discussing his wife’s death with Frederick Burgess, Merrett was torn between running her over, drowning her, or having her killed in a burglary, but not being a cold-blooded killer, Burgess wanted nothing to do with it. It was around this time that Merrett realised he would have to do it himself. By March 1951, while casually chatting with his pal, Flying Officer Irwin Maling, Merrett said “If I think of a plan, would you furnish me with an alibi? It’d be worth £1000”. Merrett gave him a cheque, only it was unsigned and undated. Merrett also mentioned that he’d “toyed with the idea of turning on the gas taps as she slept”, and had previously broken into the house unnoticed by his wife, her mother, the staff, the residents and the dogs, “but something had gone wrong”. Maling tore up the cheque. None of the men went to the Police, as none of them believed he was serious. Merrett was a thief, a fraudster, a smuggler, a narcissist and a royal pain in the arse, but he was also a liar and a fantasist. No-one took him seriously, except Isobel… To her boyfriend, ex-Flying Officer Alvan William, Isobel said “he invited her to come to Germany with him, but she was worried she would not return… she said ‘he might do me in or get me bunged off”. …it’s no wonder that, every night, she drank herself to sleep. Merrett had concocted, what he felt, was the ‘perfect murder’; to kill his wife, while he was in another country, and make it look like an accident, but without having to pay a stranger to do it. On the 25th of June 1953, six months before her murder, Merrett went to Thomas Cook travel agents on Pall Mall and submitted a passport application in the name of his pal, Leslie Bernard Treville Chown. The photos were of Merrett (cunningly disguised in a pair of glasses), the birth certificate was stolen from Chown’s flat, Chown was furious, but agreed to say nothing about it for £25, £15 of which would never arrive. Merrett’s ‘perfect murder’ began one week before. On Thursday 4th of February 1954 at 12pm, Merrett (using his own passport in his legal name of John Donald Milner) took the boat train from Harwich to Holland, proving that Merrett had left England. Taking the train to Cologne, he meet his girlfriend, Sonja at the Dom Hotel, staying two nights. He then booked two tickets to Amsterdam under John Donald Milner, the name he used as Managing Director of the Anglo Germanic Export Company, his semi-legitimate business in Cologne, and like any couple enjoying a break, he booked them into Hotel Frefo in central Amsterdam. John Donald Milner was friendly with the staff and had booked a room until Friday 12th of February, two days after the murder. He made sure his name was known, his face was seen, and that everyone remembered him. On Saturday the 6th, Merrett walked into the KLM office in Amsterdam and purchased in cash, a return plane ticket to London, using the name Leslie Chown, as proven by his fake passport’s photograph. Having changed the tickets twice - we have no idea why, but we do know it corresponded with a call he made to Isobel, after which Phyllis said she was ‘stressed and depressed’ – he changed them again to depart on Wednesday the 10th, day of the murder, and return early the next morning on the 11th. If the plan went awry, Chown wasn’t known to Isobel, so would never be suspected of murdering her. On Tuesday the 9th, as seen by the hotel staff, Merrett waved goodbye as Sonja headed back to Duran. She believed he was awaiting a letter from his wife, granting him a divorce so he could marry her, but ever the arsehole, Merrett had told his pals he planned to dump Sonja, even though he was broke, she was bankrolling his trips, his hotel stays, his business ventures, and he was forging her cheques. Merrett was ‘a rotter’, and now, for the second (and third) time in his life… …he would turn to murder for the sake of money. Wednesday the 10th of February 1954 was a day like any other at ‘Sunset House’, the care home at 22 Montpelier Road, Ealing. At 6:30am, with Isobel sleeping off a hangover, Lady Mary awoke Eileen, the 18 year old housemaid, and together, all three women washed and fed the 19 residents. The day was uneventful, the dogs were calm, the residents were put to bed by 8pm, and the doors were locked. At 10pm, from her bed in the scullery, Eileen heard Isobel say ‘goodnight’ as she ascended the stairs to her bed, and with Mary the last up, she went to sleep on the sofa in the front ground-floor bedroom. At that moment, it was believed that John Donald Milner aka Merrett was still in Amsterdam, whereas a man called Leslie Chown had left Schiphol airport on KLM Flight 137, and landed in London at 7pm. Merrett’s so called ‘perfect murder’ had begun… …but as with everything this useless swindler put his hand to, it turned to shit. Several people saw this hulking brute with greasy hair and eyes like the proverbial ‘piss holes in the snow’ walking up Montpellier Road from 10:30pm to midnight; Patricia March and Peter Henderson were drawn by the fake limp he was affecting, which moved from his left leg to his right. Then he was heard with his huge heavy feet walking up the path at the rear of the house by neighbour Betty Cooper. Using his supposed unique insight of the owners and in-depth knowledge of the house, with the doors locked, he entered via the French windows whose lock was broken, held in place a large stone and led to an unused spare room on the ground floor. Nobody stirred because it was well past 1am. The dogs – Tinker & Chow Chow – didn’t bark as they knew him. And the whole house was dark and silent. Isobel would be unconscious having drank herself to sleep, he knew that, his behaviour assured that. If he was quiet, Mary, Isobel’s mother wouldn’t hear him. Being in a different part of the house, neither would Eileen. And with the residents mostly deaf, blind geriatrics, it’s unlikely that a detective would take them seriously, but still, to make Isobel’s death seem like an accident, Merrett had to go unseen. The problem was, care homes don’t just stop after dusk. At 12:35am, 77-year-old George Cumming, who shared a room in the rear first floor mezzanine with 74-year-old John Clark, said he remembered seeing Mary looking in on him, and he looked at his clock. At 1am, she brought 81-year-old Elizabeth Whitmore a warm glass of milk to help her sleep, and then she went back to her ground-floor bedroom, and got back into her bed on the sofa with a cup of tea. Of course, Merrett didn’t know that. Quietly, he snuck into the hall, nobody saw or heard him. As softly as his Size 12 boots could allow, he crept up stairs. And knowing where her room was, that the door was always unlocked, and she would be dead to the world, with her bedside light always left on, he crept in as she slept under her covers. With his large hand, he gagged her, silencing any screams or cries. Her legs kicked out, catching the bedpost and smearing blood across the under sheet. He dragged her into her en-suite bathroom which only she had access to, he popped in a plug and filling it up, he drowned her in a few inches of water. Wearing her usual cardigan and a black nightdress, he rolled her body into the tub, added soapy water to her hair, and popped a pack of Soak Flakes’ on the sink, so it would seem that this secret drinker had slipped and drowned while she was washing her hair, all while under the influence of alcohol. He would leave unseen having stolen nothing, and by the morning, having supposedly woken from a deep sleep, John Donald Milner aka Merrett would be seen having breakfast at his hotel in Amsterdam. In his diseased little mind, he had committed the ‘perfect murder’… …except; how could Isobel wash her hair if she didn’t have a towel to dry it, how had she locked herself in the bathroom without a key, and not only did two of the residents, George Cummin & John Clark, hear a ‘thud’ followed by running water, but these odd sounds also alerted someone else – Mary. It was as Merrett smugly descended the stairs (knowing Isobel was dead, that it looked like an accident and that the £10,000 inheritance was his and his alone) that he saw Mary staring at him from the hall. Out of a greed-filled panic, before she could scream, he beat the 68-year-old about the face with his fists, violently punching her, and beating her around the head with a metal gong. Fighting back, Mary clawed at his hands, drawing blood, and as she fought on, he dragged her into her bedroom. With her being the only impediment to his money, he smashed her repeatedly over the skull with a metal coffee pot, strangled the life out of her using her own stocking, and then dragged her into the spare room. In a baffling attempt to hide her body, he piled the seat covers and cushions on top of her, which oddly worked as neither Eileen, Phyliss nor Elizabeth would find her for hours by the morning, and then he set about cleaning up the crime scenes… but badly. In Mary’s room, he hid any signs of struggle, folded her clothes, hastily mopped up any blood, but also made her bed, but not on the sofa where she slept. He did the same in Isobel’s room; by making the bed (which she never did), by switching off the wall light (which stopped her alarm clock at exactly 1:10am), he locked the bedroom room and placed the key on the tea-tray in Mary’s room. Having left, at 1:20am, he was seen at Hanger Lane by Frederick Dave who knew him, and his flight back to Schiphol (as Leslie Chown) ended up landing in Dusseldorf, so having to be driven by coach back to Amsterdam, he didn’t make it to the hotel until late afternoon. The investigation was headed up by Detective Chief Superintendent Jack Livings. Isobel’s death seemed plausible on the surface. A post-mortem by Dr Donald Teare found “ballooning of the lungs due to asphyxia by drowning”, but with lacerations, pressure marks to the neck, a crushed larynx and drag marks to her arms and heels, it was ruled as ‘inconclusive’. Where-as Mary’s death – having been violently beaten, sadistically strangled and hidden by sofa cushions – this was a murder. On Friday the 11th of February, two days later, Merrett checked out of Hotel Frefo and in Cologne met Sonja. With the case all over the newspapers and Merrett being hunted as he was most likely to benefit from her death, he promised to fly back to England to prove his innocence… only he didn’t (End) As before with the so-called suicide of this mother, he got greedy and rather than grieving, within days he had already contacted the Office of Public Trust to get them to issue the inheritance. He promised to aid the Police’s investigation in any way he could, but when he realised he was screwed, he sent a letter to his solicitor stating “I realise that although innocent, I haven’t the chance of the proverbial snowball in Hades of getting out of the mess. I have seen so much of prisons I have no wish to return there and the prospect of being hanged appeals to me even less. I assure you that the way I shall have taken to get out of it all may seem cowardly, but it nevertheless does require some courage”. He also sent a letter to Sonja, professing his love for her, claiming he had always planned to marry her, and flatly refuting the concrete facts that he had drowned his wife and murdered his mother-in-law. On Tuesday 16th of February, in a wood outside Cologne, Merrett died by gunshot wound to the head, just like his mother. The gun was by his side whose fingerprints matched those found at the care home, his pockets were stuffed with articles about the murder, fibres on his trousers matched the clothes of Mary & Isobel along with their bloodstains (Type O, with his being Type A ), and Police knew that Mary clawed at his hand, his arms were severed and sent to Scotland Yard, proving he had murdered her. Concluding on the 25th of March 1954 at Ealing Town Hall, the coroner’s inquest was conducted by Dr Harold G Broadbridge. He told the jury, that although Merrett was dead, even though they had enough evidence to convict him posthumously of the murder of Lady Mary Menzies, as there was insufficient evidence to convict him of murdering Isobel Chesney, it would be up to them to decide his guilt. Was her death an accident or a murder? After a short deliberation, they concluded that Merrett was guilty. Merrett’s dying wish was that the £10,000 settlement from his dead mother’s Will should be given to Sonja, but as Isobel & Merrett were both dead and she wasn’t entitled to it, it went to the next-of-kin, their daughter, Elizabeth. And having dated an absolute ‘rotter’, all Sonja was bequeathed was £20… … and most of his debts. The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of.
0 Comments
Eight time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
On Sunday 8th of September 1963, just after midnight, well-liked and popular married father of two George Wilson had closed up his pub, The Fox and Grapes in Sneinton, Nottingham, when he was stabbed to death outside of his pub. 63 years on, it remains unsolved to this day, but why? In this episode, we investigate the myths, the suspects, why the investigation was derailed, and unearth the most likely motive for this good man’s murder.
SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives:
MUSIC:
UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT: Welcome to Murder Mile: Unleashed. (Engine) And I’m away. Goodbye London. Hello Britain. And as I cruise the UK’s canal network in my little boat, I shall bring you true crime cases from the cities, towns and villages I visit. This week, I’m in Sneinton in Nottinghamshire to pose a very possible solution to this city’s famously unsolved murder. My name is Michael, I am your tour guide, and this is Murder Mile. Episode 373: The ‘Pretty Windows’ Murder. For 63 years, the brutal murder of pub landlord, George Wilson, has remained unsolved. It was a killing which prompted one of the biggest manhunts in the county’s history, alongside the interviewing of thousands of possible witnesses and probable suspects, as well as those who confessed to his murder. In 2013, on the 50th anniversary of the Pretty Windows murder as it was called, the evidence from the cold case was re-examined, new information came forward, but as today, no-one has been arrested or charged, and the case remains open. So why was it never solved? Have the guilty been shielded, were the witnesses wrong, was the original investigation bungled, or - as a case which remains awash with a wealth of baffling myths and sensational theories – has a very simple solution been overlooked? If it was sitting there all along, why did we miss it? George Wilson was born in 1921, the same year as the Anglo-Irish Treaty was signed, the coal strike known as Black Friday and the R38 airship disaster in the Humber estuary which killed 44 crew. Raised in a tiny miner’s cottage at 12 Frederick Street in Chopwell, Durham, he was the youngest of at least four to a housewife mother, and a father who was a coal miner and hewer, so it’s no surprise that having left school at 14, that he too became a miner, later based at the Rossington Colliery, Yorkshire. Aged 18, with the Second World War in full swing, George did his bit for King and Country and enlisted in Royal Air Force, and while on home leave, having met old school friend Alberta Johnson known as Betty who was doing her bit in the Auxiliary Territorial Service, with these childhood sweethearts starting courting, when the war ended, they became a couple, and married on Christmas Eve 1946. Post war, with George not wanting to return to the dirty slog of coal mining, alongside his loving wife, George & Betty became publicans. It made sense, as even though the hours were long owing to the 1961 Licencing Act – Monday to Saturday; 11am to 3pm, 6pm to 10:30pm, and Sundays from 12pm to 2pm and 7pm to 10:30pm – it was a stable income, and having given birth to a son, David in 1953 and later a daughter, Margaret in 1957 – they could raise a family and earn a living in the same place. Pub work suited George, as when a customer walked in, he greeted them with a big beaming smile, a warm welcome, inquisitive eyebrows and jovial patter that made everyone feel welcome. For several years, they ran the Walton Arms Hotel in Chesterfield, until May 1962, when Betty & George became licensees of The Fox & Grapes pub in Sneinton, just on the outskirts of Nottingham City Centre. Owned by Home Brewery, The Fox and Grapes at 21 Southwell Road has been situated on the corner of Sneinton market since 1833 and only briefly changed its name once in the 1980s being known as Peggars Inn. Locals know it as ‘The Pretty Windows’ owing to its striking stained-glass windows across the entrances, and – with no buildings on either side - it sits alone at the peak of the market with Avenues B and C surrounding it and side entrances via an alley to the pub’s rear and the family’s home. Having taken over from Charles Morton and prior to him Arthur Hoyland, George was known to be “a quiet, likeable chap, who got on well with everyone”, and described as “the nicest chap you could imagine”, he was never rude or aggressive, and “would dip into his pocket” to cover a thirsty customer who wanted a drink but couldn’t afford it. Their cleaner, Nellie Leaf said “he was such a nice fellow, kind to everyone and especially to his staff”. He was experienced, well-liked, kind, and “not the kind of man to have enemies” even in this rough and ready pub, which – like many – had a colourful past. Prior to George & Betty being the pub’s licensees; in January 1958, 26-year-old labourer John Kilmartin was fined £15 for smashing a window with a bottle. That December, 28-year-old James Wright stole a purse, emptied it, left it in the pub’s loo, and was convicted of theft. April 1959, 70-year-old Frederick Turner admitted to smashing a window after landlord, Charles Morton ‘abused him’. And in August 1958, 29-year-old barman George Taylor stole £5 from the till of Charles Morton. He apologised, and promised to pay it back. All were minor offences, with none recorded during George & Betty’s tenure. In August 1963, George served as relief manager at the Newshouse pub on Canal Street, during which time it was burgled and £78 was taken, but – it was said – the culprit was arrested and convicted. At the end of August, alongside their dog, Blackie, the family; George, Betty, 6-year-old Margaret and 10-year-old David went on a week’s holiday to the seaside town of Mablethorpe. Betty later said “It was the first holiday we had had for seven or eight years. We had really looked forward to and had a whale of a time. We had fun being away from it all. The weather was glorious… the best holiday ever”. …but barely a week later, George was senselessly murdered. Saturday the 7th of September 1963 was a typical evening in the Fox and Grapes. It was relatively quiet, behind the bar were George & Betty plus Arthur and Irene Ash who George was training up to become licensees, and alongside a few regulars, they had a good old sing song until the pub shut at 10:30pm. Arthur confirmed “it had been a quiet evening. We had no trouble at all. Everything was in order”. As was customary - once the empties were washed and put away, the pub’s doors were locked, the lights switched off and the till cashed-up with George putting two £5 notes into his pocket - five people stayed behind in the family’s sitting room at the back for a post-work drink; George and Betty, Arthur and Irene, and regular customer, Mr Smith. Yet from the outside, no-one would know they were in. As was his nightly routine, at 12:15am, George left via the side gate to Avenue B, taking his dog, Blackie for a walk. He said goodbye to Mr Smith, Arthur & Irene, and left his wife inside to get ready for bed. Where he went? Nobody saw. And although the investigation would lead to limitless possible sightings of his killer, after 12:15am, George Wilson vanished, not being seen for 39 minutes. No-one said they heard any bangs, crashes, shouts or screams, nothing but the usual Saturday night, post-pub melee. At 12:54am, Betty was startled by Blackie’s frantic barking and scratching at the side door. Opening it, she saw their fiercely protective dog, unhurt yet drenched in blood. But barely a few feet behind, with his keys beside him like he was seconds away from entering his home, clinging to a lit lamppost, George was face down in a pool of his blood, barely alive, fading fast, a broken roof tile beside him. George, the kindly, well-liked publican had been viciously stabbed 13 times; two in the abdomen, five in the chest, six in the face, and with no defensive wounds, he was attacked swiftly from the front by an unseen assailant with a very thin, double edged knife, possibly six inches in length. An ambulance arrived, but he died at the scene, with the only witness to his brutal murder being Blackie the dog. Informed of George’s death, at 2:45am, Arthur & Irene returned to the pub to look after Betty and the children. With her nerves shot and unable to speak, Betty later stated she smoked 100 cigarettes in six hours, and in deep shock, said “I had nothing to live for”. She didn’t leave their home for days. George’s murder was senseless and unprovoked. So who killed him and why? The investigation was led by Detective Superintendent Rex Fletcher, head of the city’s CID. An incident room was set-up at Bath Street police station with extra phones added to handle the calls, the City Transport headquarters at Carter Gate became the nerve centre for the search, and – bafflingly – with the Fox and Grapes re-opening at 12:45pm, a mobile unit was set-up outside for witness statements, which made sense as with the crime scene covered in a green tarpaulin, the pub was full of gawkers. Throughout the night and the following days, Police interviewed thousands of market traders, locals and pub regulars, as well as anyone who may have had a grudge against George (but that was unlikely), the pub’s ex-landlords were questioned, but with no witness to the murder except Blackie, the search criteria was wide. Vans with loudspeakers appealed for sightings, and householders and employers were asked “has anyone been missing since Saturday?”, and “has anyone not shown up for work?”. It didn’t seem to detectives that this was a planned attack, as George was murdered on the corner of a busy intersection at the rear of the city centre, surrounded by pubs, flats, hostels and a market which was busy at night with cleaners, porters and security. The area was regularly patrolled by Police, and unlike other bits of Southwell Road and Avenues B and C, George was attacked under a lit street lamp. A professional wouldn’t make that mistake, so what if the culprit lashed out being desperate to flee? With no viable suspects, the initial stages of investigation had the hallmarks of a scatter-gun approach. The attack was so frenzied that Police searched the psychiatric hospitals for anyone who had escaped or was released, but this led to no suspects. With the pub circled by two homeless hostels, at 2am, 300+ inmates at Sneinton House were questioned, with 120 at the Salvation Army on Aberdeen Street, but all were accounted for. And with two £5 notes in George’s jacket still there, robbery was ruled out. Of course, being a time of blatant bigotry, 15 caravans were searched on waste ground in Chilwell. And although, Charles Murray, a known burglar was accused by William McKinnon of planning to break into the Fox and Grapes on Saturday the 7th, as McKinnon failed to turn up at the inquest to verify this as true, as there was no evidence of an attempted forced entry, burglary was ruled out as a motive. One key piece of evidence was the lone witness, Blackie. With George’s mother-in-law describing this black and white mongrel collie-cross as “a fairly fierce dog” and certainly so protective he “would have gone for anyone hurting the family”, being found with Type O blood over his face (the same type of George’s) but no injuries to the dog and no bite-marks to George, it was assumed that Blackie had attacked George’s killer, but no-one with any dog bites checked into the local hospitals, and being inconclusive, “a forensic examination of the dog did not indicate if he had gone for the attacker”. What the Police needed was the murder weapon. Appeals were put on posters and vans driven around the city. Several knives were found by street cleaners near the pub, and constables and cadets scoured the Lenton Lane refuse tip with a one-tonne magnet. All knives were sent for laboratory testing, but with only one proving promising, ”a carving knife with blood on it found just five feet away”, sadly it was the wrong size, shape, and with the blood being animal, it was likely discarded by a market trader. Two days after the murder, on Monday the 9th September, schoolboy Graham Scotney was making a den in a dyke called Polser Brook - near the entrance to Hoveringham Gravels on the Nottingham to Radcliffe Road, two miles from the stabbing - when he found a discarded knife in the mud. Just like the murder weapon, it was a double edged sheath knife six inches in length, the blade was thin, almost too thin to be stabbing weapon, and its tip was bent and broken having hit something hard like bone. Examined by Jack Fish, principal scientific officer at the Home Office Forensic Lab, the tests confirmed that blood smears on the blade were Type O (the same as George’s but also 48% of the UK population) and yet, the with the blade’s bent tip acting like a hook, as it was stabbed into George’s body, it had yanked fibres matching his jacket and shirt, and when re-sheathed, they had remained untouched. Jack Fish said “undoubtably this was the weapon”… …but with no fingerprints to be salvaged, it couldn’t be linked to any suspect. At the incident room, Police said they had received “an amazing response from the public”, and by the 16th of September, three men had been detained and questioned, but were released without charge. The problem was although eye-witnesses are only ever 30% accurate at best, that means they are 70% wrong. With the murder of George Wilson being so sensational, with the police struggling and locals wanting it solved, it’s no surprise that so many people came forward, believing they were being helpful and submitting a statement of something they believed they‘d seen, had seen but had attributed to the wrong date or place, or had their facts unwittingly embellished by what they’d read in the papers. Some people, with a grudge against the police or a rival, may have deliberately put forward false facts, which is why this murder is so awash with possibly sightings of the killer which lack any plausibility. Submitted by the public to the incident room, Police sought “a motorist who picked up a man at the entrance of Hoveringham Gravels where the knife was found. The man was about 30, 5 foot 8, thin, pale and had receding auburn hair brushed back, wearing glasses with no lower rims”, and unlikely for a brutal killer “he chatted to the driver about monasteries, chiropody, nursing, veterinary surgeons and religion… he wore a college type scarf, was of a clerical appearance and wore a small gold crucifix”. This sighting of the potential owner of the murder weapon occurred two days after it was found. Also submitted by the public was “a couple in a small, black ‘modern’ car which stopped opposite the Fox & Grapes around the time of the stabbing and asked for directions”. The driver filled his steaming radiator with water and it was said “spoke to Betty and asked the way to West Bridgford”. It has been suspected that, before it was towed away, the car was a cunning distraction to aide the killer. Yet the couple came forward the next day, and it was proven to be just a common mechanical breakdown. Every potential sighting was thoroughly examined by the Police for fear of missing a vital clue. But this is what hampers the investigation, so many people claim or suspect that they saw the potential killer… …but as no-one actually saw the murder, how would they know if they saw the murderer? Over three hundred ‘possible’ suspects were questioned and had their alibis checked, but none were ever charged or arrested, and although the police would claim that “a wall of silence of protected the killer”, many ‘potential suspects’ were never found owing to insufficient details from eye-witnesses. The most likely suspects, according to the press and locals were these. On the night of the murder, 200 yards from the pub, a man said to be “mentally ill… flung himself in front of a car, when the driver braked, the man lay in the road with folded arms, then picked himself up and walked away ”waving his arms as he ran down Carlton Road.” This man was never found. That same night, at the same time, 500 yards from the pub (but also “in front of the pub” depending on which retelling you believe), a man in an Army uniform without a beret “darted into road, waving his arms” just 30 minutes after the killing. Witnesses said “he came out of nowhere, and could have been drunk. His hair was ruffled”. On the 13th of September, DS Rex Fletcher said the man had been detained and dubbed it “the most important lead we have yet”, but later released him without charge. And then there was ‘The Running Man’. At around 12:50am, Securicor Sergeant, Sidney Brown was on patrol at the junction of Aberdeen Street and Longden Street, two streets north-east, when he saw “a man hurrying to get away with a knife in his hand” or a chisel. He wore a trilby or a fedora hat, a beige raincoat, and although a reconstruction appeared on the TV show, Police 5, the man was never found. It seems an odd coincidence having all these bizarre events happening in or around the murder scene at roughly the same time as the killing itself, even though no-one had seen the killing or the killer. Of course, these could have been different men doing similar things on different dates, or maybe the same man who had his details confused or mistaken by different witnesses. But as, on the same night at around the same time, one witness said he heard “a man banging on the side door of the pub saying ‘let me in’” and a different man at the same door at the same time but brandishing a knife, with often only on known source for these sightings being a tabloid newspaper, how reliable are these sightings… …if they happened at all? As the investigation dragged on, weeks became months and not a single plausible suspect was named, instead of focussing on the basic facts, the press, the people and (at times) the Police tugged at the tattered thread of any theories which, as they grew larger, became more ludicrous. For example: A library book was found in a toilet not far from the pub, it was titled ‘Be Kind to the Killer’, and having to take it seriously, it was said “Police know which library it comes from and are checking the details”. Two months after the murder, Betty, George’s widow, received an anonymous letter telling her to go to Derby bus station with £100 (£2700 today) “to find out who the murderer is”. She didn’t, as she’d moved out of the pub, but this shows the length that unscrupulous people will go to for easy money. Five people also came forward admitting to the murder, including (almost two years later) a man who while serving a life sentence at Dartmoor Prison gave an 8 page statement claiming he had argued with George that day at a football match between Nott’s Forest and Wolves, which resulted in murder. Police had to take it seriously, but all five suspects were released without charge, as none were able to identify their victim, the murder weapon, the crime scene, or the dyke where the knife was dumped. Oddly, Police spoke to the prisoner on the day that the abolition of the death penalty became law; so either he had confessed to it for bragging rights, or was paid to do so to spare another prisoner? Detectives had several credible theories, many of which having been investigated, they rejected. Robbery: this was rejected, as George’s wallet was still in his jacket, along with the two £5 notes, and although some sources state that £20 was missing from the till, it wasn’t. The killer clearly wanted him dead, but not for the cash, as his mother-in-law clarified “George would not carry a lot of money”. An argument: this was rejected, as the night had been quiet and uneventful, as had previous nights, no shouting or screams were heard (which would have drawn a witness’ attention, as well as Betty’s), and with no defensive wounds, George had been attacked fast just as he entered the side entrance. Mistaken Identity: this was rejected as although some suggested that George looked similar to one of the old landlords, either Arthur Hoyland or Charles Morton being a similar build and they both had dogs, that he was mistakenly attacked, but Police couldn’t find anyone with a grudge for either man. Blackmail: although the Guardian Journal reported “Mr Wilson’s widow, said that two months before her husband had received a threat to his life”, Coroner A G Rothers asked if he had taken it seriously, she replied “he was worried about it”, but Police found no evidence that he was being blackmailed. The Police suspected that George was murdered a local gang known as The Jocks who ran an extortion racket by threatening publicans with violence if they didn’t pay up, and that with George being a proud and tough ex-miner, that he had refused and his killing was a warning to other publicans to pay up. On Tuesday the 10th of September, three days after his murder, two Nottingham pub landlords were given police protection having received anonymous calls threatening that they would be murdered; Fred Perry of the Traveller’s Rest in Lenton and Albert Gilbert of the Barley Mow on Clarence Street, all received calls within minutes of each other, and were threatened, saying “you’re next on the list”. To Fred, this refined intellectual voice (which it was suggested was disguised and may have been put on) said “you know what happened at the Fox & Grapes. Well, you’ll get the same treatment. Cheerio”. The Jocks were a gang of Scottish criminals who operated in Nottingham, they were known to use slim bladed sheath knives for slipping window latches during burglaries (a similar knife to George’s murder weapon), and although every known member of The Jocks was questioned, none were arrested. So was George Wilson murdered by The Jocks having stood up to their extortion? That’s uncertain, as years later, the Police still described his killing as ‘motiveless’. On the 25th of January 1964; with 54,000 people interviewed, 10,000 houses and 4000 firms visited, as well as 3000 statements taken, with no fresh developments and every clue hitting a dead end, the Coroner Mr Rothers ruled that George Wilson was “murdered by person or persons unknown”. George was buried at Southern Cemetery in West Bridgford. His widow, Betty, moved out of the pub, and having received £750 compensation from the Nottingham Licensed Victualler’s Association, she set-up a off-licence and general shop in Bentinck Road. One year on, she said “I lived through a year of hell. I’m not the type of person who would commit suicide, but I would if I had to go through it again… there isn’t many days that daddy isn’t mentioned by my children. It’s still on their minds”. On the 17th of November 1997, aged 73, Betty passed away, being buried in the same cemetery as her husband and she died never knowing the truth about his senseless murder. Over the last six decades, the ‘Pretty Windows’ murder has entered into lore and although a cold case review in 2013 led to “30 new leads”, with so many myths, theories and misinformation surrounding it, it may never be solved. But one theory is credible, and it’s a theory Betty believed. But it didn’t involve mistaken identity, an extortion racket, a theft, an argument, a broken down car, a mentally unwell man, or a gang of blood-thirsty Scottish criminals. This was a theory so simple, so basic, it was staring us in the face. (End) On Saturday 7th of September 1963 at 10:30pm, the Fox & Grapes pub was locked up with the lights switched off. The staff sat at the rear of the pub having a drink, and from the outside, it looked empty. At 12:15am, with Betty off to bed, the staff having left and George taking Blackie the dog for a walk, the family home at the rear looked as if everyone was asleep. With the banks shut till Monday and the takings held in a cash box overnight, it’s no stretch of imagination that a burglar may see this as an easy opportunity. With the doors locked, smashing a window would have alerted witnesses, so the burglar may have tried to climb the inclined roof above the side entrance on Avenue B leading to an unsecured window, the latch of which could be slipped using a thin bladed knife. But when a loose slate crashed to the pavement, the burglar climbed down and Betty may have ignored it, knowing it needed repairs. With the only other possible entry point to the pub or backroom, away from the lit streetlamp, the burglar may have entered the darkness of the side entrance on Avenue B, and with no signs of any forced entry and nothing stolen, it’s likely the burglar was about to break in, when George returned. As always, George approached with his keys in his hand, but seeing the gate to the alley open, he came face-to-face with the burglar. Perhaps as a pub regular or friend, George may have recognised his face, and with George, a burly-ex-miner being protected by his ferocious dog, this desperate man may have realised that his conviction was certain, his only chance at freedom was blocked, and before George could react, using his burglars knife, he stabbed George to death, ensuring that he never spoke a word. Blackie may have attacked him, but perhaps, this Type O blooded burglar didn’t go to hospital. That’s it; a burglar tried and failed to enter the rear of the pub to steal money, George disturbed him and was stabbed by a man desperate to flee and never be convicted. The killer of George Wilson may remain unnamed forever (whether he was one of the suspects supposedly seen by witnesses that night or someone entirely unknown) but what we do know is only Blackie & George saw the killer… …and that they took to their graves. The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of.
Eight time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
On Sunday the 25th of June 1995, chronic alcoholic Lawrence Bierton of Nottingham brutally and sadistically murdered two elderly ladies in their own home. Being released after a life sentence and seeking a safe place to house him, the council put him in the one place they shouldn’t have - a cul-de-sac full of pensioners. This is the horrific case of a triple killer who – being sentenced to a whole life tariff - will never be released.
SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives:
MUSIC:
UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT: Welcome to Murder Mile: Unleashed. (Engine) And I’m away. Goodbye London. Hello Britain. And as I cruise the UK’s canal network in my little boat, I shall bring you true crime cases from the cities, towns and villages I visit. This week, I’m in Worksop in Nottinghamshire, where a catastrophic mistake led a brutal double killer to kill again. My name is Michael, I am your tour guide, and this is Murder Mile. Episode 372: A Fox in the Henhouse. Social housing has always been a complex issue, providing accommodation for the most needy; the old, the infirm and the homeless, as well as single parents, victims of violence and ex-prisoners seeking to re-enter the community. As an overworked system, too easily, those on waiting lists become merely a box to be ticked and a space to be filled, as a faceless bureaucrat temporarily eases their workload by cramming Person A in House Z, regardless of whether it fully suits their history and needs, or not. Too often in an impersonal and overworked system; a battered mother is placed one street from her violent ex, a bored recovering alcoholic is perched between the dole office and a pub, and (at least once) a brutal double killer was housed in a cul-de-sac surrounded by the kind of victims he targeted. In a world where lives are changed by a button being pushed, mistakes can be made… …and sometimes, these ‘administrative errors’ can be deadly. 79-year-old widow Aileen Dudill and 72-year-old spinster Elsie Gregory were sisters, living together in a quaint semi-detached house in the historically industrial town of Rotherham in South Yorkshire. As Aileen’s niece, Carol, clarified “it would be wrong to think of them as dotty old dears, innocent to the ways of the world. They were members of the Neighbourhood Watch group… they were intelligent and articulate women and were nobody’s fool. Both were generous with their time and hospitality… anyone calling to do work at the house was treated with kindness”. They were in their sunset years, but certainly were not doddery old dears with Zimmer-frames and blue rinses, cooing at every cat as they totter to the bingo, before curling-up at 8pm with a Blue Ribbon biscuit and Highway to Heaven. They may have been older, greyer and frailer, but as strong and independent women (raised in an era when this wasn’t the ‘done thing’ for young ladies), they remained solid and stoic in mind and spirit. As the older sister of at least six siblings, Margery Aileen Gregory, known as ‘Aileen’ was born in 1915, eight years before her younger sister, Elsie. Being not just family but soul-mates, for decades the two women had ran a very prosperous grocery wholesale business in Rotherham, and although Aileen had married Douglas Dudhill in 1939, with Elsie never tying the knot, they lived together for half a century. Following the death of Douglas, Elsie & Aileen were like a married couple, two sisters joined at the hip and although by 1995, both had become frailer – as Aileen walked with a stick owing to an ankle injury and Elsie’s mobility was impaired as an accident had left her with a severe stoop – but far from being consigned to a care-home, these two magnificent women were living happily and independently. Neighbour Sean Page said of these two well-liked sisters “they were two lovely, very gentle old ladies”, who were always kindly and welcoming. For the last ten years they had lived in a red bricked semi-detached house on Herringthorpe Valley Road, a quiet residential area on the east side of Rotherham, and although over two lifetimes, they had filled their home full of antiques, Detective Superintendent Bob Purdey who headed up the case said of the outside “it is not a house of any splendour and neither would you pick it out as one that two elderly ladies lived in”, so why it was targeted, “It’s a mystery”. But still, being security-savvy, their front-door was fitted with three bolts and two locks, each window was suitably secure, and as their niece, Carol confirmed “they never allowed strangers in through the back door”, where-as friends “anyone calling to do work at the house was treated with kindness”; an old fashioned generosity involving cup of tea brewed in a pot, served in China cups and saucers, and I’m guessing, paper doilies, a milk jug, a selection of triangular sandwiches, slices of cake, and biscuits. By the summer of 1995 – made famous by the height of Britpop, Braveheart on the cinema, and British Prime Minister John Major’s impending resignation - with a heatwave approaching, although Aileen & Elsie usually tended to their garden themselves, their recent infirmity had meant they needed help. Two years before, a jobbing gardener had gone door-to-door providing duties like mowing, weeding, tree-felling (if needed) and tool sharpening, so when he called again, as they liked him, they hired him. His name was Michael Pluck. Born Michael David Phillip Pluck in Worksop, Nottinghamshire, for years he had tried to make money any way he could, whether by gardening or as a scrap dealer. Little is known of his life, except for the murder and this from the local paper, when in May 1994, Pluck visited a home in Retford which was being renovated, asked if they had scrap to sell, promised them £200 which they didn’t get and stole their Aga cooker which the Magistrate described as “an inept attempt at theft”. He was fined £150. Pluck supplemented an honest wage with petty theft, and living in a flat at Sunfield Avenue in Kilton, north-east of the market town of Worksop, by that summer, his lodger was an old pal of his… …Laurence Bierton. Born in Worksop on the 30th of December 1959, 37-year-old Laurence Stanley Bierton was a married father-of-four, who was first convicted as a juvenile and continued to flout the law to suit himself. With a long list of petty crimes and minor convictions, one of the few recorded was in 1977, when at Nottingham Crown Court, this 17 year old sawyer of Westmoreland Drive, Worksop, pleaded guilty (to three burglaries with his accomplice, Gregory Marsden) and having asked for 11 other offences to be taken into account, they both were sentenced to 150 hours of community service and a £100 fine. Having issued Bierton with such a pathetic sentence, he never learned his lesson, he didn’t change his ways, and with his violence increasing with every crime, it would soon result in three horrific murders. Bierton’s issue was that he was a chronic drinker, an alcoholic with no self control who was too easily angry, impulsive and when his addiction to alcohol was mixed with other drugs, soon it became an all-consuming habit in which he stole to get drunk, and as a coward, he targeted the weak and vulnerable. To make himself some cash, Bierton helped Pluck as a gardener, and that’s how he met Aileen & Elsie. Thursday 22nd of June 1995 was the start of the heatwave which peaked at 35 degrees Celsius. Proving too hot for two recently-infirm ladies in their 70s, when Pluck called by offering to cut down a tree and sharpen their lawn-mower blades for £140 (£350 today), he started work, aided by Bierton. From the outside, the house of these elderly sister’s didn’t look as if they had two proverbial pennies to rub together, and as far as we know, Pluck had never been inside before. But being such a hot day, maybe the backdoor was open, maybe Bierton or Pluck asked to use the toilet, or maybe (being trusted workers) they were invited in to drink a cup of tea in the shade, and seeing a house full of antiques and with the gardening paid for in cash (as proven by a handwritten receipt) they were easy targets. The next day, Friday the 23rd of June, the sisters went to the seaside town of Blackpool to soak up the sun, see their friends, and at a sedate pace owing to a injured ankle and severe stoop, browse the gift shops on the seafront. It was a fun day out for these two lovely ladies enjoying their twilight years… …but their lives would be brutally ended by two drunks in search of money. It’s uncertain what excuse Bierton & Pluck used to come back to the house on Herringthorpe Valley Road; maybe they deliberately left some tools there, Carol their niece said “my aunts had paid Bierton and his mate already for the gardening work they had done, and they came back to ask for more”. But what we know is that the sisters were expecting them, or welcomed them, as the kettle was brewing. It was the evening of Sunday 25th of June 1995. The Prosecution would state “the ladies knew them well enough to prepare a cup of tea for two people”, so with four China cups on the tray, they were to drink them together, “but no saucers indicated that the tea was to be taken outside to the garden”. With no witnesses, it was suggested that one of them (perhaps Pluck) distracted the sisters, while the other (Bierton) crept about the house seeking money and objects to steal. And mistakenly believing that these were two doggery old dears – one with a limp, one with a stoop – and both possibly senile, definitely infirm and likely unwilling to fight back, these pathetic drunks had sorely misjudged them. The Prosecution said “the role each played is within their knowledge only”, but what is known is that with their actions aroused suspicion, and when Elsie found Bierton ransacking the house, he punched the 72-year-old frail spinster to the kitchen floor with a sickening and barbaric level of violence. An autopsy confirmed she had cuts to her head, face, neck, as well as fractures to her skull and ribs consistent with someone stamping on her or kicking her. It was more than enough to floor her, but as a feisty, strong-willed women, her niece Carol said “I know Auntie Elsie tried to get to the telephone”, by crawling into the front room with every ounce of strength she could muster. But being a psychotic coward, Bierton smashed her over the skull six times with a heavy object, possibly a flat iron, breaking her ribs, nose, breastbone and her neck, leaving her in a pool of blood, dying of a severe brain trauma. Hearing the commotion, 79-year-old Aileen limped into the kitchen, and seeing Elsie slumped in a bloody heap and Bierton holding the spattered flat-iron, she barely had time to defend herself as he viciously reigned down blow after blow with that kilo of cast iron; fracturing her skull, face and thigh, then – and she lay slumped and immobile – grabbing a bread knife, he repeatedly stabbed her so savagely that he almost severed off his little finger as it slid down the handle, onto the blade, leaving a trail of his blood throughout the house, and then yelled to Pluck, “I’ve killed the old bitch”. Aileen died of severe head trauma, and yet, with a bloody cushion found, it’s likely she smothered them both. Carol later said, “on the day of the funeral, I went to the house… through the window, I saw blood up the wall… and then to be told that one of your aunties is in an oak coffin and the other in a pine coffin, but you can’t see them because of their…well. And then to follow two hearses, it was really bad. It is something that stops with you for a long time… to pick on elderly people like this is unforgiveable“. But neither Bierton nor Pluck showed an ounce of compassion or remorse for the two old ladies who lay on the floor, their lives extinguished, and as Bierton ransacked the house while (it was suggested) that Pluck loaded the loot into his van, the two of them took their time, even smoking some cigarettes. Only Bierton hadn’t finished with the sadistic torment he would inflict on Elsie & Aileen’s family. To erase any evidence of their crime, he dragged Aileen’s body into the front room beside her sister, piled every flammable furnishing on top of them, set them alight and left with the house ablaze… …only it failed. With smoke seen by the neighbours as the van sped away, fire-fighters were on the scene in minutes and extinguished the blaze swiftly, so the kitchen, the hall, the doors and upper floor were untouched. The investigation headed up by Detective Superintendent Bob Purdey was thorough and swift; a knife was found with Bierton’s blood, an envelope and a receipt for their gardening had Pluck’s fingerprints, several witnesses had seen both men, a set of false teeth belonging to one of the women was found in the back garden of Pluck’s flat among a pile of burned clothes, and several cigarette butts had been found in and around the house; with several smoked down to the filter (as Pluck smoked his), the rest part smoked and stubbed out (as Bierton smoked his), and several contained both men’s DNA. Quickly arrested, the men denied the killing, being at the house that day and pleaded their innocence, but on the 16th of July, both were charged with ‘murder by joint enterprise’, as “each was a party to a agreement to steal and were jointly involved in the violence and plan to destroy the house by fire”. Tried at Sheffield Crown Court before Justice Jowett, after a four-week trial, on the 31st of May 1996, having deliberated for four hours, unanimously found guilty of murder, they were given life sentences. In 2002 and 2007, Pluck appealed, claiming that fresh DNA evidence only proved that Bierton was at the scene of the murders, and that his ‘prison cell confession’ to child sex offender, Jamie McCann was unreliable. In 2010, his appeal was rejected and his conviction upheld, with Lord Toulson summing up “the natural conclusion for any jury to draw would be that both were guilty of the murders.” On the 8th of February 2012 while serving his sentence at HMP Rye Hill, his solicitor wrote to the Parole Board asking him to be released, as he had three months to live. Five days later, Pluck died of cancer. For many, justice was served, both men served their sentence… …and Laurence Bierton hated every minute of it. After 24 years inside, Bierton was released on licence in December 2017. He was recalled in July 2018 due to drug use, alcoholism and violence, but released in May 2020, as his behaviour had ‘improved’. To ensure that he never returned to prison, he volunteered to wear an alcohol tag, an ankle bracelet which tested his sweat every 30 minutes as monitored by the Probation Service. If removed, damaged, or tests positive, this would be a breach of probation and would result in him being sent back to prison. By November 2020, “following concerns about his association with certain individuals" such as thieves, drunks and psychopaths like himself, the head of Nottinghamshire’s probation delivery unit later stated “it wasn’t appropriate for him to be in approved housing” like halfway houses and hostels, and as they couldn’t send him back to prison, where could they house a double-killer of elderly women? That month, Bierton had his alcohol tag removed as he said it was irritating his skin, something he may have done deliberately by not washing it, and there were ‘unsubstantiated’ rumours he was involved in benefit fraud and using Mamba, a synthetic cannabinoid similar to Spice with side effects like severe paranoia, unpredictable strength and psychosis – a dangerous drug for a violent alcoholic psychopath. His drinking wasn’t regularly monitored, his drug use was speculative, his anger went unrestrained, but these weren’t the deadliest mistakes which led to Bierton murdering another elderly woman. The decision where to house him was later described by the Probation Service as a “serious oversight”. Steve Williams, a church pastor and manager of the Oasis Centre which supports released prisoners were not told of Bierton’s past, “We, like everyone else, just assumed he was an elderly man that was no danger to the community and was subsequently released - we weren't given any information. Why was someone known to be a murderer allowed to be placed in such an area with vulnerable people?” Knowing his history, the Police raised concerns at the risk he posed to the elderly, but their concerns were ignored, and with the tick of a box, a faceless bureaucrat had approved his move to a new home. The location was his home town of Worksop. The accommodation was a one-bedroomed bungalow, as being 62-years-old, it was considered suitable for a man of declining years and health. But the street itself was not. Rayton Spur was a cul-de-sac, a dead-end of council-owned assisted living spaces full of disabled ramps for the vulnerable, infirm and the elderly – it was like putting a fox in the hen house. 73-year-old Pauline Helen Quinn was a mother-of-three and a widow who was happy and caring. Being burdened by COPD (a chronic lung condition) which made it hard to breathe and difficult to walk, so even from her front door to her car, she needed to use a stick. Like Aileen & Elsie, as a trooper, Pauline never let her illness get the better of her as she fought to live as independently as possible; she loved gardening, she kept her house neat, she regularly met friends and went shopping with her dog, Charlie. She lived in a one-bedroom bungalow at 35 Rayton Spur… …but next door at 33 lived Laurence Bierton. Pauline’s brother, Peter, later said “he killed two women, he spent 20 plus years in prison, and then, when he came out, they put him in a house next to my sister. To house a convicted double killer in an area with elderly and vulnerable residents is more than just negligent - it is unforgivable”. Tuesday the 9th of November 2021 was an ordinary day being cold and wet. At 12:55pm, CCTV showed Pauline pulling up in her Reneault Clio outside of her home at Rayton Spur, and carrying her shopping, she took her time as she ascended the disability ramp using the metal railing for support to her door. Again – like Aileen & Elsie – being security conscious, she had door locks, dead bolts, a chain and a spy hole to access any strangers who approached her front door before deciding to open it. And like many elderly citizens, she had a wall-mounted emergency cord which – if she fell, needed help, and couldn’t get to her phone – she could pull it, and day or night, it would instantly connect to monitoring centre. That morning, in the bungalow next door, Bierton wasted his release from prison by getting drunk on rum and vodka which is a sedative; to combat his depressive anger he got high on crack cocaine which it was said “adding alcohol to crack cocaine is like adding a wild card” and becoming severely paranoid – as if his drink and drug use was uncovered, it would lead to his instant recall to prison – he topped it off with Subutex, an opioid used to treat opioid abuse, which mustn’t be mixed with alcohol or crack. By the afternoon, he had ran out of drink, was coming down, and being broke, he wanted money… …and like most foxes, he didn’t need to travel far, when the hens were in the hen house. At around 4pm, Bierton went next door to 35 Rayton Spur, he didn’t knock on Pauline’s front door, as the weak point in the security of most homes is the back door, and their back gardens were connected. As before, he didn’t force entry, he didn’t have to as the door was unlocked. With Pauline weakened by COPD and barely able to breathe, let alone flee, he demanded money. As a strong, independent woman she said no, and being an addict, his violence exploded against this helpless lone pensioner. Just like Elsie & Aileen, he pushed her to the floor, and began a ferocious attack of extreme violence and zero compassion. Where as the sisters were beaten to death with their own flat iron, against this lone and terrified women who was no threat to him, he attacked her using a coffee table. Not the leg, not the top, but the whole table, with Justice Pepperall stating “you used severe force, lifting your weapon high above your head, repeatedly smashing it into her skull with as much force as you could muster… there is no doubt that you intended to kill your victim”, again showing this woman no mercy. As before, his violence was so barbaric, that her blood stained the walls, floor, ceiling and having struck her ten times, she suffered 29 known injuries resulting in 14 separate areas of blunt force trauma, as well as defensive wounds to her arms and hands, and fractures to her face, skull and brain damage. With not an ounce of remorse, he took her purse, he bought some drink, he smashed up the remains of the coffee table, bagged it up, disposed of it, and having stolen her car, he drove it to from Sheffield to Barnsley where (at about 9pm) he gave an unwitting relative a lift, as if nothing had happened. Barely an hour later, Pauline was found unconscious by paramedics… …as somehow, during her final moments alive, she had pulled the emergency cord. With all calls being monitored, a recording captured the sounds of Pauline being attacked by Bierton, as over the hubbub of the television, several loud thuds can be heard, as he repeatedly beat her to death with the table. Pauline Quinn died of her injuries, and the next day at 10:37am, Laurence Bierton was arrested. For the investigators, the similarity between the murder of Pauline Quinn to those of the sisters, Aileen Dudill & Elsie Gregory were striking. Questioned at Sheffield's Shepcote Lane Police Station, Bierton admitted he was alcohol dependent, had smoked crack, and during his interviews, he answered “no comment” to every question, he denied any wrongdoing, but did state he hit her “to keep her quiet". The two week trial was held at Nottingham Crown Court before Justice Pepperall in December 2023. Prosecutor John Cammegh KC stated “what is unusual about this case is that he admits that he killed the deceased. What he did is not in issue. The issue for you to decide will be whether or not he was of diminished responsibility at the time”, with Bierton’s Defence counsel, Mark McKone KC stating that his “alcohol dependency… constituted a mental abnormality”, preventing him from thinking rationally. Bierton admitted to a charge of theft, but denied the wilful murder of Pauline Quinn. (End) Pauline daughter Lisa stated “I don’t believe there is a punishment that could ever compare to what he has caused with his cruelty. He stole her life and ruined ours in the process. He is a monster”. As part of his defence, Bierton stated that (unlike before) “he recognises the impact his offending had on many people… and wants to spend the remainder of his life doing good” by being a teacher in prison. On Thursday the 14th of December 2023, the jury deliberated, and returned in less than an hour. They rejected the defence that his alcohol withdrawal had caused a ‘mental abnormality’, they accepted that the aftermath of the murder – the theft of the car, trip to Sheffield, and destroying of the murder weapon – proved these were the cruel and callous actions of a man who was calm and calculated. Even without the benefit of knowing about his past crimes – including the brutal double murder of sisters, Aileen & Elsie, and being sentenced to life in prison – the jury found him guilty of wilful murder. Summing up, Justice Pepperall said “you have been found guilty of the senseless and brutal murder of three elderly and disabled women. You showed each victim no mercy. I am left in no doubt that you must never again be given the opportunity to walk the streets. The only just sentence in this case is that you should remain in prison for the rest of your life”. Bierton was given a whole-life order. The Judge also described the decision to house this violent psychopath at Rayton Spur as “flawed… Ms Quinn was entitled to expect better, and the system plainly failed her”, but no-one was convicted or found guilty of this horrifying error which let a killer of old women live amongst his potential victims. The Probation Service conducted a review, and subsequently; alcohol tags became mandatory if a probation officer feels that drinking would lead to reoffending, independent senior managers chair risk-assessment panels to assess prisoners who serve life sentences, and although the Probation Service stated “we are sorry for the unacceptable failings in this case, our thoughts remain with the family of Pauline Quinn”, only one person was reprimanded, and they received a just formal warning. The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of.
Eight time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
On the 14th of November 2002. 14-year-old Adam Morrell of Loughborough in Leicestershire told his dad he was going to stay at his friends’ house, something that boys do every day in every city. But with the group growing bored, it said, that his death was decided by a childish game of Rock, Paper, Scissors, and after two days of torture, his body was scattered across the canal and fields, with no all of it found. But what kind of animals would do this to a child?
SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/leicestershire/3588884.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/leicestershire/2971460.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/2505911.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/2505661.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/2505661.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/leicestershire/3239546.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/leicestershire/3241126.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/2837935.stm https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2003/dec/04/ukcrime.gerardseenan https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/1413880/Body-parts-murder-victim-named.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/teenager-s-body-parts-dumped-in-canal-after-torture-78114.html https://www.standard.co.uk/hp/front/policemans-son-jailed-for-life-6951872.html https://uk.news.yahoo.com/woman-fell-love-killer-spent-115043802.html https://www.irishexaminer.com/world/arid-10100289.html https://www.thesun.co.uk/fabulous/28339326/ghosted-prison-murderer-fiance/ https://www.thetimes.com/travel/destinations/uk-travel/lovable-rogue-14-tortured-and-killed-6zdwrmxjc05 https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/gang-leader-convicted-of-torturing-boy-14-to-death-81067.html https://www.standard.co.uk/hp/front/policemans-son-faces-life-for-murder-of-boy-14-7233214.html https://www.irishexaminer.com/world/arid-10126032.html https://www.thefreelibrary.com/I+kicked+Adam+a+number+of+times+to+the+head%2C+chest+and+legs.+He...-a0110999622 http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/leicestershire/3246846.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/leicestershire/6755605.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/leicestershire/3327831.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/leicestershire/3244384.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/2501905.stm MUSIC:
UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT: Welcome to Murder Mile: Unleashed. (Engine) And I’m away. Goodbye London. Hello Britain. And as I cruise the UK’s canal network in my little boat, I shall bring you true crime cases from the cities, towns and villages I visit. This week, I’m in Loughborough in Leicestershire, where a group of so-called ‘friends’ tortured a boy for their own fun. My name is Michael, I am your tour guide, and this is Murder Mile. Episode 371: Rock, Paper, Scissors, Death. Saturday the 7th of June 2003 was wet and drizzly as a low dark cloud hung over the market town of Loughborough. It had been seven months since the horror on Havelock Street had shocked the locals to their very core, yet still the pain and disbelief was as raw as before, and as they stood with heads bowed in solemn silence to pay their last respects, a black horse-drawn carriage carried the body of 14-year-old Adam from All Saints Church to Loughborough Cemetery… only his body was incomplete. The service by Reverend Stephen Cherry spoke of a boy who was ‘fun’, ‘cheeky’ and a ‘loveable rogue’. With standing room only and mourners spilling out into the courtyard, the funeral was full of Adam’s family and loved-ones, but four of his so-called ‘friends’ were rightfully absent, and for good reason. Seeing the small coffin of her ‘ray of sunshine’ for the final time, Dawn, Adam’s loving mother would later comment "I would rather it was me than him, but I cannot turn the clock back. It was horrendous. I was praying they had made a mistake but I knew in my heart of hearts it was him". No mother should have to go through what she did. Motherhood is stressful, hard but rewarding, sometimes its painful and full of worry and hope, but because of the cruelty and callousness of four people – not just during the killing, but also in court – she endured impossible levels of pain, and scars which would never heal. The story of Adam’s final days was one which was perfectly summed up by Dawn’s own thought which would haunt her for forever, "how anyone could do that to another human being is beyond me?"… …but they did, and they claimed to be his friends. Adam Morrell was born on the 12th of October 1988 in Leicester, the same month that the must-have pre-Christmas toys for boys hitting the shelves were Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Transformers and Micro Machines. As a small sweet-natured boy who was blessed with a charm which could break your heart, his mum said "Adam was happy-go-lucky and would have done anything for anybody”, but this wasn’t just a mum doing as mum’s do and seeing only the best in her son, those who knew him agreed, he was bubbly with a lively smile, outgoing, sensitive and articulate being a boy who loved to talk. At primary school, he began to discover his passions; fishing, wrestling, he was keen on drama, and he had a love of animals especially his dog Maya. Like everyone, at that age, he was finding himself; who he was, what he liked and what he wanted to be, alongside the trickiest of life’s issues, making friends. Before the turn of the millennium, Adam went to Limehurst Secondary School in Loughborough, and as happens to many of us, as he entered those difficult pre-pubescent years, he struggled as many do. A few years later, as sadly occurs in many relationships, his parents separated, he had moved in with his mother, Dawn, but since March 2001 he was living with his dad, barman Shaun Smith, and although they did their best to maintain some semblance of stability for him, it’s hard for a child to adapt to a change to the one and only constant that they have had in their short but safe life - a mum and a dad. Having been expelled several times and described as a ‘handful’ at home, Adam attended the student support centre, where unit leader, Jacinta Barnard stated "when he first came, we certainly knew he had arrived and we had a tough job ahead of us”, but keen to learn and succeed, “he made enormous progress… and his reading age increased by three years over seven months. Adam brought life and laughter to our base with his loud and vivacious personality… he showed great promise and maturity”. Some boys don’t realise (or choose to see) their mistakes or take advantage of the opportunity in front of them, but Adam did and he was turning his life around at this critical juncture in his formative years. He could be anything he wanted to be and having never been in ‘any real trouble’, like all of us, he wanted to be liked, he wanted to be happy, and was looking for a like-minded group to hang out with… …he was finding his real friends. Thursday 14th of November 2002 was an ordinary day in the life of 14-year-old Adam Morrell, as it was for the roughly 13,000 teenagers in Loughborough. That day, Adam went out to the skate park as he often did, and being a good lad, he phoned his dad to ask for permission to stay at his friend’s house. That night, he went with his friends to the Loughborough Fair, a traditional historic street fair which dates back to a royal charter as granted by King Henry III in 1221. Built across its historic streets and public spaces like Market Place, this family fair had a mix of rides like Waltzer’s, dodgems and bouncy castles; food stuffs such as e-number explosions like candy floss, burgers of a very questionable meaty origin and hot sugary doughnuts which are absolutely delicious for six whole seconds, and then rank. As far as we know, Adam had a fun night-out, and was living his life as any young boy should… …but seen alive for the very last time, he went back to the house of his ‘friends’. The journey from Market Place was barely half a mile, it was uneventful as the group of five; Matthew, Nathan, Sarah, Daniel and Adam headed back to Matthew’s house; a thin two-storey, end-terrace, ex-miner’s cottage at 72 Havelock Street on a quiet residential street, which he was sharing with Nathan. Nestled in the borough of Charnwood at the rear of Loughborough Hospital, not far from Cumberland Field and the basin end of the Grand Union Canal, 72 Havelock Street is one of the last of the old buildings which once covered this street as it was replaced by a newer estate. And although, a cheap two-bedroomed house which had seen better days, it’s now remembered as a house of horrors. We’ll never know what really happened, as all of Adam’s so-called ‘friends’ lied and even bastardised the truth to save their own skin, and with not a single care for Adam’s life, his feelings or his grieving mother who as they refused to spare her the trauma of admitting their guilt, she would have to endure weeks in court, listening to what these monsters did to her only son in his last days alive… …this gang of four squabbled over who did what to this young boy, to lessen their sentences. When you think of a gang of yobs, you probably imagine a gaggle of barely literate knuckle-scrapers identically dressed in grey Terry towelling tracksuits (bought from Mothercare), trying to look moody but coming across as constipated, banging on about “the mean streets of Compton” yet they live in a town more akin to Trumpton, constantly grabbing their crotches like they’ve got crabs, making gun signs with their fingers like four-year-olds who’ve lost their toys, and muttering ‘you get me’ every six seconds, because when they mumble their utter gibberish, nobody does. But this gang was ordinary. Detective Superintendent Bob Small of Leicestershire CID stated “you could not profile them before this offence to say that they were potentially dangerous. It is just the lethal combination on the night”. Dumbarton-born Matthew Joseph Welsh was 18-year-old. As the son of a constable at nearby Burton-on-Trent Police Station, Welsh had lived at Stapenhill in Staffordshire before moving to Loughborough, and although – like Adam – he had his issues, where-as Adam strived to do better, described as having “tendencies to violence with previous convictions for theft, affray and criminal damage”, the judge at the trial called him “a psychopath with sadistic tendencies”, but being high on his own self-importance among this gaggle of weaklings, it is said he was ringleader of the orchestrated violence against Adam. Oddly, having been bullied by other boys, Adam had met Welsh, who was teaching him ‘self-defence’. Welsh then introduced Adam to his best friend, 26-year-old Nathan Luke Barnett, who was living with Welsh on Havelock Street. But suffering from Asperger's Syndrome, a neurodevelopmental disorder, and having a strong homosexual attraction to Welsh – it was said – that made him “susceptible to be influenced by others”, especially Welsh who he was 'infatuated' with - which created its own conflict. The dynamic of the group was described in court as “a bad mix of chemistry; the wrong people in the wrong place at the wrong time”, and having met 16-year-old Sarah Morris – a once promising athlete who was vulnerable, immature and struggling with her own psychological problems – as Welsh’s new girlfriend, having been living in a homeless hostel just two weeks before, Morris moved in. Being new to the group, 18-year-old Daniel John Biggs was still an outsider, but with 14-year-old Adam having only spent the night there two or three times, he was now the smallest, youngest and most vulnerable. Later that evening, having been to the fair, the group entered 72 Havelock Street… …and began one of the most brutal and harrowing incidents in Loughborough’s history. As stated, in court; Welsh the gang’s ringleader, Barnett his wannabe gay lover, Morris his emotionally vulnerable girlfriend and Biggs who had been the newbie, would bicker over who did what to Adam. With Morris described by her defence as “not a player in that household nor a dominant character”, her statement was seen as a nearer-to-the-truth of what may have happened, so much of it was used in evidence at the trial. But they all participated in some way, and not one of them protected Adam. As Detective Superintendent Bob Small who headed up the investigation stated ”I don't know what the argument with Adam was about - if there was an argument at all”. What was known was that the group, excluding Adam, were drinking beer and whisky, smoking cannabis and taking a form of ecstasy known as 'Bin Ladens', which - like all drugs made on a dirty halfwits kitchen hob – is bulked-out with all manner of fillers like bath salts, starch, acids or whatever’s cheap, with its side-effects highly toxic. But drugs shouldn’t be blamed for the cruel actions of these monsters, as they were all responsible. DS Small said it erupted “because basically (Adam) was whingeing” - whether about his girlfriend, or as Sarah said he ruined their high “and was bringing us all down”, or it was even suggested that Adam had threatened to go to the Police over their drug use, as being mature he realised they weren’t the friends for him – and with Welsh growing annoyed, DS Small said “It was almost like a mob mentality”. In court, with no-one able to explain why they turned on 14-year-old Adam; one theory was that with Welsh as the ringleader, Barnett was eager to impress him and saw young, pretty Adam as a threat? Or that the mix of chemicals and conflict was already a volatile mix? But a criminologist suggested that “as the youngest and weakest, the group may have targeted him to deflect tensions from themselves”. In short, they were all cowards, who let a young boy be brutally tortured to death, to save themselves. I warn you now, if you can’t listen to acts of cruelty, fast forward this episode a few minutes. But don’t forget, as the gang squabbled in court to lessen their sentence, Dawn, Adam’s mother had to listen to these details being retold, and likely saw the crime scene photos, all because this gang of selfish losers. It was said, the first attack on Adam lasted two or three hours. The jury were told that as the first punches hit him, Adam shrieked in pain, pleading for help, but his cries were coldly ignored as this pack of laughing hyenas attacked their prey, raining down blows on the little boy who was curled up into a ball, as from all sides, he was punched, kicked and stamped on. Morris said she was urged (if not, ordered) to participate in the beating, and Biggs said he only watched and then went to a homeless hostel, but none of them stopped it. In her account, Morris admitted “I kicked Adam a number of times to the head, chest and legs for about three to four minutes. They were football-style kicks. Some were stamps”, and as the small boy was beaten and “drifted in and out of consciousness, each time he fell to the floor like a rag doll, they picked him up and beat him again”. Morris later told Police, that having kicked his head like a football, with his face all discoloured and swollen, “he looked like an alien”, only the helpless boy wasn’t dead, but probably wished he was. When one attacker got tired, they rested, as the others carried on. Mr Justice Morland would state “(Adam) was befriended by you four. Befriended is a totally inappropriate word to describe the callous manner in which he was treated with barbaric cruelty… he was repeatedly assaulted, kicked, punched and stamped on. He sustained multiple injuries so that he was unrecognisable. None of you had the decency to stop the prolonged savagery of the beating or the humanity to see he got medical help". And as Morris claimed “at about three in the morning I went to bed”, although, how anyone could sleep having witnessed and participated in such a savage attack. But for Adam, although he lay broken, swollen, alone and afraid, with only his torturers hearing his tears, no-one would come to his aid… …and his torture was only beginning. The next day, Friday 15th of November, having subjected Adam to another prolonged beating (which it’s a miracle he survived), as if nothing had happened, Welsh, Biggs & Morris went back to the funfair. They’d had their fun in more ways than one, and while they were away, it was said, Barnett, Welsh’s wannabe lover being eager to impress, went to the kitchen and added water and sugar to the kettle. The gang claimed when they returned - high on drink, drugs and adrenaline – Barnett had already heated the mixture till it was boiling hot and as Adam lay broken on the mattress, he poured it on his chest and back. When boiled, the sugar becomes a sticky, super-hot syrup which hardens to the skin, burning deeper and longer through the skin’s layers, causing severe burns, infection and intense pain. But not one of them called an ambulance as he writhed in an agony we couldn’t even begin to imagine, instead, if this is even true, Morris claims that “Biggs said 'Let's kill him, it will be fun, let's kill him'”… …and so they did. Regardless of who they claim did what, they all killed him either through beatings, or neglect, or self-preservation. It was said, but never be proven, that the decision of who would kill 14-year-old Adam Morrell – between Biggs and Barnett - was done by a game of Rock, Paper, Scissors In court, Sir Ivan Lawrence QC defending Daniel Biggs, said “this was a lie aimed at protecting co-defendant, Matthew Welsh. He said Nathan Barnett had written a series of letters to Welsh in prison, saying he wanted to see Biggs suffer”. Sir Ivan asked jurors: “‘How far can you trust the word of a man who deliberately killed Adam with his bare hands? He hates Biggs. Barnett was infatuated with Welsh”, but what was agreed was that, although Nathan Barnett, Welsh’s best friend admitted to the bulk of the murder and disposal of Adam’s body, the judge said “I’m satisfied that Welsh ‘called the shots’. Morris stated “On Saturday (16th)”, roughly 45 hours after Adam was first beaten, and maybe a day since he had been burned by the super-heated sugar, “between 4pm and 6pm, Adam was in Nathan's room. I heard Adam choking. Nathan came back into our room and said Adam was dead. I went into Nathan's room and he had crossed Adam's arms over his chest. I will never forget that memory”. Adam Morell had suffered 280 individual injuries, including breaks, fractures and burns, which left him unrecognisable. And again, without an ounce of remorse for this dead boy or his soon-to-be grieving mum, as the so-called ringleader of this pathetic rabble of cowardly wastrels who only thought about themselves, Welsh said “I’m going to phone my dad because he’ll know what to do, he’s a policeman”. It was never stated if the call was made, if the statement was true, or his dad was involved or informed. But what was clear was that there was no dignity in Adam’s assault, his torture, his murder, or in the disposal of his body. In the same way they had gleefully kicked his head like it was a football, he was just an object; something to be used, abused, and then got rid off when they were done and had their fun. And as the only evidence of their crime was him and his blood, they set about erasing it for good. Morris recalled of Barnett, “Nathan carried him and put him in the bath”. He left the house, and having walked to the B&Q store on Jubilee Drive “he came back with two saws. He asked Danny” meaning Daniel Biggs, “if they would be sharp enough. Danny said 'yes'. I heard the sound of sawing and turned up my music”, to drown out the sounds of abject horror, just as the bath taps drained away his blood. “One hour later Nathan said he’d cut off a leg and an arm, and that he still had one arm and the head to go”, in a dismemberment which took several hours. And summing up his callous cruelty, Morris said of Nathan Barnett “then he had a cigarette”. The head, legs and arms were wrapped in black plastic bags, sealed in electrical tape, and dumped across the town, where they hoped they’d never be found, as the rest of the gang frantically cleaned-up the crime scene, erasing any proof of their patheticness. In court, the Justice Morland asked Nathan Barnett “what had Adam done to deserve this fate?”, as Welsh’s loyal henchman, he replied “nothing”, recalling that he had chuckled as he cut up the body. Everything about this gang of halfwits was incompetent… …from their clean-up, to the disposal, to their lies. The next day, on Sunday the 17th of November at around 3pm, a group out walking spotted a black plastic bag floating in the water near Canal Bank, at the junction between the Grand Union Canal and Loughborough Canal Basin, not far from Havelock Street. Fishing it out near Belton Road bridge, they saw what looked like the fingers of an arm the Police thought was that of a girl being small and hairless. Keith Hartley, landlord of the nearby Albion Inn said "it is not an every day occurrence, but we do see rubbish that floats down the canal all the time", just not body parts. A full-scale investigation was set-up with the area cordoned off, and underwater search teams checking its murky depths by hand. Detective Superintendent Small appealed for witnesses, but over the next few days, so chaotically was the body dumped, that the rest was easily found; a bag of bloody clothes by an electricity sub-station, the legs in a nearby field and the head in another part of the canal, but one arm was never recovered. John Brindley, editor of the Loughborough Echo said “we regard Loughborough as a very ordinary and prosperous town and the brutality took everyone completely by surprise”, especially when, to aid the search, the town’s mayor, Debbie Green, asked residents to check their bins for body parts. She said, "you don't expect to see it on your doorstep - you always expect it to happen elsewhere". Not here. As for Adam’s family, they not only had to deal with his disappearance, then his discovery, and then the facts about his beating, his torture, his murder and his disposal, and later relive it all again in court. It made no sense, as this was the kind of killing reserved for gangland criminals, and yet, 14-year-old schoolboy Adam was just a “cheeky, chatty, likeable lad” who went to the fair with his so-called pals. Detective Superintendent Bob Small said “at the moment, Adam's parents are shell-shocked, and it has not sunk in yet, but have conducted themselves with the utmost dignity”… unlike Adam’s killers. With word spreading like wildfire, as Welsh, Morris, Biggs & Barnett each knew that – as they were last seen alive with Adam, heading towards the house on Havelock Street, just hours before his death - that they would be suspected, rather than coming clean, Welsh coerced Barnett (who had Aspergers) to go to the Police and take the blame while the others concocted a tale to minimise their involvement. They even went so far as to all agree that “Adam was killed by Barnett in a churchyard before being taken to the canal bridge where his body was cut up”, but with a wealth of evidence against them all – CCTV at the fair, B&Q and the streets around the canal, but also a mix of DNA, blood, hair and skin found at the badly cleaned-up crime scene – their involvement was proven, but to what extent? On Saturday the 23rd of November 2002, just nine days after the first attack on Adam, all four suspects were arrested on suspicion of murder. Appearing at Loughborough Magistrates Court, Welsh, Barnett & Biggs were remanded in custody, but owing to her age, Morris was held in secure accommodation. The initial hearings were held at nearby Leicester Crown Court before Judge Michael Stokes QC, but seeking an impartial jury who may not have been so angered and outraged at their barbaric crimes, the trial was moved to Nottingham Crown Court, under the watchful gaze of Adam’s mum. (End) The four-week trial began in November 2003, before Mr Justice Morland. All four pleaded guilty to conspiring to pervert the course of justice, but they all blamed the others to minimise their actions. Matthew Welsh plead guilty to GBH without intent and not guilty to murder, as did Sarah Morris, Daniel Biggs denied murder and GBH, and Nathan Barnett admitted to manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility owing to his Asperger’s. In court, it was said that Morris was the only one who had shown any remorse, but the trial still became a blame game, as the evidence was rehashed again and again, as Adam’s mother had to sit though all four version of their alibis, reliving her pain. On 17th of December 2003; 19-year-old Daniel Biggs was cleared of murder and GHB, but convicted of conspiring to pervert the course of justice, he was sentenced to two-and-a-half years. The judge told him: "I ignore the fact that by your own admission you watched Adam being pulverised for two hours, and did nothing about it. I accept that you were scared of Matthew Welsh". 17-year-old Sarah Morris was cleared of murder, but sentenced to four years for GBH and conspiring to pervert the course of justice. 27-year-old Nathan Barnett was told “I am satisfied that you are very dangerous", so lacking empathy and being easily led, Barnett was detained indefinitely under the Mental Health Act. So far, none of the gang were found guilty of Adam’s murder, until it came to the ring-leader, 19-year-old Matthew Welsh. The judge and jury decided “it was you who took the decision to kill the boy after a night of barbaric cruelty” and for his crimes was given a life sentence with a minimum of 20 years. Summing up, Justice Moreland stated “You, Welsh, called the shots. You decided that Barnett, then aged 26 but mentally abnormal, would strangle Adam Morrell. Barnett is infatuated by you and did as he was told. No doubt to some extent the callous selfishness of all four of you can be part explained from your dysfunctional family background and by the drink and drugs that you took during this time”. 23 years on, all four have been released, with it is said online “after 3 months out, (Welsh) was recalled for bad behaviour. He's currently staying at an approved premises in Leicester… he’s high risk and not allowed near children, and having had a secret relationship with two young women while in prison”, one of whom stated to the national papers, "I feel like he groomed me, used me”, something he does. As of today, Dawn, Adam’s mother has attempted to rebuild her life, and told BBC Radio Leicester, “He is in my thoughts every day, when I wake up and when I go to sleep", describing the emotional turmoil she was put through by four selfish criminals as "a living hell… but now I have a new lease on life because I have something to aim for. I am aiming to make a difference in Loughborough”, having fought to create of a youth centre for teenagers in Loughborough “to help them stay out of trouble". The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of.
Eight time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
EPISODE THREE HUNDRED AND SEVENTY: On Friday the 3rd of August 1951, 49-year-old housewife, Mabel Tattershaw went out on a date with 19-year-old Herbert Mills. She was smitten with him, but as a chronic gambler who was obsessed with making an easy fortune, smashing the authorities and beating the odds, she had no idea that she would be the part of his plan to place the biggest gamble of his life.
SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cr4935yvy6vo Southern Daily Echo Thu, Nov 22, 1951 Coventry Evening Telegraph Sat, Aug 25, 1951 Daily Mirror Thu, Sep 20, 1951 Hull Daily Mail Thu, Sep 20, 1951 Lincolnshire Echo Wed, Sep 19, 1951 The Daily Telegraph Thu, Sep 20, 1951 Worcester News Sat, Dec 08, 1951 Dorset Echo Tue, Dec 11, 1951 Daily Echo Wed, Sep 19, 1951 Evening News and Star (Late Final ed.) Tue, Dec 11, 1951 Sunderland Echo Thu, Sep 20, 1951 Leicester Mercury Thu, Nov 22, 1951 The Bolton News Tue, Dec 11, 1951 Evening Chronicle Wed, Nov 21, 1951 Bristol Evening World Thu, Sep 20, 1951 The Guardian Thu, Sep 20, 1951 The Birmingham Post Fri, Nov 23, 1951 Leicester Evening Mail Tue, Nov 20, 1951 The Argus Thu, Nov 22, 1951 The Guardian Journal Wed, Oct 13, 1965 The Guardian Journal Wed, Apr 04, 1973 Nottingham Evening News Sat, Sep 01, 1962 The Guardian Journal Wed, Apr 11, 1973 Sunderland Daily Echo and Shipping Gazette - Friday, 10 August 1951 Belfast News-Letter Thursday, 23 August 1951 Daily Herald Wednesday, 21 November 1951 Daily Express Thursday, 23 August 1951 Bradford Observer Friday, 10 August 1951 Bexhill-on-Sea Observer Saturday, 1 September 1951 Bradford Observer Thursday, 23 August 1951 Daily Express - Tuesday, 14 August 1951 Daily Herald - Saturday, 11 August 1951 Leicester Evening Mail - Saturday, 1 September 1951 Bradford Observer - Saturday, 11 August 1951 Western Daily Press - Monday, 3 December 1951 Daily Herald - Monday, 20 August 1951 Aberdeen Evening Express - Saturday, 11 August 1951 Coventry Evening Telegraph - Saturday, 25 August 1951 Yorkshire Post and Leeds Intelligencer - Monday, 13 August 1951 Coventry Evening Telegraph - Wednesday, 19 September 1951 Leicester Evening Mail - Tuesday, 14 August 1951 Aberdeen Evening Express - Tuesday, 20 November 1951 Gloucester Citizen - Friday, 10 August 1951 Leicester Daily Mercury - Friday, 10 August 1951 Bristol Evening Post - Friday, 10 August 1951 Torbay Express and South Devon Echo - Friday, 10 August 1951 Grimsby Daily Telegraph - Friday, 10 August 1951 Staffordshire Sentinel - Friday, 10 August 1951 Scunthorpe Evening Telegraph - Friday, 10 August 1951 Huddersfield Daily Examiner - Friday, 10 August 1951 MUSIC:
UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT: Welcome to Murder Mile: Unleashed. (Engine) And I’m away. Goodbye London. Hello Britain. And as I cruise the UK’s canal network in my little boat, I shall bring you true crime cases from the cities, towns and villages I visit. This week, I’m in Nottingham, where a killer made a bet by confessing to a killing in the hope of winning big, but lost. My name is Michael, I am your tour guide, and this is Murder Mile. Episode 370: The Biggest Gamble. The year was 1951, the war was over, but rationing was still in-force. Mabel Tattershaw wasn’t a gambler, she didn’t have the luxury of a disposable income, as being a 49-year-old housewife who was single-handedly raising her two daughters (Nora aged 14 and Lilian aged 16) while her husband was serving time in prison, the toughness of her life was etched across her tired face and body, being a woman of hard work and hardship whose life was a daily grind and struggle. In the only photograph published of Mabel, she looks like the epitome of weary, as if the ravages of her life have drained and rung her dry; her short dark hair (often) tied in a headscarf like all she ever did was clean, her nails worn down from a lifetime of scrubbing, her limbs skinny from bad war-time nutrition, and with more wrinkles than she had teeth, Mabel looked a lot older than her years belied. Described as quiet, kind and sociable, by day (as she no longer worked as a cleaner at Nottingham City Hospital) she earned a modest wage renting out rooms to lodgers - which may seem odd as it was said her daughters had been taken into care having been seduced by a former tenant – but she had to earn to live to eat, and with very little love, her only enjoyment was a pint at the pub or a trip to the cinema. F Donal Barry for the Prosecution said “there could be little or no reason for destroying so inoffensive a person”, but someone did, and they would do it for the most cruel and arrogant of motives… a bet. Thursday the 2nd of August 1951 was Mabel’s night to go to the cinema; she ate a frugal dinner, at 6pm she left her home on Longmead Drive in Woodthorpe two miles north of the city centre, and headed two streets north-east to The Roxy at 2 Ribblesdale Road, at the junction of Mansfield Road. Accompanied by her friend and lodger, Lily Wilson, it’s uncertain what they watched, but out that week across the UK were Walt Disney’s ‘Alice in Wonderland’, ‘No Highway (in the Sky)’ an aviation thriller starring James Stewart, and the Ealing Comedy, ‘The Lavender Hill Mob’ starring Alec Guinness. Sat together, her friend Lily Wilson later told Police, “I saw that Mabel was talking to the person next to her. He was a man, I can’t described him, I didn’t take much notice of him”, and that was how they met - by chance. When interviewed, the man confirmed this, “I went to the Roxy, someone sat down next to me. She commenced to speak to me. I do not remember what she was saying. I think it was an attempt to converse with me. She wished me to meet her… I did not wish to, but eventually agreed”. Whether he initiated it or not will forever remain unknown, but downtrodden housewife, Mabel Tattershaw was getting attention from a young and handsome man, and she liked it. But that night, he brutally murdered her… …as the killer make the biggest gamble of his life. Her date was Herbert Leonard Mills, a slim, well-groomed and nattily-dressed former dispatch clerk who, at just 19-year-old, was 30 years her junior, but many mistook him as older owing to his style and old-fashioned demeanour. Describing himself as “sensitive and poetic”, Herbert Mills was a loner, a dreamer who loved reading and writing prose and was never without a book of poems by Shelley. Like Mabel, his life had its own hardships; his mother died when was a child, he lived unhappily with his father and stepmother, born with rickets – a deformity of the legs caused by severe malnutritian which meant he spent his childhood wearing leg irons and being bullied – he still walked with a limp, and struggling to hold down a dead-end job, he was now unemployed and living with his grandparents. His only joy was gambling, he bet on horses and bragged that he made more than he lost - at one time claiming he had won £1500 (roughly £60,000 today) – and with nothing else in his life; no career, no girlfriend and no prospects, just a desire to win and (like most gamblers) a lot of misplaced confidence, far from looking like a coldblooded killer, those who met Herbert Mills saw him as nothing but a lonely exhibitionist obsessed with making an easy fortune, defying the authorities, and beating the odds. That year, Mills would place the ultimate bet… and it began on a date with Mabel. The next night, as agreed, Mills & Mabel met. Keen to make a good impression on this man she clearly liked, her lodgers said Mabel was a bag of nerves as she did her make-up and hair to make herself look younger, and dressed in a blue flowered dress, an old overcoat, grey stockings, crepe soled shoes and a coloured necklace of plastic beads, she left home at 5pm, never to be seen alive by her loved ones. At the inquest, Mills wouldn’t deny meeting Mabel that night, but being the epitome of arrogance, he claimed “I expected her to be younger and (prettier)” having only seen each other in a dark cinema, but when two school friends saw him stepping out with a shabbily dressed woman, old enough to be his mother or even his grandmother, he admitted “I felt ashamed”. So did this make her disposable? Mabel was reported missing by the morning, but across the next six days, with no-one believing that she was dead just absent, as she wasn’t depressed or suicidal, and with no witnesses to any foul play, the police regarded her as a missing person and the press reports spoke only of her disappearance. As misinformation spread, possible sightings of Mabel gave her family a false hope; as police checked lodging houses in the Mansfield Road area to see if she had stayed over, and it was reported on Sunday 5th of August at 5pm – 45 hours after her death - Mabel was somehow seen two miles south at Forrest Recreation Ground with a man with a limp, but this one was “50 years old, medium build, moustached, a scar under his right eye, fresh complexion, in a black suit, black Trilby hat, blue tie and brown shoes”. The man wasn’t Herbert Mills, just as the woman accompanying the limping moustachioed man was not Mabel Tattershaw, but with the Police not even considering this as a crime - where-as other killers would jump for joy that they had got away with the perfect murder - it proved problematic for Mills… …as having hidden Mabel’s body a little too well - to win his bet - he needed it to be found. Given the timings, it’s unproven but likely that Mabel & Mills went to The Roxy that night as planned. Afterwards, needing to lure this lonely lady who was charmed by the affections of this younger man, with dusk at 9:23pm, it was around this point that she willingly went with him to ‘the jungle’, a series of abandoned clay pits, disused brickyards and derelict orchards just to the side of nearby Woodthorpe Park. It may not seem like the most romantic of spots to take her, but this was a lover’s lane where it was known that couples went to kiss, cuddle and have sex, but MIlls had something else on his mind. Under the quiet seclusion of twinkling stars and an almost new moon, with no-one about, Mills recalled “we walked up a path and branched off to the right”. Finding a comfortable spot on the grass “she took off her coat and lay down”. Seeing her coloured beaded necklace, “I asked her if I could have it. I was interested In plastic, or rather I thought it might interfere with my little crime and intentions. She broke the beads from her neck to give to me and I tied them. She was a very simple woman”. The night was cold, she shivered, Mills recalled ”I covered her with her own coat, then my own coat”, which seemed like a kindly gesture, but it had a much darker motive. “She had her eyes closed” as if she was awaiting his tender kiss… but instead, he violently punched her in the face, again and again, smashing her nose, her teeth and her eye sockets, so her face was a swollen and unrecognisable mess of reds, blacks and purples, as blood burst through her pale skin, so no hint of white could be seen. But Mills wasn’t finished with his murderous ‘masterpiece’. “I put on a pair of gloves”, and as she was still conscious, “I knelt my knees on her shoulders. She was trying to claw at me, but… the coats were placed so that she would not clutch or gather any threads within her fingernails. I was very pleased. I think I did it rather well”. And placing his gloved hands around her neck, arrogantly he would crow to the press and the police “the strangling itself was quite easily accomplished. I examined the contents of her pockets which I replaced. I slid her down the bank, then covered the coat over her, and left”. Hidden down an eight-foot gully thick with dense nettles and thorns, he had too effectively disposed of her body, and although – in order for his plan to work - he needed to deny, then confess to killing her – he made it clear “I had not interfered with her in any way”, as if the very thought disgusted him. He walked back to his grandparents house and began to plan how he could profit from her death… …but with Mabel only missing and the body not yet found, with the Police looking elsewhere and the press (as he said) writing ‘silly stories’ about a moustachioed man with a limp, he took his next big risk. In court, Mabel was described by the Prosecution as “a woman of small significance… you may take the view that his mind was such that this reason appeared to him a significant motive”; a woman who he had no connection to and no-one would suspect, but later stating with a sense of self-importance, “I made a study of murders… I found the perfect victim for the perfect murder. No motive. No clues”. And for a lonely fantasist like Mills who loved attention, the press would give him what he wanted. Thursday 9th of August at 11:30am, six days after her murder, from a phone-box, Mills called Norman Rae, chief reporter at the News of the World. He gave his name ‘Herbert Mills’, his job ‘poet’, said “I’ve found a body of a missing woman” asking “what price will you pay for information about her murder?” Telling the interested reporter who regularly got calls from cranks as well as confessions from culprits, Mills said “it looked like the perfect murder, there were no clues”. Mills offered to sell the exclusive for £200 to £300, and as Rae recalled “his scheme was that he would keep quiet about this until I had arrived in Nottingham with a photographer… so we could get some pictures of him at the crime scene”. Smelling something rotten but also eager for the scoop, Rae recalled “I told him that the police should know at once. He refused to give information to the police and said he would try another newspaper. Mills indicated that whatever I said he had said, he would deny”, but having come to an agreement that if the News of the World were satisfied, they “would see him alright”, Rae called Nottingham CID, the phone-box was traced, and a few minutes later, Mills was met by Detective Sergeant Burrows. He didn’t run and wasn’t arrested, as being merely a man who may have ‘found’ a body, showing them the plastic necklace Mabel had worn, Mills directed the detective (and later the press) to ‘the jungle’. Part One of his plan was complete; ‘find’ the body. Part Two would be to make everyone suspect him of her murder. And with it all mapped out to the finest details, by Part Three, at his trial, Herbert Mills would be acquitted of the killing of Mabel Tattershaw, and then made famously wealthy by the press. It was the biggest gamble of his life… …and he felt it was a dead-cert that it would succeed. That afternoon, Mills led detectives to the old orchard in ‘the jungle’, where he said on Wednesday the 8th of August about midday “I went to read poetry and pick raspberries”, and down an 8-foot gully, just as he had described it, there it was, the bloody body of Mabel Tattershaw, covered in her coat. First he said he found the plastic necklace, then her pale white face, and stated “I was quite shocked. I recognised the woman”, but decided not to go to the Police, coldly stating “after thinking it over again, I thought it possible to sell the story to the News of the World… I felt he should profit from it”. Found with her face pressed into the earth and her body concealed, officers had to hack through the thick bushes to see her face - a swollen mottled mix of reds and blacks - and with “severe head bruises Police think may have been caused by a blunt instrument”, this was a comment Mills would ridicule. With it suspected she was killed not far from where she was found owing to the limited drag marks, sniffer dogs and officers with metal detectors scoured the area, and although a rusty shovel blade and a 3 foot of chain was found, Professor Tryhorn of the East Midlands Forensic Lab discounted them all. The crime scene was processed, but it wouldn’t reveal its secrets for a few weeks. That night in a cafe, Mills met Norman Rae the celebrated crime reporter, and Mills’ opening words were “did you bring the money?”. He had. £75 (£3000 today), which was worth it as Rae knew he was onto a winner. The next day, as the autopsy took place, on the front page of the News of the World was an exclusive featuring a photo of Mills beside the bushes pointing down the gully to where he said he had ‘found’ Mabel Tattershaw’s body - a murder he was now connected to, but not yet as her killer. Keen to keep him for themselves as Mills promised them “another piece of sensational information which was worth a lot of money”, with the odds in their favour, the newspaper took him back to their offices in London, gave him £5 pocket money, took him to see the Festival of Britain, the sights of Soho and King’s Rhapsody on Shaftesbury Avenue under the watchful protection of a reporter, and assuring them he wouldn’t speak to any other paper, he dropped two bombshells: he didn’t find the body on Wednesday 8th but a few days earlier, and confirming “without doubt, Mrs Tattershaw was strangled” - an odd statement to make as he claimed he hadn’t been within 8 feet of this well-hidden body. By Saturday the 11th of August, with the investigation headed-up by Detective Superintendent Percy Ellington of Nottingham CID, being bereft of the exclusive, the local papers incorrectly reported that Mabel was last seen alive two days after her murder being accompanied by a moustachioed man with a limp. And with Police struggling to hunt this man down, as well as two men she met at a darts match, so lopsided was the hunt for Mabel’s killer that they wondered if it was connected to the recent killing of 22 year old Florence Jean Weatherall at Hucknall, who was also found murdered on a lover’s lane, and who (with nothing better to do) the local press blamed on a fictional killer known as The Traveller. The culprit was clearly Mills, but with the Police and the Press looking the wrong way, as Mills was just a 19-year-old, slightly shy, wannabe poet who had no criminal record or known motive to kill her, he wasn’t even considered as a viable suspect, so this chronic gambler decided to take his next big risk… …to draw the suspicion for her murder onto himself. On the morning of Sunday the 12th of August 1951, outside of Leenside Police Station on Nottingham’s Canal Street, wearing his best suit and with his hair neatly coiffured, Herbert Mills arrived by taxi to give evidence at the inquest. Before him, a wall of reporters from the national papers jostled for his attention, calling his name as if his celebrity status was already a given, as the paps took his picture. Playing it coy, but blabbing too much like an eager killer desperate to spill the beans, Mills told them about how he had ‘found’ the body; “I went to the orchard to read poetry and pick raspberries, I wiped my mouth with a hanky as if the Police found it, they would think the stains were blood. It began to rain, I went to find shelter, I saw a necklace on the ground, and bending down to pick it up, I saw something white in a gully. It was a woman’s face. She was dead”. Asked why he had held onto to it, Mills replied “it had my fingerprints on it”, as if that was justification for his arrest. When asked “why didn’t you go to the police straight away?”, he grinned and said “there’s money to be made in murder”. Playing with them like they were his toy, he told the press the Police were wrong that she had only been battered to death, he called the detectives ‘fools’, and lapping up the attention, he stated “I’ have put himself in an awkward situation with the Police, as I could be charged with murder”, but being so reluctant to talk to them in any detail, if they wanted to know more, it would cost them. To John Perry of the Press Association he said “I know things no-one else does” but wouldn’t say what. To Alfred Connelly of the Daily Graphic, Mills said “I don’t mind being charged with murder, as when I’m acquitted, there will be a high price to pay”. And to Harry Longmuir of the Daily Mail, Mills he said “the Police won’t catch the killer this week, next, or the next… they have no clue apart from a cheap little necklace”. The reporters regarded him as cocksure but rational, shy but clearly an exhibitionist. And although hardly subtle, suspicion was now falling on Mills as the culprit… …but his guilt needed to be proven before he could play the penultimate part of his trifecta. On Monday the 13th of August, Professor J M Webster, the Home Office Pathologist gave evidence at the inquest. Before the coroner, A G Rothers, he confirmed that she had been beaten about the head by fists (as reported), but she had died by manual strangulation, which Mills had stated five days prior. The Pathologist was asked “do you consider your examination would have been easier if you had been able to conduct a post-mortem on Wednesday?”, the day Mills claimed he found the body but didn’t report it, the Professor replied “very definitely”, with the Coroner warning Mills that because of his actions for the sake of financial gain, “there is a probability that other proceedings might arise”. Three times the Coroner asked “are you sure it was on Wednesday 8th August, when you found her?” Three times Mills answered “yes”, having already alluded that it was the Friday before. Again, warned about his testimony of how he found the body, the coroner asked “were you there long after you had seen the body”, Mills replied “about five minutes. I did not touch the body, nor put anything on it… I could not touch it without going down”, when of course he’d admit he had, to place her coat over her. But if the body was hidden, how did he know she had been strangled? At the inquest, the limping moustachioed man was removed from the line of inquiry, and suspicion clearly crept towards Mills as a possible culprit… but also as a deluded, attention-seeking fantasist. Mills should have been arrested, but he was right, the Detectives had no hard evidence against him; he admitted he had been with her earlier that night (as confirmed by the lodger, Lily Wilson) and said he’d found the necklace at the crime scene on the night he found the body. But nobody saw him there with Mabel, and as for her being strangled, he could have simply guessed it, as it’s not exactly unique. Mills had to play a very careful game now. If he pushed the press too hard for money, they would see him as nothing but a liar and his prospective cash-cows would dry up, which was not good, as the £75 the News of the World had given him, he’d blown most of it on a single bet. If he gave away too many facts, he may be convicted of murder making his dramatic and financially rewarding acquittal a bust. But if he went too far in his retelling of his lies, if he was found insane and may end up at Broadmoor. So, on Friday the 24th of August, having told Norman Rae that he had something ‘sensational’ to reveal - knowing that if Rae kept Mills talking long enough that he would eventually incriminate himself - even this seasoned crime reporter was shocked to find that Mills was already two steps ahead of him. Sat in the lobby of The Black Boy Hotel on Nottingham’s Long Row, at first the conversation was casual; a talk about money, racing, murderers, prison conditions, Broadmoor and acquittal. Initially, Rae felt as if Mills was merely wasting his time and had nothing sensational to say, until he hit him with this… “I want to tell the truth”. And over the next hour, he wrote his confession on the hotel’s headed notepaper. In his handwriting, it read “on the evening of August 8th, I killed Mrs Tattershaw and now wish to clean my conscience and confess to the murder”. He told of how they met, their date and described the killing, arrogantly bragging “I had always considered the possibility of the perfect crime – murder. I am very much interested in crime and here was my opportunity. No motive, no clues. I am quite proud of my achievement. Seeing an opportunity of putting my theory into practice, I decided to meet her. I was satisfied I had found the perfect victim. I put on a pair of gloves. I knelt on her. I was very pleased. I think I did rather well. The strangling was easily accomplished. I slid her down the bank, and left”. Rae had Mills sign each page and agreeing “we’ll take it to Superintendent Ellington in the morning, if that is what you desire?”, Mills agreed, and went to bed, as Rae had to file his explosive news story. In gambling parlance, Mills had gone all in, he’d placed all his chips on one number, the roulette wheel was spinning, and if he won, he would walk away wealthy having beaten the house. But if he lost… …it would mean his death. On Saturday the 25th of August at 10am, at Leenside Police Station, accompanied by Normal Rae, Mills handed his confession to a shocked Detective Superintendent Ellington, who having read the first page cautioned him. Sup: “is this document in your handwriting?”, Mills: “yes”, Sup: “you understand that what is in this document is of a very serious nature and can have serious consequences for you?”, Mills “yes”, Sup: “do you wish to make a statement?”, Mills: “yes”. An official statement was made, Mills read it and signed it, he was cautioned again, and was charged with the murder of Mabel Tattershaw. That week, Dr Fish of the Home Office laboratory came back with the exhibits found at the crime scene which had been sent off for scientific testing. With Mills, having repeatedly stated that he hadn’t been within 8 feet of the body, three hairs similar to his were found on Mabel’s dress which had been hidden under her grey overcoat, and although he’d placed over that his jacket to trap her arms and stop her clawing at him, fibres from his jacket were found under her fingernails, proving he was there. (End). The trial began at Nottingham Assizes on the 19th of November 1951 before Justice Bryne. He pleaded not guilty to murder and did not present an insanity plea. His own defence called Mills “a desperately lonely, hateful boy, whose character was a mixture of cruelty and boastfulness", whose confession was ‘completely bogus’ and had been a ruse to make his story more valuable. They would also state that there was no motive for the murder, as Mills didn’t know Mabel and hadn’t met her before then. On the other hand, even though the Prosecution had hairs from his head on her, fibres from his jacket under her nails, a confession in his own handwriting and he knew details only the killer knew, although a chronic gambler who admitted he did this for fame and money, the question was would the jury see the deliberate mistakes in his confession and acquit him, as he wanted, making him famous and rich… …or find him guilty of murder beyond a reasonable doubt? Having been instructed by the Judge that there were only two possible outcomes - wilful murder or not guilty, not manslaughter on any grounds – after 25 minutes of deliberation, they returned a verdict – guilty. As per his directions, having agreed that Mills’ confession was true, the charge of murder was established, and with his guilt proven, on the 22nd of November, Herbert Mills was sentenced to death. Described as having the composure of a gambler, the Judge said “if you have never seen a man who would gamble with his life, you are looking at one now”. Even during the trial, the prosecution asked “if you had thought it would have brought you more money would have pleaded guilty?”, Mills said “I considered it”. He didn’t appeal the decision, and although a reprieve was submitted, it was rejected. He hated prison life, he refused to see his father, he ridiculed his grandmother’s prayers for salvation, he crushed a prison officer’s arm in a door, and on Tuesday the 11th of December 1951 at 9am, Herbert Leonard Mills was executed by hanging at Lincoln Prison by Albert Pierrepoint. As a convicted prisoner, he was not allowed to profit from his crimes, and having made the biggest gamble of his life… he lost. The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of.
Seven time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
On Saturday the 28th of August 2010, 30-year-old Izabela Zablocka telephoned her mother and 9-year-old daughter, Kasia, as she did every few days without fail. That day, she vanished without a trace and would never be seen or heard from again. And although her killer thought they had got away with murder, after 15 years fighting to find the answers, Iza's body was finally unearthed, and the truth slowly began to emerge.
SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives:
MUSIC:
UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT: Welcome to Murder Mile: Unleashed. (Engine) And I’m away. Goodbye London. Hello Britain. And as I cruise the UK’s canal network in my little boat, I shall bring you true crime cases from the cities, towns and villages I visit. This week, I’m in Derby in Derbyshire, where a simple missing persons case unearthed something a lot more sinister. My name is Michael, I am your tour guide, and this is Murder Mile. Episode 369: Cracks in the Concrete. Izabela Helena Zablocka (zah-BWOT-kah) was born on the 5th of September 1979 in Trzebiatów (Tshe-bya-toof), a small town of 10,000 inhabitants in north-western Poland, just 9 km from the Baltic sea. Raised in this tiny rural community where many generations of the same family had lived for decades if not centuries and everybody knew each other’s business, Izabella known as Iza followed the herd. As many did, she was married to a local man in her early 20s, she earned a modest living at a factory job, and by the turn of the millennium, her daughter, Katarzyna, who she called Kasia, was born. Times were rough, as with the town reliant on tourists who flocked to the Baltic coast in the summer months but left it desolate from autumn to spring, it had one of the highest rates of unemployment in the county. Sadly, because of their struggles, the marriage didn’t last long and soon they separated. The financial hardship they faced as a young couple was only one side of the conflict between them, as Iza was bisexual, which – although many in the so-called modern West believe that former Soviet-block countries like Poland were ran with very draconian laws – England & Wales only decriminalised homosexuality between men in 1967, and yet same-sex activities had been legal in Poland since 1932. Iza had also been ‘presenting’ as male for several years; with short tapered hair, wearing shirts, jeans and trainers, but no make-up or feminine touches like bright colours or jewellery. At that point, she didn’t ‘identify’ as a man and hadn’t adopted a man’s name or nickname, just the mannerisms, but gender reassignment surgery was something she was considering, which she knew she couldn’t afford. On the 1st of May 2004, Poland joined the European Union, along with Cyprus, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Slovakia and Slovenia. With Britain in need of hardworking migrants willing to do the jobs that our homegrown lazy bastards refuse to do having been raised on a culture of free-benefits and self-entitlement, if they came here, worked hard and lived cheaply, young women like Iza could earn two-to-three times their wage back home, and give her daughter a much better life. In 2008, having known each other since childhood, while living in the same block of flats, a relationship blossomed between Iza and her friend, Anna Podedworna, who was five years younger. And with Bozena, Iza’s mother looking after 9-year-old Kasia, in 2009, Iza & Anna headed to England for work. London proved to be too expensive, so they headed to the smaller city of Derby in the East Midlands, with a population of 250,000, and surrounded by factories seeking hardworking immigrants willing to do the dirtiest of jobs for a minimum wage. With a good work history and no criminal record, Iza & Anna got jobs at Cranberry Foods, a turkey processing plant in Scropton, 20 miles west of the city. Slaughtering turkeys wasn’t exactly their idea of a utopia, but it was steady work with a regular wage, and although Iza only remained employed sporadically through an agency, being described as a ‘skilled butcher’ whose job involved ‘skinning, deboning and portioning out carcasses with a large knife’, Anna soon became a permanent employee at the plant, and the main breadwinner for their household. Around the same time, Iza & Anna moved into a two-bedroomed mid-terrace flat at 113 Princes Street in Normanton, a rough but affordable immigrant neighbourhood south of the city centre. Outside was often parked builder’s vans, and although its flat-fronted facade was grotty, inside Anna had added a woman’s touch by cheaply but effectively decorating the living room and kitchen with silver wallpaper, carpet, chairs, and signs reading ‘Chanel’, ‘Love’ or ‘Happy’, so it resembled a robot’s wet dream. On every wall were family photos as a reminder of who they were doing this for, and although small, it was practical, cheap, and outback, they had a small garden of uneven grass to hang up the laundry. 113 Princes Street was their home for a year… …until Iza vanished out of the blue. Every few days without fail, blessed with a close bond, Iza called her family in Poland. On Saturday the 28th of August 2010, while Anna was at work, Iza spoke to her mother, grandmother, daughter, and they said "nothing appeared to be amiss". Then all communication stopped, no calls, no emails, no nothing, and with no warning at all, she completely disappeared off the face of the earth. Her family grew suspicious, when on the 4th of September 2010, she didn’t call to wish Kasia a happy 10th birthday. This was unlike her; she didn’t reply to texts, she didn’t post on social media, she hadn’t claimed her unemployment benefits, and no-one in Derby and the wider Polish community had seen her since. In November, her family reported her missing to Derbyshire Police and they called at 113 Princes Street. Inside it was clear that Iza had moved out; her bags were gone, her possessions were taken, Anna’s mum and sister had moved-in in her place, and with Anna telling them how Iza was drinking more and working less, she stated “Iza had an argument with someone dangerous and ran away to London”. Police found no trace of her after that call; neighbours hadn’t heard her, friends hadn’t seen her, she hadn’t applied for work, her passport was unused, her bank account had no money in it to start with, they couldn’t find anyone who disliked or had threatened her, no-one benefitted from her death, and she matched none of the bodies found in the neighbouring counties. There was no proof that she was alive, or dead. So with nothing suspicious to report, Iza Zablocka wasn’t reported as a missing person. It remained that way for years, with Iza’s family "forced to live in a state of constant anxiety and dread" as not knowing was killing them. Kasia, Iza’s daughter was just 9 years old when her mother vanished without a trace. She later stated “I spent my adult life looking for answers... I felt subconsciously that she must have had some sort of accident, or something bad must have happened. Even if she had ended up homeless, she would have still managed to make contact with me and my grandma”. That day her childhood ended, and right through her teenage years, a big piece of her life was missing as the ever-expanding hole in her heart was only filled with more unanswered questions; like where her mum was, what had happened to her, and why she never called? And as much as those who worried about her suggested that (for the sake of her mental health) she should accept that her mum was most likely dead and very likely will never be found, even as a young girl, Kasia never gave up. Her mum’s disappearance haunted her sleep and her every waking moment, Kasia said "as a young child, I was incredibly close to my mother, she was my whole world, so the fact she simply vanished from my life without a single word of explanation was a horrific experience for me. This sudden void left a deep wound in my psyche which has stayed with me until this day. The worst part was the soul-crushing uncertainty. For years, I didn't know why she left me. Instead of playing with friends, I was constantly wondering where my mother was and why she stopped calling me. I felt abandoned. Even though I lived in limbo for years, in my heart, I always knew my mother didn't leave me on purpose". Every birthday, Kasia waited for a call from her mum… …but the call never came, and it never would. As Detective Constable Emma Birch stated “while she held onto the belief that her mum was safe with each passing year, those hopes diminished and the worry that she had come to harm loomed larger… (but being ever determined) she grew into a strong-minded young woman who wanted answers”. Annually, 170,000 people go missing in the UK, almost all are found but a few. Iza’s disappearance remained high-profile in Poland and with Polish nationals in the UK thanks to Kasia’s relentless search, her social media campaign to ensure Iza was never forgotten, and in June 2024, she contacted ‘Missing For Years’, a Polish charity who investigate cases. They contacted Anna, but as such a distant memory, she could only reiterate what she had told Police in 2010, “I don’t know what happened to her”. In 2025, Kasia, now a 25 year old woman increased the case’s profile further by contacting several highly-respected journalists, and having taken the case, on the 15th of May 2025, Rafal Zalewski (Rrraf-ow Za-lef-ski), a journalist for Polsat TV called Anna and requested an interview – but she declined. Six days later, Rafal and his cameraman flew to East Midland Airport, travelled to Derby, and filming an episode of his social affairs programme ‘Interwencja’ (een-ter-VEN-tysa) which means intervention, at Anna’s new home on Boyer Street which she shared with her new male partner as well as her 11 year old daughter and 6 year old son, he doorstepped her, asking the questions Kasia wanted to know. (ADD AUDIO). Rafal said “she was very surprised and nervous… I knew she could be hiding something, that she might know something more than she's not telling us". With this described as the ‘tipping point’, his call on the 15th of May led Anna to email the Police that day stating she knew about Iza’s disappearance. On the day he doorstepped her, she sent a flurry of emails giving further evidence (which Police admitted, took them by surprise). And three days later, on the 24th of May 2025, having informed detectives that Izabella was buried in the back garden of 113 Princes Street, Anna headed to Pear Tree Police Station. With her red-hair tied back, her eyes shielded by sunglasses and wearing jeans, trainers, a salmon pink t-shirt and a blue sports-jacket, she looked like any another working-class mum as she rang the phone on the door of the police station. Interviewed by a lone officer, she stated that Iza had confronted her, assaulted her, and in an act of self defence, she had killed her by accident, and buried her out of panic. In her confession, she said "I couldn't carry on any more, I couldn't look at the pain of (Iza’s) family. I couldn't bear the fact that she was lying there in the garden and I wanted to be free” - psychologically free of the guilt and remorse she said had ravaged her mind for the last 15 years. Detectives searched their former flat at 113 Princes Street, and buried under the concrete, they finally found Iza’s body. So what went wrong between these two lovers? It’s impossible to unravel the truth, as with Iza dead, we only have Anna’s version of events. With Iza frequently unemployed, Anna was the sole breadwinner and according to her, by March 2010, "we had arguments all the time… Iza drank nearly every day unless she had no money. She was tipsy all the time, not drunk, a bit tipsy", but because of that, Anna said “she was jealous about everything", everyone Anna spoke to or met, and by the summer, they had split, but had remained living together. Justice Williams KC stated “this was a source of frustration to you, as was the level of Izabela’s alcohol consumption, which you believed the two of you could ill-afford. In these circumstances the prospect of Izabela undergoing a gender reassignment operation faded into the background and I am quite satisfied from listening to your evidence that you grew increasingly angry with and bitter towards Izabela who you felt was too reliant upon you and was not keeping up her side of the bargain”. Their arguments were frequent, but so was the violence. In court, Anna claimed that Iza had given her a black eye and was the instigator of most fights, with Anna merely a passive victim, but as Kasia had lived with them both in Poland, she recalled Anna chasing Iza out of a flat carrying a butcher’s knife. In early to mid-August 2010, two-to-three weeks before her death, Anna claimed that Iza threatened to kill her and strangled her, but the Judge rejected this, “as you told no-one about this until after you were charged with murder, and your explanation for not reporting it to the police at the time lacked credibility, not least as Police officers had been called to the address by Izabela a few months earlier”. Throughout, Anna’s lies were described as "a continuation of her post-murder cover-up". Their relationship was stormy and turbulent, riddled with suspicion, jealousy, conflict, and with it said that men found Anna attractive and Iza had noticed that Anna preferred men (later beginning a relationship with a man and bearing two children with him), as Iza was only presented as a man and her gender reassignment surgery was a distant pipedream, she was no longer what Anna wanted. On Saturday the 28th of August 2010, Iza phoned her family for the very last time, and by all accounts, "nothing appeared to be amiss"; she was happy, calm and said nothing about a need to flee to London having argued with someone dangerous. Her beloved daughter’s 10th birthday was just one week away and she’d arranged a present, but that night she died, when Anna returned from the slaughter house. Anna told the court, “I was scared to be around the house… I was scared of speaking to her because I did not know what was going on”, as (according to Anna) when she got home from Cranberry Foods 10 minutes late, Iza was furious, she grabbed her, pinned her to the wall, and began to strangle her. Questioned in court by her barrister, Clive Stockwell KC; CS “Izabela pushed you against a wall, she had hold of your clothing and she was stronger than you?”, AP “Yes. After she grabbed me, she started to strangle me, and I pushed her away”, CS “Where were her hands?", AP “Around my neck”, CS “Both hands?”, AP “Yes. I could not catch my breath”, CS “What did you do?”, AP “Pushed her, but it was not working, so I started strangling her”, CS “So you took hold of her neck to stop her from strangling you? What did you think was going to happen?”, AP: ”That it was the end, the finish, that she’d kill me”. Anna’s defence was that this was self-defence, but Gordon Aspden KC for the Prosecution stated “that this was yet another lie by this defendant to try to conceal her guilt”, as the violence escalated further. CS “What did you then do?”, AP ”On the window ledge there was a big figurine, and so I grabbed it… it was quite heavy, it was some kind of horse, I don’t know”, CS “Having grabbed it, what did you do with it?”, AP “I hit her”, CS “Why did you do that?”, AP “To make her weaker so she would let me go”. In all the panic, Anna said couldn’t remember if she hit her on the head or the arm. CS “How hard did you hit her?”, AP “I don’t know”, CS "Did hitting her with the figurine work?”, AP “No”, CS “Did she release her grip on your neck?”, AP “No”, CS “You were still struggling to breathe?”, AP “Yes”, CS “What did you then do?”, AP “I was strangling her, it was all happening that fast, I know I was strangling her, I know I hit her, and I know she fell somehow”. Anna’s defence counsel stated "something must have happened to make this defendant of previous good character behave in the way that she did”, but both the jury and the judge would reject this claim that Anna had acted in self-defence against Iza. So, was this a murder? Anna would deny this, as when Clive Stockwell KC asked "Did you want to hurt her?”, Anne replied to the court “No, absolutely not, I did not have such an intention”. But did she? CS “Can you remember hitting her a second time with the figurine?”, AP “I could have hit her a second time”, CS “Do you know where?”, AP “It could have been the head. She fell… she was lying on her back”, CS “Was she moving?”, AP “No”, CS “Did you want to kill her?”, AP “No”, CS “What did you want to achieve by hitting her?”, AP “I just wanted her to leave me alone and let me go”. And she did. Iza was motionless, silent and still, as the flushed colour slowly drained from her cheeks. Her defence asked CS “What did you do?”, AP “I checked her pulse in her neck”, CS “Was there a pulse?”, AP “No… I tried to resuscitate her”, CS “How?”, AP “Mouth-to-mouth”, CS “How long did you do that for?”, AP: “I don’t remember”, CS "Anything else?”, AP “I was pressing on her chest”, CS “Was she breathing?”, AP “No”, CS "What were your thoughts when you realised she was dead?”, AP “To call the police and call the ambulance”, CS “Did you call the police?”, AP “No”, CS “Did you call an ambulance?”, AP “No”, CS “Why did you not?”, AP “there were no witnesses, no one would believe I was defending myself”, and as the last person to see her alive, having killed her, AP “I’d go to prison for the rest of my life”. But it wasn’t the killing of Iza which convicted Anna… …it was the disposal of the body, and the lies proceeding it. Even her defence counsel stated “there is nothing I can say about what she did to Izabela's body and how she acted for the next 15 years. She is the mother of two children, aged 11 and six, and they will live the vast majority of their young lives without their mother", all because of her selfish actions. Iza’s body lay on the floor of the silver living room, bleeding profusely; a broken horse figurine by her side and overlooked by photos of their loved ones and cut outs of words which read ‘love’ and ‘happy’. AP “I could not leave her like this, and I had to do something”, CS “Were you thinking clearly at that time?”, AP “No. I was just terrified, I felt fear”, CS “Did you think what you were going to do to Izabela’s body?”, AP “At that address, there was a garden”, CS “You thought you would bury Izabela there?”, AP “Yes”, CS “Why did you think that?”, AP “I don’t know. I did not want to do that, but at that point it was the only option. I went into the garden, I looked around and checked if there was a place where I could have done it. When I located that place, I made the decision to bury her in the garden”. She stripped her former lover of everything but her underwear and tossed them in a bin, AP ”I wanted to move her somewhere into the kitchen but she was heavy”, which was odd, as Anna was a manual worker used to physical labour, and as Iza wasn’t fat or muscular, they were roughly the same weight. She said she couldn’t lift her or pull her by the arms, AP “I had an idea to cut her… to cut her in two”, and as a skilled butcher in a slaughter house, taking a knife from the kitchen, on the living room floor, it took her two hours to sever the body into two manageable pieces. CS “What were you thinking?”, AP ”I think at that point I was not thinking”, CS “You managed to cut Iza in half. Was there much blood in the living room?”, AP “I don’t recall. It didn’t seem that much”. And any there was, she cleaned up. The autopsy was carried out by Home Office pathologist Dr Stuart Hamilton who stated “it required ‘considerable force’ to cut through her spine with a knife”, severing it at the lumbar vertebrae. And although seemingly crude, basic and hasty, “the dismemberment and concealment of the body proved to be extremely successful. She had destroyed all evidence of how she had murdered Izabela". Both parts; the torso, arms and head, and the hips, legs and feet were wrapped in electrical tape and “trussed up like a turkey”, taping the arms across her chest, and her legs bent up against her buttocks and the two halves of her body placed in black plastic bin-liners and tied at the top. She then cleaned up the house, mopped up the blood, and with the body in two parcels dumped in the kitchen by the backdoor, she threw out everything (the figurine to Iza’s phone) which connected her to the murder. By nightfall, she was sweating and exhausted… …but the horror was far from over. In court, Anna said “I felt like some kind of monster", and so having spontaneously taken two weeks off work, she dug a hole (1 metre deep) in the back garden – in what would have been a backbreaking job – and dumped Iza’s severed body parts in what the judge described as a “filthy, makeshift grave”. And to erase any chance of the body being discovered and Iza’s family finding peace, she had the back garden covered in a concrete hardstanding; a thick, durable paved surface used to support heavy loads which (according to forensic anthropologist Gaille MacKinnon) crushed many of her skeletal remains so that forensics had to sieve them, some were never found and her cause of death remains uncertain. For 15 years, Anna lied to Iza’s family, to her friends, to the police, and as much pain as she caused to Iza’s young daughter, Kasia, who held onto the hope that one day her mother would return… but never would, in court, she had to hear everything you’ve just heard about her mother’s death and disposal. Kasia never gave up, even as Anna (the woman she suspected of knowing more about her mother’s death than she was letting on) lived her life and started a family as if nothing had happened. And even though Anna would never show an ounce of remorse during the trial, the guilt was there. Police searched both properties; her old house on Princes Street and the new one on Boyer Street. A phone discovered proved that she made internet searches of Iza’s name, her daughter’s social media campaign, Google Streetview’s of the house, but also murderers who had reformed, a Catholic prayer, messages to a local church asking for help interpreting dreams about a dead woman, and summing her up perfectly whether she could still get Universal Credit (a UK benefit) if she had a criminal record… …as well as all the lies she had told to everyone who was searching for Iza. On Sunday 1st of June 2025, in the back garden of 113 Princes Street, having used ground penetrating radar to isolate a spot, and jackhammers to dig through the concrete, 15 years after she went missing, the body of Izabela Zablocka was found, entirely skeletonised with a few fragments of human tissue. Having been bailed while evidence was gathered, the next day at 6:25pm, in the hallway of her home on Boyer Street – spoken in whispers so as to not upset her children – Anna Podadworna was arrested. (End) She was charged with perverting the course of justice, preventing an lawful burial and murder, along with two women and men of similar age, who were arrested on suspicion of murder but bailed. A three-week trial began at Derby Crown Court on the 20th of January 2026 before Mrs Justice Williams KC, at which Anna pleaded not guilty to all charges and stuck to her alibi of self defence. Prosecutor Gordon Aspden KC stated “ two of you were arguing and you murdered her didn't you?", Anna denied this, Aspeden re-iterated “you hated her so much that you chopped her in half and chucked her out with the trash didn't you?", to which Anna admitted "I'm accepting I did it. I was only defending myself". But having told so many lies and caused so much pain, nothing Anna said would be believed. On the 10th of February, the jury returned with a unanimous verdict for all three charges – guilty. With her sentenced to life with a minimum term of 20 years and 116 days, minus the days she had already served on remand, summing up, Mrs Justice Williams KC said: “Your actions caused untold misery to Izabela's family who could not hold a funeral until last year. You have shown no remorse ". Calling her actions “violent, manipulative and cruel”, the Judge stated "I am satisfied that you became more angry and bitter towards Izabela who was not contributing or keeping her side of the bargain. Izabela suffered a violent death at your hands and I am sure you killed her in anger and frustration rather than being under attack from her. Your account you gave to the jury was untrue. To all intents and purposes you carried on your life as though nothing had happened", but now her life is over. In a rightful tribute Iza’s mother and daughter, the Judge said “had it not been for the persistence of Bozena and (Kasia) who did not give up hope of uncovering what had happened to Izabela, it is likely that your crimes would have remain undetected. I pay tribute to their tireless dedication”, with lead investigator, DI Kane Martin reiterating “nothing can bring Izabela back, but it is my hope that today's sentencing allows her family to lay her memory to rest", and bring a sense of closure to this horror. Kasia said “In my heart I always felt that my mother did not leave me on purpose”, and having worked so tirelessly to find the truth, she can be certain that her mother loved her until she day she died. The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of.
Seven time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
EPISODE THREE HUNDRED AND SIXTY-EIGHT: On Monday the 26th of April 2021 at 12:15pm, 63-year-old retired Police Constable, Clive Porter approached Lock 14 at Broughton on the Aylesbury Arm of the Grand Union Canal. As a License Enforcement Officer, he placed a notice on an unlicensed boat... and then was brutally murdered by NOT the owner of that boat. But why? And what secrets was his killer hiding?
SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives:
MUSIC:
UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT: The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of.
Seven time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
EPISODE THREE HUNDRED AND SIXTY-SEVEN: From Saturday 20th of March 2004 to Friday 15th of May 2004, in numerous lakes and rivers, across several countries, the head, hands, thighs, lower legs and feet, but not the arms, torso and pelvis of 63 year-old Ian Halls was found. He wasn't a criminal and hadn't double crossed anyone, so why was he brutally murdered and dismembered?
SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives:
MUSIC:
UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT: Welcome to Murder Mile: Unleashed. (Engine) And I’m away. Goodbye London. Hello Britain. And as I cruise the UK’s canal network in my little boat, I shall bring you true crime cases from the cities, towns and villages I visit. This week, I’m in several counties exploring the tragic case of a greedy little man and his dream of being a serial-killer. My name is Michael, I am your tour guide, and this is Murder Mile. Episode 367: The Serial Killer’s Handbook. For many in Britain, Saturday 20th of March 2004 was marked in two ways; with protests across every city in anger at the first anniversary of the Iraq War, and geeky hurrahs as Christopher Ecclestone was named as the ninth Doctor Who. Elsewhere, life went on. It was a typical spring day as shards of light burst intermittently across the River Witham in Lincolnshire, just off the coast of the East of England. Near the hamlet of Anton’s Gowt, two miles north of Boston, a dog walker was savouring the fresh air of these wide waters, as several boats navigated Anton's Gowt Lock to explore the backwaters beyond. The reed beds bristled, the trees swung softly, and everywhere there was peace and tranquillity. It’s the kind of a place you don’t expect to see crisps packets, Coke cans and discarded junk lying about, so when the dog tentatively crept into the foreshore and began sniffing, its owner took heed. Weighing about 5 kilos, a parcel bobbed below the waterline. 16 inches long and 20cm thick, it was oddly shaped like a long breeze block, but it was squishy when touched. Wrapped in black bin bags and sealed with electrical tape, someone had wanted its contents hidden, but an end had been nibbled loose by fishes. Through the torn plastic, a fleshy stump protruded; the skin was jagged and ripped, not surgically cut like in an operation, as the muscle was shredded as if it had been severed by something brutal; and with the thigh bone sheered off near the hip and the knee, they didn’t need the festering maggots, the buzzing of flies or the feted stench to tell them that this was the upper part of an adult male thigh. But what was it doing here? Had it been misplaced being sent to a medical incinerator, was it a prank by junior doctors, or had a bad lad received his comeuppance having crossed a big time criminal? Two days later and 10 miles north, along the serene banks of the River Witham, running through the leafy village of Tattershall, another parcel was found floating. Owing to the decomposition, it was hard to tell if it was from the same person, but identification was made easier, as this package comprised of two hands and a head. He was an adult male possibly in his 60s. But who was he, and was he local? Lincolnshire detectives searched the vast and winding waterways of the county expecting to find the rest of the body, but all they found were these four pieces of a man who was most likely murdered. The bits were examined by a pathologist, his details were ran through Missing Person’s, and his fingerprints and biological data were uploaded to the Police National Database and the DNA database. It led to a man, who was not the kind of person the Police were expecting to find, it unmasked a darker tale spanning large swathes of the country, and resulting in the arrest of a wannabe serial killer. The body parts belonged to Ian Edgar Halls. Born on the 30th of August 1940, possibly in the borough of Lambeth, South London, Ian was described as a ‘kind soul’, who was ‘liked’ and ‘well respected’. He was warm and social, but never married or had kids as maybe he didn’t find love, or his focus was the things he loved in life, the pursuit of knowledge. As a bookish man who loved history, from the early 1970s, around the time that he lost contact with his mother, he had worked and managed many public libraries in the country of Surrey such as Ditton’s in Thames Ditton, one in Elbridge, one in Weybridge, and he was the manger of the library in Walton. “Ian was a very gentle and well-liked fellow”, a friend said, “he was always pleasant and helpful… and went out of his way to help my son with his history schoolwork…. he was a thoroughly nice guy”. And that was Ian in a nutshell; a friendly and peaceful man who never ruffled any feathers or made ripples. In 2002, after almost three decades as a librarian, Ian retired aged 61, and unlike too many who work themselves into an early grave, he wanted to make the most of his golden years. Moving to the coastal town of Ipswich in Suffolk, as a slim man with glasses and a crown of greying hair, Ian was often seen at the public library, head down and neck deep in research, enjoying his life in the way he knew how. His step-sister, Diana said “Ian was a gentle person who was enjoying his retirement… in the year prior, he had been the happiest anyone had ever seen him… relishing the time to pursue his many interests”, and enjoying his new home; a £150,000, three bedroomed detached cottage called South View. Set north-west of the heart of Ipswich town centre, it was the perfect home for this 63-year-old bachelor. Situated roughly 100 miles south of where the head, hands and an upper thigh would be found, what had Ian done to end up dead and dismembered? Who had he cheated, hurt, offended, or blackmailed? The answer is… no-one. Six days after his dissected thigh was found in the River Witham, another 95 miles north-east, a team of workers for the Environment Agency were clearing a site on the River Ouse at Skelton, near York, when they stumbled across an identical parcel; an adult human thigh, wrapped in black bin bag, sealed with electrical tape, with the flesh jagged and ripped, and severed near the hip bone and the knee. DNA would later prove they belonged to Ian, but as the River Witham doesn’t directly connect to the River Ouse except by a meandering series of rivers and open-water, it was becoming clear to the police that his body hadn’t been dumped in one spot and drifted away, but had been deliberately scattered. So far, a head, two hands and two thighs were found. But what had happened to Ian Halls? For Christmas and New Year of 2003, Ian stayed with friends in France, by all accounts he was filled with his usual humour and laughter, and as planned, on the 2nd of January, he headed home to Ipswich. But was never seen alive again. His step-sister, Diana kept in regular contact with him, and although he was known as a loner, she said “it was out of character for him not to keep in touch”. Diana reported him missing on Thursday 29th of January 2004. With no suspicious circumstances, at this point, Ian was only a missing person, but when Diana visited his home two days later, the owner of a workshop, maybe Deben Vehicle Repairs directly opposite told her “I’d seen a man in a cap… I saw this person come out, I knew he didn’t live there”. Alerting the Police, officers called at South View and were greeted by Ian Halls. At least that’s what he said his name was, and although similar in appearance, he didn’t match Ian’s description; this man was shorter, fatter, easily a decade younger, with a similar crown of hair and glasses, but was portly. Arrested on suspicion of deception, with his painfully pathetic ruse revealed, he was proven to be 49-year-old Michael Harvey, Ian’s nephew, but when questioned at Ipswich Police Station, his series of impossibly pathetic lies continued when he denied knowing anything about Ian's disappearance, and claimed “he’s joined a religious cult and gave me permission stay at his home and use his money”. Ian was last seen on the 2nd of January, but one week before he was reported missing - as if his uncle was already dead, missing and never to return - Harvey had cashed in Ian's life insurance, £20,000 in premium bonds, drained his bank account, and an applied for £150,000 in loans against Ian’s house. At this point, it was nine weeks before the first piece of Ian’s body was found, and with no proof of life or death, a search of Ian’s home gave detectives a startling insight into the horror of his demise. A crude attempt had been made by someone to clean up the pools and spatter of blood, but behind the radiators, under the door handles and in the fibres of the carpets of the kitchen, lounge, utility room and the foot of the stairs, it was proven that this was where Ian was murdered and dismembered. But how could the detectives prove that this was a murder, and not manslaughter? Monday the 10th of May 2004, six weeks after the first discovery, at 1.50pm, another dog walker made a shocking discovery. This time at the Ransome Road Lake, near Delapre Abbey in Northamptonshire; 75 miles south-west of the River Witham, 100 miles west of Ipswich and 135 miles south of Skelton. Again, it was wrapped in black bin bags with electrical tape, this was a lower right leg and foot, and it had been washed up beside a jetty next to the Northampton Water Ski Club where many families sit. Search teams scoured the surrounding woodland with sniffer dogs, a police helicopter made a survey of the area, and with divers exploring the depths of this former gravel pit, by Friday, the lower left leg and foot had been found, wrapped and sealed like the others. As angler, Paul King stated "It seems such a strange place to dispose of a body part… all sorts of things go on down here; waterskiing, fishing and horse riding. You've got to be really pushing your luck to drop it in here because the chances are it will be found". Unlike a river, it wouldn’t drift and perhaps vanish forever, instead it just floated. Both lower legs and feet were taken to the Leicester Royal Infirmary where a Home Office pathologist confirmed that the DNA matched Ian Halls. Further searches were conducted, but although his head, hands, feet and legs (in four parts) were found, his arms, his torso and his pelvis would remain missing. Harvey would never say where they were dumped… …exacerbating the trauma and grief of Ian’s loved ones. Little was reported about Michael Harvey; we know he was a bachelor, one article said he was “an unemployed drifter”, another said he went by the alias of Michael Mulkeirn, but having spent roughly 20-years working as a surveyor in the architecture department of Northamptonshire County Council, a colleague, 71-year-old Alan Ede recalled “he didn't mix much. I wouldn't say people got on with him”. He worked there until 2001, and in a catastrophic fall from grace, he got a job as a caretaker at Delapre Abbey, next to the Ransome Road Lake, and lived onsite in a small flat. By 2003, the year of Ian’s death he had moved to a council flat on Northdown Avenue in Hulme, Manchester, and was £20,000 in debt. He wasn’t a master criminal, an experienced killer, or even a fraudster with a history of semi-successful cons, Harvey was a half-wit, with bad debts, who struggled to hold down a simple job, but had an ego and an arrogance which vastly outweighed his limited ability. He did everything to hide the evidence of (what he assumed was) the perfect crime by dismembering the body and scattering it far and wide. And yet, his own sense of superiority would be his downfall. The investigation was headed up by Detective Superintendent Stewart Gull of Suffolk Police, with the support of the neighbouring forces. From the start, Harvey denied any involvement in the murder, yet his phone records proved he had called Ian, his uncle, on several occasions in January, cell mast data put him in Ipswich, and a bus ticket from his home put him in the town when Ian was murdered. The blood found at the house was Ian’s, and with the weapons used to dismember and kill him having been disposed of, the only way to prove the guilt of this greedy little man was by following the money. It’s likely Ian was still alive by Wednesday the 21st of January 2004, 19 days after he was last seen alive, but as a quiet, solitary man who lived alone and was new to the town of Ipswich, this wasn’t unusual. On Thursday the 5th of February, a week after Ian had been reported missing, Harvey had hired a Ford Transit van using Ian’s Visa card. Having disposed of the body and cleaned-up the house so if the cops came calling it wouldn’t raised any suspicions, believing he was a criminal genius, he parked the van a few streets away, and inside it he stashed everything (and I mean everything) to do with the killing. Sliding open the door, Detectives found a treasure trove of evidence to prove his guilt; a Derringer pistol, a crossbow, a slingshot, a set of bloodstained overalls, bin bags, electrical tape and tarpaulin. On all of them were his fingerprints, as well as his DNA, with Ian’s blood found in the floor recesses. Even a haphazard killer with lower than average IQ would know to destroy everything, and given that Harvey drove around the country dumping body parts in rivers far and wide, why didn’t he toss any of these items in a skip, or a bin, or buried them, or burn them. Instead, like a moron, he stored them. Found among his files, he also kept a ‘kill list’, a list of 12 or 13 potential victims who he would murder for their money. One was his ex-colleague at Northamptonshire County Council, Alan Ede, who said “It had been 12 years since I'd last seen him. I was very surprised he had thought of me", as if this was a nice treat. With two others being his ex-neighbours, Tony Markham (who, like Ian, had lost contact with his family), and Tony’s girlfriend Jennifer Galsworthy had inherited a large sum of money. Tony's brother, Colin said "we’d go to Tony’s flat regularly. he used to say there was a strange bloke living next door, but we haven't heard from him for years. The last I heard, he was living in north Wales". Harvey’s ‘kill list’ comprised of those he knew who fitted his criteria; they had to be single, preferably with few relatives, who had paid off most of their mortgage and had £25,000 in savings whose identity he could assume. Harvey called his marks, ‘Don’, and although each ‘Don’ had potential, only one was perfect (being a bachelor with £300,000 worth of assets), but he was only #6 on the list – uncle Ian. His ‘kill list’ wasn’t the most moronic thing he had left in the van for the Police to discover, he had also left for the detectives to peruse at their leisure – his murder manual – a series of blood-stained files, written by him, describing his plan to befriend, kill and dismember a single man, assume his identity and strip all his assets. He also wrote detailed notes on how he would do it, with maps and diagrams. In his so-called serial killer’s handbook, Harvey – in which he had written ‘SK’ next to his name claiming he fit the profile of those like Bundy and Dahmer – he had drawn a diagram on how to dismember a body complete with comprehensive notes, he had created detailed flow-charts on how to maintain his web of lies (like Ian joining a religious sect) and how to deal with any possible scenario (like Police not believing he was Ian, a man several stone heavier and 15 years his senior), he had left examples of him practising his uncle's signature, drafts of letters to the insurance company, and a list of ‘'people to be sorted'; as he wrote, “the old bill… the social worker who keeps calling… nosey neighbours… and Diana and Rosie", Ian’s step-sister and her daughter, who were getting far too close to the truth. When quizzed about this at Ipswich Police Station, Harvey claimed that his ‘murder manual’ wasn’t in relation to his uncle - whose name doesn’t appear anywhere in it, but ‘Don’ or the initials ‘ONK’, which he would never explain what it meant – but that it only related to the carcass of a dead sheep. With the files being so detailed - comparing the 1,675 miles he had travelled over four days in a hired Vauxhall Vectra, to the maps and the descriptions - detectives tried to identify where the outstanding remains of Ian’s body may have been dumped; they searched the waterways in Sheffield, Nottingham, Peterborough, Huntingdon and Cambridge, and even though Harvey had marked in the tidal patterns and in one case, where a noisy dog lived, none were ever found, having drifted away, or been eaten. But how far did he scatter the body parts? As Ipswich to Anton’s Gowt is 95 miles, it’s 10 miles more to Tattershall, it’s 95 miles to Skelton, and 135 miles to Ransome Road Lake, totalling 340 miles, if they were dumped on the same journey. But as he drove 1,675 miles in four days, where did he drive over those remaining 1,335 miles, and which parts of the country did he dump the arms, torso and pelvis? He had connections to north Wales, and although Police searched, nothing was found. Regardless of whether some or all of the body was found, as the ‘no body, no crime’ rule has never required a physical body to be found for a murder charge or conviction to be secured, given the wealth of evidence Harvey had left behind, it wouldn’t be difficult for the prosecutors to prove ‘beyond a reasonable doubt that the victim was dead and the defendant caused the death’, but what detectives feared was that the case could be scuppered with Harvey claiming manslaughter, or accidental death? The tragedy of it all was that the killing occurred because of Ian’s kindness. In 1999, four years before, when Ian’s estranged mother had died, she had left an insignificant amount of money to his nephew, Michael Harvey. Doing the right thing, Ian traced him, and they kept in touch. Over the next years, as Harvey’s life collapsed and his debts rose, he contacted his uncle more often, and in November 2003, the nephew had stayed for a few days at his uncle’s house in Ipswich, and the two (Ian thought) grew closer, but it was all a ploy for the sake of money. Diana, Ian’s step-sister said "he maliciously exploited Ian for his own gain. He betrayed Ian's welcome, his openness and his trust. Ian was a sociable, knowledgeable, humorous man. He was excellent company”, and as we know, when someone needed his help, Ian was there to help them, but Harvey was there to help himself. Ian was last seen alive on the 2nd of January 2004, having returned from a trip to France, at some point Harvey travelled from Manchester to visit him, and on Wednesday the 21st of January he killed him. In court, Harvey denied many odd details which the Prosecution claimed. According to the pathologist, he killed Ian by firing a crossbow bolt into his neck, Harvey refuted this, stating it was a single wound from a flick knife which killed him instantly, in a ploy designed to plea manslaughter by provocation. He also denied that he had stabbed him to death at the foot of the stairs, and bafflingly, considering the pre-meditated nature of the crime and how Harvey had written and drawn every element of the killing down to the tiniest details, he denied cutting up the body in the spare room, instead claiming it happened in an outbuilding, and would state he suffered from amnesia, and forgot many key details… …mostly when it suited himself. With his uncle Ian dead by the front door, Harvey moved the body out of sight, locked up the house, switched off the lights and headed to Manchester where - with Ian’s bank and credit cards - he went shopping, and with no relatives to spot irregularities in his spending habits, Harvey went on a spree. On Saturday the 24th of January, three days later, Harvey effectively moved in, using his uncle’s ID and living his life as if a dead body wasn’t in the spare room, slowly rotting, as decomposition took hold. He drained the bank accounts, cashed in his premium bonds, attempted to claim on his life insurance, and referring to Ian’s corpse in his murder manual as ‘pongo’ and ’whiffy’, he wrote that he “set about finding something to wrap Pongo in", and in another note, he wrote "prepare for chop daytime". That same day, at Argos in Ipswich, using Ian’s credit card, he bought a sack barrow (to cart the body parts from the vehicle to the dump sites) and rather than a kitchen knife or a power saw, he bought an angle grinder - an odd choice, as (being a spinning blade used to cut, sand and polish metal, stone and concrete, not flesh, hence it splattered congealed blood everywhere), it left the limbs shredded, jagged, and although a loud and grating noise, it was possibly disguised by the car workshop opposite. In his murder manual, as if he wanted the Police to follow his every clue, he wrote "a) get the place cleaned up" (in refence to the house), "b) prepare for exit" (by cleaning up the bloodstains) and “c) get stuff distributed" (the stuff being his dead uncle’s dismembered body parts, which on Monday 26th of January, he purchased black bin bags, electrical tape and heavy-duty rubber gloves to aid this). It was around this time that Diana, Ian’s step-sister was added to his list of ‘people to be sorted’, as she’d have called Ian’s phone, knocked on his door, and - that same week - reported Ian as missing. With the body parts severed into at least 15 pieces, he had marked on his murder manual that it was too risky to dump any body parts in "Ippers", his name for Ipswich, so compiling an elaborate map, in the hired Vauxhall Vectra, over four days, he drove 1,675 miles, crisscrossing the nation and scattering Ian’s body parts far and wide to draw attention away from the house and himself, but failing massively. Between the 20th of March and the 15th of May 2004, everything except the arms, torso and pelvis was found in a river or lake across Lincolnshire, Yorkshire & Northamptonshire. He believed he was a serial killing genius with a master plan, but if he had weighed them down, maybe none of them would ever have been found, proving that Harvey wasn’t the sharpest tool in the box… he was just a tool. (End) On the 12th of February 2004, just six weeks before the first body part was found, 49-year-old Michael Harvey was charged with Ian Halls’ murder. At his committal hearing on the 29th of October 2004, he denied murder as expected, but admitted to dismembering and disposing of his body. The Prosecution had a wealth of evidence, so were ready to prove that this was not manslaughter by provocation. And then, the day before his trial at Norwich Crown Court, this criminal mastermind changed his plea from ‘not guilty’ of murder to ‘guilty’. Even his own solicitor, Charles Riddleston, was stunned. On Thursday the 21st of April 2005, before deputy High Court Judge Sir John Blofeld, with the jury not needing to deliberate, the next day, Michael Harvey was sentenced to life with a minimum term of 29 years, meaning he will not be eligible for parole until 2034, when he’ll be 79. Upon hearing this, he tutted loudly, rolled his eyes, and muttered “it’s about time” as he was lead away to the cells for life. Summing up, the Judge said "you murdered your uncle for gain. You had clearly thought about it long and hard before you did so. It may have started as a fantasy project; you went through the gruesome task of dismembering, you scattered the body parts… it was all precisely planned and pre-meditated". Ian’s body was released for burial on 24th of September 2004, but as said, not all of it was found. When asked if Michael Harvey was a ‘serial killer’ given his ‘kill list’, Detective Superintendent Stewart Gull said “it would appear that he had identified a number of other potential victims. We believe we have traced all of those individuals and have found them to be alive and well. At this stage, it does not appear that Michael Harvey is a serial killer. I cannot stand here and say he has not murdered before, but we have not uncovered any evidence that he is responsible for killing other individuals". And that seems the most likely truth. Michael Harvey wasn’t the master criminal he thought he was, he was an idiot, an ego-ridden loner who was desperate for money, showed no emotion for the uncle he had murdered, and was just a sad little wannabe who was caught by his Serial Killer’s Handbook. The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of.
Seven time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
EPISODE THREE HUNDRED AND SIXTY-SIX: Sunday the 7th of February 1988 was a typical day for Samantha, Colin and their family, residents of Kingsley Way in Tring, Hertfordshire. They went to church, they had dinner, they went to bed, and by the morning, Colin had brutally murdered his wife, cut up her body and hid it in the freezer and the back garden, But why?
SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives:
MUSIC:
UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT: Welcome to Murder Mile: Unleashed. (Engine) And I’m away. Goodbye London. Hello Britain. And as I cruise the UK’s canal network in my little boat, I shall bring you true crime cases from the cities, towns and villages I visit. This week, I’m in Tring, Hertfordshire to unearth a barely reported murder, which is as baffling as the day it occurred. My name is Michael, I am your tour guide, and this is Murder Mile. Episode 366: Dole Cheat. On Christmas Day 2025, I began my journey to tour the canals of England. Travelling at a whopping 2 miles-per-hour, I made it to Cowroast by the 5th of January, only to find the three locks at Marsworth were shut for repairs until the end of March. With no option, except to wait it out, I was stuck in Tring. Which is no bad thing. Tring is a market town whose name in Old English means 'a slope where trees grow’. it is nestled between the Chiltern Hills, was built on an old Roman road, is mentioned in the Domesday Book, has been inhabited since prehistoric times, and currently has a population of 12,500. As a surrogate Londoner with a big city mentality who has been spoiled by 24-hour transport, all-night shops, limitless choice, but also sky-high rents, unbreathable air and a 100% chance of being stabbed, I feared that a small town like Tring would drive me bananas with boredom by teatime. What I found was a warm, welcoming place, where everyone knows each other, and (shock) they say “hello”. I know. At least once a day a stranger would stop to talk to me, and it only took a week or two before I realised they weren’t going to mug me, and there was no ulterior motive, they were just being friendly. To keep myself busy, I started researching murder cases in Tring to upload as 90 second shorts. But that’s when I hit a hurdle. Unlike cities whose inhabitants tend to be transient, as small towns are held together by pride and a neighbourly spirit, they have fewer murders but what I did find was interesting little cases which mostly gave an insight into the rising and falling fortunes of the town’s inhabitants. One case occurred in 1906, when the body of a former Shoesmith known as Rivett was found dead in a ditch at Pound Meadow. His life had been one of hardship and poverty. He had been homeless for months, living on the kindness of others who gave him bread, cheese and water. The Saturday prior, being seen in a “filthy condition”, Fanny Probots said his ankles looked withered and blue, and Rosa Alibone noticed “a dreadful discharge coming from his legs and running from his boots”. It had a feted stench, and his legs were “badly affected by blowfly” (insects which feed on the flesh after death, or when it becomes necrotic). Rivett was alone, hungry, broke, and suffering with chronic bronchitis, his death had been caused by heart failure, exhaustion and neglect. And although, when Rivett needed to, he went to the workhouse, he hated it, saying “I’d prefer to die in a ditch, than go back there”. For those who saw my little video, it struck a chord with the people of Tring; some were sympathetic to Rivett’s plight, some found they were related to those mentioned, and others (bereft of brains) said “that was years ago, who cares” as if a life story isn’t worth retelling if they didn’t live in their lifetime. Murders rarely occur in Tring, but one case in particular seemed to have been forgotten, with many details lost to the mists of time, re-arranged over generations, or simply swept underneath the carpet. It remains as baffling today as back in the 1980s, yet it begs the question, will we ever know the truth? For the sake of the relatives (who still locally) many details have been redacted from this retelling. Samantha was born in October 1963 in the neighbouring town of Hemel Hempstead; she was raised local, lived local, worked local, and every moment of her life existed in and around Hemel and Tring. Little was reported of her early years, but everyone who met her liked her; neighbour James Sharp said “she was a pleasant girl… always said ‘good morning’” and Paul Dickinson recalled “she was lovely. She had the patience of a saint”, as all agreed Samantha was quiet and polite, pleasant and charming. In the early-1980s, while in her late teens, she was in a relationship, and around 1983, she gave birth to a daughter. Being a young single mum can’t have been easy, so it made sense when she got together with a man six years her senior who had a boy and a girl from a previous marriage, his name was Colin. Like Samantha, Colin was born and raised local, as were his family and many generations before them. By 1985, with a 2-year-old, a 3-year-old and a 5-year-old, life became more hectic for this young family headed-up by a 21-year-old mum and a 27-year-old dad when they had another son, and another was still to follow two years later, making this a family of seven. Life is expensive, especially with kids, and even the basics – like rent and food - can be a struggle. For this family, money were tight living off Colin’s modest income as a decorator specialising in aertex ceilings (which were all the rage then), but they did it, they held it together, and as the neighbours said “she never raised her voice to the kids”. Cementing their love but also giving this family the stability they deserved, in February 1986 Samantha & Colin married in the district of Dacorum, and slowly (although with the typical chaos that family life brings) they began to settle into a steady routine; the three eldest attended Dundale Infants School, the two youngest were looked after by Samantha, Colin drove to painting jobs in his white Ford Transit van, and they lived in a terraced house on Kingsley Walk in Tring. In fact, the only hint of criminality was that their home had previously been occupied by the wife of Michael Fagan, the man who broke into the Queen’s bedroom at Buckingham Palace – but that’s it, and even that link is tenuous at best. Their story was as ordinary as any other young family, struggling with the stresses and strains of life. Almost 100 years before, and just a few streets over, on the 15th of October 1892, Charles Smith and his wife were convicted of child cruelty. They lived in a one-room lodging on Akeman Street, and often, being so poor, their children – a boy and a girl - would beg in Tring High Street; their faces dirty, their clothes ragged, their feet bare (even on the coldest of days) and they were malnourished. Two weeks before, their 10-year-old son Charles was admitted to the Workhouse Infirmary. He was so emaciated that his bones poked through his skin, and when they weighed him, instead of five stone, he was one and a half. He died the same day, and his parents were sentenced to just three months hard labour. The Smith family lived in an era before the Welfare State, sickness and unemployment benefits, when no-one had holiday or sick pay, no-one had savings except the wealthy, and there was no safety net for those who needed it. You worked and lived, but only just. If you didn’t owing to sickness, you died. Samantha & Colin were blessed, not only with the strength of their love and their commitment to their children, but also their extended family, friends, and Samantha found faith as a born again Christian. According to Pastor Ian Walker of Tring Community Church, an independent Pentecostal church at the Exchange Christian Centre on Frogmore Street, Samantha attended the mid-week meetings, her family regularly attended Sunday Service and (as a couple) the church had become a big part of their life; just before Christmas, Samantha & Colin had joined the Pastor and his wife for a meal at their home, they were preparing for the church’s sixth anniversary, and as the Pastor said “just the Sunday before, she had said that she and her husband were looking forward to attending the Valentine’s Day supper”. It was a killing which (seemingly) came out of nowhere, and would devastate a family forever. But there had been murders in Tring before. In the early hours of the 22nd of March 1950, outside of the Britannia pub, 21-year-old Peter Thomas Jackson was shot dead. 100 yards away at the Duckmore Lane allotments, his flat-mate and RAF buddy 22-year-old Stanley Christopher Payne was found, dying, a bullet wound to his head and a gun by his side. Back at their shared room, a note was found in which Stanley had written “although I had every cause to hate him, I still have pangs of affection”, and asked that the two men be buried together. Found guilty but insane, Stanley was convicted of his murder. Sunday the 7th of February 1988 was a typical day for Samantha, Colin and their family. That morning, they had attended Sunday Service at Tring Community Church. Unlike the traditionally depressing dirge of over-long hymns and sleep-inducing prayers, Pentecostal worship is deliberately upbeat and lively, beginning with joyful singing, clapping and raised hands, followed by testimonies, passionate preaching, and an invitation to the altar to pray for healing, salvation or spiritual renewal. Attendees come away feeling enlivened and revitalised, rather than suicidal and plagued with guilt. Like many millions that year, with Britain still struggling through a recession which had unemployment at 10% and record high-interest rates, the basics were more expensive and with the average person having less money to spend, Colin’s business was struggling, as aertex ceilings weren’t a necessity. As a born-again Christian, Samantha had been praying for help, whereas to supplement their meagre income during this difficult time, while still working, Colin had been claiming unemployment benefits, also known as ‘the dole’. It wasn’t a major crime, it was a minor fraud. It wasn’t like he was dealing drugs or burgling houses, he had seen his friends do it and saw it as a temporary means to an end. As a married man, it would have earned him an extra £52.95 per week (about £200 today) which wouldn’t have covered his rent, and with five kids, it would have made very little dent in his food bill. With Britain precariously balanced on a fiscal cliff, in 1988, the UK government initiated a nationwide crackdown on those who fraudulently claimed ‘the dole’ resulting in 90,000+ claimants withdrawing their benefit claims and recouping roughly £65 million of the tax-payer’s hard earned cash. TV appeals shamed them into submission, and letters arrived on doorsteps threatening court action and arrest. It’s uncertain how Samantha found out that Colin was double dipping by working and taking ‘the dole’ – maybe they got a knock at the door by an investigator, a court summons, or simply a letter with the initials DHSS on it – but as a born-again Christian, it is said that what worried Samantha most was what her Church and its congregation would think of them, and so said she would report him to the Police. It wasn’t illegal what he was doing, it was dishonest, and caused increased frictions between them. Colin had a bad habit of taking the easy option, and Douglas Climson, his friend said “Samantha would nag him dreadfully”, yet what young family living on a tight budget with five children don’t squabble? But was this enough motive to commit a murder? Just a few streets away, seven years before, on the 7th of September 1971, believing his wife Patricia had cheated on him, 29-year-old David Draper, a decorator held his wife and two children hostage in their home. Armed with two shotguns, in a siege lasting five hours, he indiscriminately fired shots at Police, a passerby and a coach; when Police brought in his mum to mediate he shot at her too, and at 1am, having fired CS gas into the house, Police stormed inside, and Draper was arrested, unharmed. Draper was sentenced to five years for resisting arrest, having a loaded weapon in public and causing malicious damage to a coach. His attempted murder of Inspector George Rafter and Sergeant Alex Shears were reduced to GBH, but he wasn’t convicted of the death of the brave Police dog called Rolfe. People react to stress in different ways; some talk it over, some shout, hit or lash out in ways which make no sense at all, even when alcohol and drugs aren’t involve. Emotion is a flood of chemicals into the bloodstream, and when you’re stressed, that level of adrenaline could kill an average human if it was injected directly into your body while you were calm, but when you’re upset, your body adapts. That evening, the family had dinner, if they watched telly they may have viewed Antiques Roadshow, All Creatures Great and Small or Perfect Strangers, the younger kids – aged 5, 3 and 18 months were bathed and put to bed in their pyjamas, the older two - aged 8 and 6 – stayed up a little later and when it was finally quiet time for the adults, Samantha & Colin couldn’t help but bicker over the dole money. As they sat on the sofa, ice formed between them as the air became decidedly chilly. Colin felt he had done it for the right reason, but Samantha couldn’t live with the shame, as life is there to test you. It’s about hard-work and battling through, not taking the easy way out by stealing it. And with Samantha insistent that she would report him to the Police (or so he said), they went to bed, hostile and upset. And as they drifted off, all that we are left with is Colin’s version of events. The night was cold and wet, as a 90mph storm barrelled in from the coast, leaving roads flooded and trees uprooted over the coming days. Maybe they kept their argument quiet, maybe the approaching storm muffled any shouts, or maybe there were no screams. It wasn’t said whether the children heard what happened next, but let’s pray that they didn’t, as what followed was grim and deeply traumatic. Colin claimed, that at 3am, he was awoken by Samantha (a usually placid and quiet women) shouting, swearing and punching him wildly about the head. Last night’s issue was still brewing, she called him a ‘dole cheat’, and in a fit of tears, she kept attacking him, and as he said, he tried to defend himself. It was never reported why he had these two objects near his bed; maybe he headed to another room, maybe he slept on the sofa, or as a tradesman, maybe they were in his toolbox, but in a pique of anger, with a hammer in his hand, he struck her several time across the head, caving in her skull, and then, with a kitchen knife, he stabbed her six times in the chest, right up to the hilt, telling the Police, “she wouldn’t die, she must have been a fanatic to last so long”, but he kept stabbing until she was dead. If Samantha had gone to the Police over this ‘dole cheat’, at best he would have had a criminal record for ‘making a false statement or misrepresentation under social security legislation’ which would have resulted in a fine of a few £100, or at worst, a custodial sentence of up to three months. It would have been an inconvenience which affected their marriage, but (for the kids) they would have got over it. Aged just 24, Samantha, this loving and devoted mother-of-five lay dead in a pool of her own blood, motionless, silent, and slowly cooling. At no point did Colin attempt to call for an ambulance, and with their children still sleeping just a few feet away, he dragged the body of their mother to the bathroom. The aftermath of Samantha’s murder was more horrific than her death itself… …so why – in the town of Tring – has it been mostly forgotten? Like many of the cases I’ve mentioned, I think there’s three possible reasons; for the sake of their own sanity, most people don’t like dwelling on morbid stories; four years before, sadistic sexual predator Malcolm Fairley nicknamed ‘The Fox’ had committed a series of burglaries, violent assaults and sadistic rapes which had terrorised the community; but also, residents of small towns tend not to dwell on the horrors on the streets around them, as living so close together, a person standing next to them in the butcher’s could easily be a cousin of the culprit or the dad of the dead, so they let it lie and move on. Unless it directly impacts their life, for the sake of retaining a sense of normality in a place where many people are directly connected or tenuously related, you can’t dwell on the past and risk the future. Samantha’s murder had occurred about 3am, the next day was a school day, and with Colin knowing that the kids would be awake within a few hours, having dragged her body from the bedroom into the bathroom, as hastily but also as quietly as he could, he set about disposing of his wife’s dead body. With the bath taps on to drain away the blood, using the serrated blade of a carving knife, he severed her arms at the shoulder, wrapped them in black plastic binbags and sealed them with electrical tape, he cut off her legs at the hip-joint and the knees and wrapped them likewise to limit the seepage, and dismembering her head from her torso, within hours, he had reduced the woman he loved to 7 pieces. With dawn slowly approaching and hearing an occasional creak as the kids stirred, throwing out bags of frozen chips and daily tea-time staples, but not a jumbo pack of beef burgers, he made space in the freezer for her torso, but with it too tiny to stash her limbs and her head, they would remain in a shopping trolley in the garden until he could work out what to do with it. But first, he had to be a dad. That was the morning of Monday the 8th of February 1988. The storm was brewing, the bathroom had been cleaned and their bedroom was off-limits, as the kids got ready for school, but all of them were asking the question ‘where’s mum?’. She was the centre of their world, the warm and reliable sun they orbited around, and now, for no reason, she was missing. It is said, that day, Colin had cancelled his jobs, and with the kids at school or elsewhere; he disposed of the bedsheet, he cleaned the carpets, he threw away the knife, and as a decorator he used the tools of his trade to disguise his crime, but someone can’t simply vanish, especially in a small town like Tring. That day, neighbours thought it odd that Samantha didn’t leave her home on Kingsley Way, she wasn’t seen by the other mums at Dundale Infants School, or didn’t do any shopping on Tring High Street, and when they quizzed Colin about it, he stammered that they had quarrelled and said she’d left him, which made no sense at all, as – with no warning to her friends and her family – she had suddenly left everything she knew and had vanished into thin air, leaving behind her children, who she adored. As happens in every small town, word spread fast, and Colin began tripping over his own lies. For a full day, being surrounded by crying kids who couldn’t understand what was happening, the only proof of this dreadful murder remained in the fridge and in a shopping trolley in the back garden. The following night, Tuesday the 9th of February, using the early evening darkness of this stormy winter night, having backed-up his Transit van to his house, he loaded the body parts into the back, and drove half a mile north of Kingsley Walk to Little Tring Road on the town’s outskirts. Being a remote country lane surrounded by fields which seem to stretch as far as the horizon, with no streetlights, a few odd houses dotted sparsely and cars infrequently passing, he pulled up at an unspecified part of the road. Shielded by wind and rain as the storm reached its peak, no-one passing would have blinked an eyelid as this tradesman in overalls opened the side of his van, pulled out two big and unwieldy binbags, and tossed them into a ditch beside an unidentified field, as fly-tippers are a common curse in this stretch. But this wasn’t builder’s rubbish, it was the arms, the legs and the head of his dead wife. And as he drove off, heading away from his home, that begs several unanswered questions; why didn’t he bury them, why didn’t he disguise them, and why did her torso remain in the back of his van? Could he not bring himself to do toss it, had he been spooked by a passing car, or did he want to be caught? When murders happen, the culprit is rarely rational and in moments of panic, they seek out something or someone familiar, which may explain what he did next. Having already dismembered and disposed of everything except her torso, he called upon his friend in Hemel, Douglas Climson, a dustman who knew everywhere that locals dump their unwanted waste, and met him for a pint at The Beehive pub. Over what must have been a bizarre chat between two pals, Colin told him the version that Samantha had attacked him in his sleep, and threatened to go to the police for being a ‘dole cheat’, he asked for Douglas’ help in disposing of the body, but guilt got the best of him, thanks to his friend’s wise words. At around closing time, his pal convinced him to confess. At the old Police Station on Combe Street, a place more used to call-outs (at that time of night) for drunks, thefts and public urination, the duty officer must have thought he was being pranked when Colin said “I’ve murdered my wife and chopped her up”. But his red-raw eyes showed this wasn’t a lie, and he led the curious detectives to the van. He had parked it at the rear of The Bell public house at 51 High Street in Hemel, 10 minutes from his home where his children were asleep, unaware of what he had done, and how it would impact them. Just after midnight, licensee of The Bell, John Buteux, said “I was taking my dog for a walk after closing, everything was quiet. I came back and there were police everywhere”. Police approached the van, but before they opened the door, Colin stated “there’s no point in looking, I killed her”. Inside they found her torso, and on Little Tring Road he had guided them to the rest, which had already been discovered. Interviewed by Detective Chief inspector Richard Pottinger, Colin gave a full confession in-between bouts of tears, he told them of the attack, the ‘dole money’, and said “it’s been building up over a long period. I just went crazy”. He admitted to disposing of her body and the evidence, but when forensics examined the freezer, his clean-up hadn’t been that thorough, as having made space for her torso by binning several large bags of oven-chips, her blood was found on top of a jumbo box of beef burgers. Both men were arrested, his friend, Douglas was later released without charge, and with the blood a match for Samantha’s, as well as fingerprints and dental records, Colin was charged with her murder. Only his version of events wasn’t as accurate as he had claimed. The autopsy by Pathologist Dr Peter Canezis agreed that she had been beaten over the head with a hammer and stabbed six times with a six-inch blade, but Colin hadn’t done it to protect himself, as with no defensive wounds, the stab wounds were to her back so it’s likely he attacked her as she slept. Committed at Dacorum Magistrates Court, Colin plead guilty to manslaughter by provocation, sticking to his story about ‘dole money’, shame and a 3am attack by Samantha, even though everyone agreed that – as a loyal and dedicated mother and wife - she was quiet, kind, and ‘had the patience of a Saint’. Tried at St Albans Crown Court, although John Lloyd-Eley QC for the Prosecution and Anthony Hopper QC for the Defence put forward both sides of the case, with the evidence overwhelming, on the 9th of December 1988, the jury found him guilty of the murder of his wife, and he was given a life sentence. After 10 years inside, described as a ‘model prisoner’, ‘trustworthy’ and being reduced to Category D, 41-year-old Colin was transferred to Springhill Open Prison in Grendon Underwood. On Sunday the 28th of November 1999, having failed to turn up for 9pm roll call, it was determined he had fled prison, and although it was assumed that he would head to Tring to attempt to see his children, he headed in the opposite direction, and was arrested in Highbury, North London on the 27th of December 1999. Sent back to prison, having served 15 years, it appears that in 2004, he was released and lived in Queen’s Park, in 2013 he moved to Hemel, and with no reported death, his whereabouts are unknown. Although Samantha’s murder was horrific, the forgotten victims in this case were their five children; all were young, all had lost a mum and a dad, and all had their childhood stolen from them for what was said to be £52.59 a week. Tring Community Church held a service for Samantha, funds were raised for her orphaned children with Pastor Ian Walker as trustee, and the children were initially cared for at a community home in St Alban’s. Let’s hope that they found peace, and put this horror in the past. The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of.
Seven time nominated BEST BRITISH TRUE-CRIME PODCAST at the True Crime Awards, Independent Podcast Award and The British Podcast Awards, and voted 4th Best True-Crime Podcast by This Week, iTunes Top 25 Podcast, Podcast Magazine's Hot 50, The Telegraph's Top 5, Crime & Investigation Top 20 True-Crime Podcasts, also seen on BBC Radio, Sky News, The Guardian and TalkRadio's Podcast of the Week.
EPISODE THREE HUNDRED AND SIXTY-FIVE: Thursday the 11th of October 1962 at 4:20pm, off Cherry Lane, in Sipson’s Field in West Drayton, the body of 16 year old Carol Ann White was found; she had been brutally stabbed, but not sexually assaulted. Police believed it was connected to a string of other sex attacks in the area. But the true culprit wasn’t hiding in plain sight, but standing by their side.
SOURCES: a selection sourced from various archives:
Daily Mirror Sat, Feb 02, 1963 The Daily Sketch Thu, Jan 31, 1963 Hull Daily Mail Fri, Oct 12, 1962 The Daily Sketch Wed, Jan 23, 1963 The Daily Telegraph Sat, Dec 01, 1962 Hull Daily Mail Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Evening Standard Wed, Oct 31, 1963 Nottingham Evening News Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Huddersfield Daily Examiner Fri, Oct 12, 1962 The Daily Telegraph Thu, Nov 01, 1962 The Daily Telegraph Thu, Oct 18, 1962 The Daily Telegraph Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Herald Express Fri, Nov 30, 1962 Daily Herald Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Daily Mirror Sat, Dec 01, 1962 Daily Mirror Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Eastern Daily Press Sat, Feb 02, 1963 Evening Post Fri, Oct 12, 1962 The Bolton News Fri, Nov 30, 1962 Daily Herald Sat, Oct 13, 1962 The Guardian Journal Sat, Dec 01, 1962 The Citizen Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Coventry Evening Telegraph Fri, Nov 30, 1962 Evening Standard Fri, Jan 25, 1963 The Daily Telegraph Sat, Feb 02, 1963 The Birmingham Post Sat, Feb 02, 1963 The Guardian Sat, Dec 01, 1962 Daily Post (Merseyside ed.) Wed, Feb 13, 1963 Hull Daily Mail Mon, Oct 15, 1962 Evening Standard Fri, Nov 30, 1962 The Daily Sketch Thu, Nov 01, 1962 Manchester Evening News Tue, Oct 30, 1962 Manchester Evening News Thu, Jan 31, 1963 Nottingham Evening News Mon, Oct 15, 1962 The Argus Tue, Jan 29, 1963 Evening Standard Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Manchester Evening News Fri, Nov 30, 1962 Southern Daily Echo Mon, Oct 15, 1962 Evening Standard Thu, Nov 08, 1962 The Birmingham Post Sat, Oct 13, 1962 The Daily Sketch Mon, Oct 15, 1962 Daily Post (Merseyside ed.) Thu, Nov 01, 1962 Nottingham Evening News Wed, Oct 31, 1962 Evening Chronicle Thu, Jan 31, 1963 Southern Daily Echo Fri, Dec 07, 1962 The Bolton News Fri, Dec 07, 1962 Southern Daily Echo Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Manchester Evening News Wed, Oct 31, 1962 Lancashire Telegraph Fri, Nov 30, 1962 Daily Echo Fri, Dec 07, 1962 Evening Post Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Evening Telegraph Wed, Oct 31, 1962 Scunthorpe Evening Telegraph Fri, Nov 30, 1962 Liverpool Echo Thu, Jan 24, 1963 Manchester Evening News Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Evening Standard Sat, Oct 13, 1962 Western Daily Press Wed, Jan 23, 1963 Hull Daily Mail Fri, Nov 30, 1962 The Argus Fri, Oct 19, 1962 The Guardian Journal Tue, Oct 16, 1962 Daily Mirror Sat, Dec 15, 1962 Evening Standard Mon, Oct 15, 1962 Evening Standard Fri, Dec 14, 1962 Evening Post Thu, Jan 31, 1963 Evening Telegraph Thu, Jan 31, 1963 Evening Telegraph Tue, Jan 29, 1963 Eastern Daily Press Sat, Dec 15, 1962 The Argus Sat, Oct 13, 1962 Evening Post Sat, Oct 13, 1962 Grimsby Evening Telegraph Fri, Oct 12, 1962 Daily Herald Sat, Feb 02, 1963 Evening Telegraph Wed, Oct 31, 1962 Liverpool Echo Fri, Oct 12, 196 Daily Mirror Tue, Oct 16, 1962 The Argus Fri, Nov 30, 1962 Daily Mirror Thu, Nov 01, 1962 Evening Standard Mon, Oct 06, 1958 Daily Mirror Tue, Oct 07, 1958 Daily Mirror Wed, Oct 29, 1958 Daily Herald Fri, Nov 28, 1958 South Wales Argus Fri, Nov 28, 1958 Evening Standard Fri, Nov 28, 1958 The Daily Telegraph Fri, Nov 28, 1958 South Wales Argus Fri, Nov 28, 1958 Daily Herald Sat, Nov 29, 1958 Evening Post Tue, Aug 25, 1981 The Journal Wed, Oct 31, 1962 Evening Post Tue, Aug 25, 1981 Daily Mirror Tue, Oct 07, 1958 Daily Record Wed, Oct 29, 1958 Daily Herald Fri, Nov 28, 1958 Evening Standard Fri, Nov 28, 1958 The Guardian Journal Sat, Nov 29, 1958 MUSIC:
UNEDITED TRANSCRIPT: Welcome to Murder Mile: Unleashed. (Engine) And I’m away. Goodbye London, and hello again, as while I cruise the UK’s canal network in my little boat to bring you true crime cases from the cities, towns and villages I visit, this week, I’m back in West Drayton, Middlesex exploring a case we touched on in Undressing Jack the Stripper. My name is Michael, I am your tour guide, and this is Murder Mile. Episode 365: The Foul Stench of Garlick. Thursday the 11th of October 1962; one week before, The Beatles had released their debut single ‘Love Me Do’, that day the African country of Uganda had gained its independent from the British Empire, and the Cuban Missile Crisis would soon be taking the world to the brink of nuclear Armageddon. The summer was drawing to a close, the sky was cloudy and blue, and the day was warmer than usual. At 4:20pm, having had a nice lunch at his aunt’s house in Harmondsworth, Edward & Barbara, a newly married couple in their 20s and 30s were heading to their home in Princes Park Lane. To the side was Stephen, Edward’s 11-year-old stepson, in a pram was their child, they were walking their landlord’s mongrel dog, Curly, and with it being a long day, they were tired, but still had two more miles to walk. Heading north up the quiet of Cherry Lane, a semi-rural road in West Drayton; with a line of post-war semi-detached houses to the left and to their right running parallel to Sipson’s Road was Sipson’s Farm, a huge field full of foot-high crops, few farm buildings, and surrounded by a thick gorse hedge. Edward recalled, that around 4:20pm, with the traffic busy, he went to put the dog on its lead, but it ran through a gap in the hedge and off into the field. “I called him, but he did not come. He was sniffing around, and I went in after him”. Curly hadn’t gone far, maybe 10 yards at best, but as Edward chased the excitable mutt around, Edward stated “I tripped over something” – something which shocked him. He recalled “I felt sick”. Unable to believe it, he called “Barb! Barb! Come here”, but he couldn’t talk. Barbara said “I saw him come out, he was staggering. He put his arms around me and said ‘Oh God’, I asked him what was the matter and I shook him to wake him out of it, he said ‘Barb’, I found a body”. Barbara checked and it was. Flagging down the first passing car, Frank Squires, a farmer from Old Slade Farm in Iver, Buckinghamshire, saw the body, called the Police, and the crime scene was sealed off. The body was of 16-year-old Carol Ann White. Said to be a shy and timid girl who was the second eldest of nine children to her father James, a crane driver and his wife Irene on nearby East Road, by day she worked at a shop assistant at Woolworths in Yiewsley, in the evening she liked to go to dances, coffee bars, and she was a Sunday school teacher. Being tall and pretty, although said to be ‘reserved’ and ‘bookish’, at the time she was dating 23-year-old Peter Watson of Guildford, who she had met a year before while doing his National Service at RAF Northolt. Everyone who knew them said they were madly in love, with her parents giving their blessing to get married, but they were holding off on getting engaged until Carol’s 17th birthday in January. Her murder shocked her friends, her family, her (soon-to-be) fiancé, and the whole community. Given the sadistic nature of her injuries, Police suspected she had been the victim of a sex attacker, as across that era and in eerily similar ways, the murders of several women and girls had gone unsolved. 14th of September 1954, having attended a party in London’s West End, 21-year-old costumier, Jean Mary Townsend caught the last Central Line tube to South Ruislip. At 11:45pm, she exited the station, walked along Victoria Road, heading to her parent’s home on Bempton Drive, but never arrived. The next day, her body was discovered on the waste ground to the north side of Victoria Road. She had been strangled with her own scarf, and – although partially undressed – there were no signs of rape. 3rd of May 1957, setting off to work at the Nestle factory in Hayes, 35-year-old widowed mother-of-two, Muriel Gwendoline Maitland cycled through an isolated and wooded area in Cranford Park, as she always did. Having failed to arrive, she was reported missing, and beside the River Crane, her body was found concealed in a hollow beneath the roots of a fallen tree. She had been raped and strangled. 25th of August 1958, in her cottage called Dawn Warren on Old Mill Road, Denham, Buckinghamshire, 31-year-old divorced single mother, Joyce Vera Green was attacked in her own bed by a man who had forced his way in. With her seven-year-old son locked in an upstairs cupboard, Joyce was gagged and raped, then strangled. And even though her son had seen her attacker, no-one was ever identified. And finally, on the 28th of October 1960, while walking home from her Girl Guide group in Heston, 12-year-old Brenda Nash went missing. A search was undertaken of all fields, pits and ponds, and after 44 days, her body was found in Hampshire, miles from her home. She was sexually assaulted, strangled and with a second victim stating her attacker had driven a black Vauxhall, 44-year-old Arthur Albert Jones was given a life sentence in June 1961, but continued to profess his innocence, as did his wife. Even though there was no evidence to prove that these cases were connected, as well as others, many believed that they were; as all four victims were accessible to someone with a car, their deaths had hints of sadism and were sexual in nature - like the murder of Carol Ann White, just a few miles away. Her killing terrified every girl in the district of West Drayton. Wednesday 10th of October 1962 was as ordinary as any other day for 16-year-old Carol. She finished work at 5pm, was back in their semi-detached house on East Road on the Bell Farm council estate by 6pm in time for tea, she helped her mother bathe and put to bed the younger of her seven sisters and one brother, and at 8:50pm - dressed in a fashionable green and white blouse, a skirt and white shoes but no coat or hat as the evening was relatively warm and her journey was short - as planned, she left. Being two hours after dusk, although her route – along East Road, down the alley and into Cherry Lane – had limited street lighting, she didn’t need a torch, as she knew this walk well. Crossing a semi-busy street circled by long rows of houses, just before 9pm, she arrived at the phone-box at the top end of Sipson’s Farm, near the corner of Sipson’s Road, and beside the Yiewsley & West Drayton Boys Club. Peter Watson, her boyfriend who lived 26 miles south in Guildford told Police “she was going to ring me to arrange what time she would meet me at the weekend. I was coming to stay with her family… there isn’t a phone in Carol’s house or mine, so we always rang each other from phone boxes. On Wednesday night, I was to phone Carol at the Cherry Lane box at nine o’clock”, but that night, Carol was early, so instead (she did as she done before), she called Alan & Molly Willis, Peter’s neighbours on Yew Tree Drive, who had a home phone and they happily took calls for these two young lovebirds. Peter recalled “while I was on my way to our nearest kiosk, Carol phoned my neighbours”. Molly spoke to Carol, who she said “sounded quite normal”, and she went to fetch Peter. But by 9pm, when Peter dialled West Drayton 4497, “I phoned the Cherry Lane call-box, there was no answer”. The phone just rang and rang. Richard Rogers who ran the boy’s club next door closed up the club at 9pm exactly, and stated, “as I passed, the phone was ringing. There was nobody in sight”. But Carol wasn’t missing… …with the call taking too long, she had run out of money, so by the time Molly had ran back and told her “I’ve got him now”, Carol had hung up. At 9:05pm, he dad, James recalled “She had no money for another call, so she came home”. She took her pink plastic purse, a blue pencil “and went out again”. At 9:13pm, back at the Cherry Lane phone-box, Carol called Peter’s phone-box in Guildford where he had been, but she got no reply. She never made another call, and she was never seen alive again. Carol had vanished. At 10:30pm, growing concerned, her dad, James said “when she hadn’t returned after an hour, I went to look for her. I went down to the phone-box, but there was no sign of Carol. Her pink purse was on the shelf and her blue pencil was on the floor. I got terribly worried then. I started searching the fields”, while her mother put the children to bed and waited at home in case Carol returned. But she didn’t. At midnight, having searched everywhere he could think, he called the Police. Initial thoughts was that she was a runaway or had met a friend, but no-one had seen her. Nothing sinister was suspected as no screams were heard. And with an unnamed woman using the phone at 9:30pm, but no signs of violence or a potential abductor, maybe she had left her purse by mistake, as it only had 5 pence in it. Her disappearance wasn’t reported to the press, and few people talked about it. But all that changed at 4:35pm, when Frank Squires, a passing farmer called the Police, having been alerted to a girl’s dead body in a field at Sipson’s Farm by Edward & Barbara, when their landlord’s dog, Curly had found her. The investigation was headed up by Detective Superintendent Maurice Osborn, who had led the case into the unsolved murder of Muriel Maitland. Surrounding houses were canvassed, but no-one saw or heard anything. At that time of night, Cherry Lane would have been quiet, but not dead, so any passing motorists were questioned, but information was slight. The owner of Sipson’s Farm was quizzed, he heard nothing suspicious, but recalled “I knew Carol, she worked for me for a time last year during her holidays when she was still at school. She would have known the field well”. But why was she here? Between the lane and the field stood a chest-high hedge, over which – as Frank Squires recalled “when the man and woman flagged me down, he said ‘there’s a woman lying dead in that field’. I looked, but could only see material”, possibly her blouse, but when he looked though a larger gap in the hedge, being just 10 yards (roughly 30 feet) away “I saw this young girl lying in the grass, obviously dead”. Edward & Barbara gave statements, as did Mr Squires, and all three were said to be “pretty shook up”. 16-year-old Carol was found on her back, her eyes open, her mouth etched in fear, and in her left hand she held a clump of bracken which she had grasped in her final moments alive. With bruising to her face (as with Muriel’s killer) she had been viciously punched to stop her screaming, a piece of rag had been pushed into her mouth “so firmly, she could not have done it herself”, and then with a six-inch double-edged knife, he had stabbed her seven times; five times to her left lung and once to her heart. The detective’s initial theory was that a serial sex attacker had seen her in the phone-box, pulled up (possibly in a black Vauxhall car which a witness saw parked opposite the phone-box at the time Carol had vanished), threatened her with a knife (hence she left her purse and pencil behind), walked her to his car (but didn’t drag her as her shoes were unblemished), then gagged, raped and murdered her. Her autopsy was conducted by Dr W Evans at Uxbridge Mortuary. Death was caused by asphyxiation owing to the rag in the throat, the repeated stabbing “suggested a sadistic attack”, and yet, none of her clothes were ripped or disarranged, and all the evidence suggested that she hadn’t been raped. Irene, her mother stated “I hope they get this maniac before he kills someone else. The man who killed my Carol must have a mother who knows something. I beg her to give her son up before he kills again”. The search for Carol’s killer was a mammoth undertaking; 1800 people were interviewed, 6000 houses were questioned, officers with dogs, sickles and metal detectors searched every surrounding field for the knife, laundries and drycleaners were asked to be on alert for bloodstained clothes, coffee bars in a five mile radius were quizzed, soil samples were taken, and fingerprints taken from the phone-box. But it all proved negative; the fingerprints were Carol’s, as was the blood, and with no signs that she had been abducted by a stranger, but more likely that she had walked from the phone-box to the field of her own accord, with the pathologist confirming that sex was most likely “consensual”, Police were no longer seeking a serial sex attacker, but someone who Carol knew – a friend, family or a fiancé? This theory was given greater credence when 15-year-old Christopher Denny came forward to report that at roughly 9:30pm, he and two pals cycled down Cherry Lane and saw a girl matching Carol and a man (early 20s, tall, dark-haired) “walking very close together” and entered “the hole in the hedge”. She wasn’t upset, crying, or in fear for her life, in fact, they cycled on, thinking nothing more of it. Said to be a quiet and timid girl who wasn’t going to get engaged until she was 17, the Police drew up a list of the boys she knew, roughly 24, mostly from the Bell Farm estate. Her dad said “she’d never go with any down and outs”, meaning rough looking boys as she was always smartly dressed, but as Peter, her fiancé-to-be would agree in court, when Ashe Lincoln QC said “I am not anxious to blacken Carol’s character, but we know there were other young men besides yourself she was friendly with”, when asked “did she have another boyfriend, and you were annoyed about it?”, he had to agree “yes”. Bill Johnson, a 24-year-old ex-guardsman who owned a black Vauxhall, one of 5000 in Middlesex, came forward and stated that three weeks before, he had met Carol at a fair, “she told me she had a regular boyfriend, she seemed a nice quiet girl, I made a date to meet her on Monday 24th of September, but I forgot all about it. I haven’t seen her since”. Bill Johnson was in the Midlands with friends when Carol was killed, and her boyfriend, Peter was ruled out as a suspect, as he was 26 miles south in Guildford. So, if she had another boyfriend or was open to seeing others, who was he? Those who found her body, although shaken by the sight of her, remained helpful to the investigation, and had their alibis checked; Frank was on his farm in Iver as confirmed by his family, Barbara was at her home in Princes Park Lane 2 and a ½ miles north, and her husband Edward had driven to four different pubs to find a brand of aspirin for her as she had a headache, and said he was home by 10pm. But one of them was unusually helpful, and when Detective Inspector Robert Field cross-referenced Edward’s statement “suspicion fell on him when we did not get truthful answers we put to him”. He said, after Curly the dog ran into Sipson’s field “I went in after him. I tripped over something and I saw the body of a girl”, but both Frank and Barbara said the body was visible from the hole in the hedge. He claimed he had to driven to four pubs to find aspirin, but the two he had said didn’t stock it, did, and they didn’t recall seeing him that night. He also said he owned a six-inch double-edged knife, but couldn’t recall where it was. He drove a black Vauxhall, like the one seen near the phone-box on the night Carol was murdered, but denied being anywhere near Cherry Lane. And yet, Winifred Coleman, who knew him, saw Edward at 10:25pm in nearby Goulds Green, when he was supposedly at home. The more he lied, the more he became a suspect… and then, Police looked into his past. Questioned at Harlington Police Station, Edward said “I never went into Cherry Lane that night. It was not me who attacked the girl. I am willing for the police to take my blood to prove my innocence”, but worried, he continued, “If you find blood on my clothes, you and everyone will say I’m a liar”. His new statement was written-up and presented to him, but he refused to sign it until he’d spoken to his wife. His name was Edward Garlick… and as his name suggests, his past had a foul stench. Born on the 30th of July 1937 in Staines, Middlesex, 25-year-old Edward Donald Garlick was a tall, dark-haired and handsome young man, said to be the only child of elderly parents. Little was reported about his upbringing, but in 1957, aged 20, he met 18-year-old Wendy June Hornblow of nearby Hanworth. Her mother Nancy recalled, “I disliked him the first time I saw him. He had some sort of terrible hold over Wendy. We rowed about him keeping her out late”, as with Wendy having to walk home alone by Bluebell Woods where Muriel Maitland was murdered, “we were only anxious about her safety”. Arguments flared, tears flowed, “we refused to give her our consent to marry”, so Wendy left home, and on Boxing Day 1957, Wendy married Edward Garlick, and her parents were not invited. Nancy said “we were willing to forgive and forget, but Wendy couldn’t… I only saw her once more, as I passed her in the street. Wendy didn’t look at me, I suppose she was too proud or ashamed of us to help her”. Times were hard, debts had piled up, many of their possessions were paid for by hire purchase, and with Wendy & Edward Garlick living in a caravan, even this was reclaimed by the finance company. In September 1958, nine months into their marriage, they were living in a grotty, two-roomed flat on Mosslea Road in Penge, South London for of £4 a week. Edward Garlick said “it was all we could get”. Phylis Stoneman, their landlady said “they were very quiet people, and appeared to be very much in love”, but were so broke, that when he lost his job as a plaster moulder, she helped them out with money and food. He also claimed, “Wendy suggested she should go to Piccadilly, go with some men and get money”, implying prostitution, “she went to Piccadilly twice and got about £1 30s”, about £60. On the morning of Saturday 27th of September 1958, Phylis handed him a bill for £9, 5s and 3d (£350) for two weeks rent and milk, which had to be paid by the following morning. Garlick said “we walked to Hyde Park Corner, where I stood around while she waited for men. But she didn’t not earn any. It was no good”, and as they walked the 10 miles back home, he recalled “I said ‘I am fed up with this. How about suicide?’ Wendy said she did not feel like living, and said ‘if you want to do it, then do it’. That night, as they sat in the kitchen, he taped up the doors and windows, put three sixpences in the meter, left a note for their landlady stating “we are very sorry for the trouble we have caused you. This is the only way out. We have no money”, and turned on the gas. Or so, Edward Garlick would say. Garlick said “Wendy said she did not like the smell of gas. We struggled. I think she banged her head on the floor”, but also said “there was a struggle in which I hit the wife. I got a knife and I tried to get off the tape I had stuck round the door off… I fell back unconscious. It was the last think I remember”. Smelling the sulphurous stench of gas, and hearing groans, Phylis called the Police. Wendy was dead by the time the ambulance arrived, but taken to Beckenham Hospital, Garlick remained unconscious for four days, and when he was fit enough to be questioned, he was charged with his wife’s murder. Tried at Maidstone Assizes, the pathologist Dr Francis Camps stated that although Wendy had died of coal gas poisoning, with Edward also suffering the effects, his memory could not be relied upon as the sole witness, and the medical evidence suggested there were no signs of a struggle, violence or force. 21-year-old Edward Garlick was acquitted of Wendy’s murder but found guilty of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility, with it said she had died by suicide pact. Justice Slade stated “it is clear you have suffered enough, I sentence you to three years probation on the condition you spend a year in a mental hospital”. He spent five months on a psychiatric ward, before he was paroled. Nancy told the press “until the day I die, I will never believe that Wendy wanted to kill herself”, and told the Police, “he forced my Wendy into her grave, he is a menace to women… he will kill again…” …and she was right. In 1959 he was released, in 1961 he married Barbara Barham, a 30 year old mother of two with an 11 year old son, Stephen, and they had a child of their own. He got a job as a storeman, a black Vauxhall car, and they lived in a council house in Princes Park Lane, two and a half miles north of Cherry Lane. Garlick later confessed, in March 1962, “I met the girl about seven months ago at a bus stop. I offered her a lift. Because of that, we arranged to meet at the weekend”, even though in his earlier statement he said “I had never seen her before I found the body”. He didn’t say if they were dating or just friendly. On the night of her killing, he implied that their encounter was entirely coincidental, Garlick stated “I met her by the phone-box, we saw each other at the same time… she came dashing out to speak to me… we chatted… and I asked her for a light for my fags… I then said ‘what about coming for a walk’”, a phrase many people took to mean ‘having sex’, “and she said she knew a place up the road”. According to Garlick, she walked of her own accord, accidentally left behind her purse and pencil, his car was parked by the phone-box and a short walk down Cherry Lane, they entered a hole in the hedge. He claimed at some point “I showed her my knife, she was not frightened, and put it in her handbag”, which makes no sense either way. He then said that they had consensual sex, which the autopsy would clarify, as she had no restraint marks, torn clothes or vaginal tears, just dry soil on her blouse and skirt. Garlick claimed, this is when the mood shifted. After sex, “she said I needed more practice”, a barbed comment which impugned his masculinity, they then spoke about girls who scream during sex, and he said “the girl said ‘have you got anything to put in my mouth to show that I am not one of those… and put it in her mouth”, but the autopsy stated “it was so firmly pushed in, she could not have done it”. Bafflingly, according to his statement, “when she was straightening herself, she used the handbag and gave my knife back. I then went mad. I got my knife in my hand and pushed it into her. I don’t know how many times I stabbed her”, and having brutally butchered her, he drove back to his family. That night he returned home about 11pm, an hour later than he stated, and with no aspirins. Barbara recalled, “his left hand was bleeding, he said he had cut it on a fence, he was cheerful and joking about it”, and although he claimed that the guilt tormented him, his morbid curiosity was to be his undoing. The next day, with nothing on the radio or the papers, he said “I asked myself ‘did I really do it’?”. Having had lunch at his Aunt Alice’s in Harmondsworth, with his wife, step-son and new baby in tow, he deliberately walked them the four mile journey home, going the long way round along Cherry Lane. When he arrived at the hole in the hedge, there were no Police officers, just cars passing obliviously. He claimed the dog ran in, but that was disputed. He said he couldn’t see the body until he had tripped over it, but Frank Squires had seen it from the road. And according to Barbara, his wife, she said “he ran in and called ‘Barb! Barb! Come here’. I saw him come out of the field and he was staggering. He came over to me and put his arms around me and his head on my shoulder and said ‘Oh God’, I asked him what was the matter and I shook him and he said ‘Barb’, I found a body. I’m not sure whether I did it or not’. I replied ‘I will go into the field with you and if I see it, you will know you did. I left the babies, went into the field with him, and I saw her. I told him ‘we can’t leave her there. We will have to get help in some way’”. And with the farmer being the next car to pass, the Police were notified. Questioned at Harlington Police Station, when Barbara arrived at 3am, with tears in her eyes, instantly she asked ‘did you do it?’, he hugged her, and crying said ‘yes, I did’. As with the death of his first wife, Garlick said “I’ll only spend a year in a mental home, wait for me?’”, she said “‘I’ll wait for you forever”. Charged on the 30th of October 1962, he showed the police how he had killed her, he led them to the knife which he had hidden in his back garden, and said “I never thought you would think I did it. I tried to forget about it, but I can’t. If I tell you all about it, perhaps it will help me to forget”, but he wouldn’t. Tried at the Old Bailey before Mr Justice Paull, Edward Garlick tried to have his detailed confession of how he had murdered Carol Ann White retracted to “protect his wife and children from the details”. He stated he only made a false statement as he was worried that his wife and eldest stepson would be implicated as accessories after the fact. He pled ‘not guilty’ to murder, and given his prior conviction and brief stint in a psychiatric hospital, he pled guilty to manslaughter by diminished responsibility. But the jury were not buying it. On the 1st of February 1963, having deliberated for 75 minutes, they found him guilty of Carol Ann White‘s wilful murder, and Justice Paull sentenced him to life in prison. He appealed his sentence just 13 days later, but this was rejected, as were all subsequent appeals. By 1981, having served 18 years, being of good character, 44-year-old Edward Garlick was transferred to HMP Leyhill, an open prison in Gloucestershire. On the 25th of August 1981, having been on home leave to visit his parents in Ramsgate, failing to return to prison, at 4:15am, a grisly discovery was made in a tunnel on the Bristol to Paddington line – his decapitated body, having taken his own life. He had murdered Carol, and possibly his first wife, but had he killed others and taken this to his grave. The Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast has been researched using the original declassified police investigation files, court records, press reports and as many authentic sources as possible, which are freely available in the public domain, including eye-witness testimony, confessions, autopsy reports, first-hand accounts and independent investigation, where possible. But these documents are only as accurate as those recounting them and recording them, and are always incomplete or full of opinion rather than fact, therefore mistakes and misrepresentations can be made. As stated at the beginning of each episode (and as is clear by the way it is presented) Murder Mile UK True Crime Podcast is a 'dramatisation' of the events and not a documentary, therefore a certain amount of dramatic licence, selective characterisation and story-telling (within logical reason and based on extensive research) has been taken to create a fuller picture. It is not a full and complete representation of the case, the people or the investigation, and therefore should not be taken as such. It is also often (for the sake of clarity, speed and the drama) presented from a single person's perspective, usually (but not exclusively) the victim's, and therefore it will contain a certain level of bias and opinion to get across this single perspective, which may not be the overall opinion of those involved or associated. Murder Mile is just one possible retelling of each case. Murder Mile does not set out to cause any harm or distress to those involved, and those who listen to the podcast or read the transcripts provided should be aware that by accessing anything created by Murder Mile (or any source related to any each) that they may discover some details about a person, an incident or the police investigation itself, that they were unaware of. |
AuthorMichael J Buchanan-Dunne is a crime writer, podcaster of Murder Mile UK True Crime and creator of true-crime TV series. Archives
November 2026
Subscribe to the Murder Mile true-crime podcast
Categories
All
Note: This blog contains only licence-free images or photos shot by myself in compliance with UK & EU copyright laws. If any image breaches these laws, blame Google Images.
|











